Thursday, September 15, 2011

If I Were A Character From Pop Culture...

...who would I be?

I'm a science/math nerd who is constantly struggling with issues of ethics and morals, rights and responsibilities and guilty feelings whether they're earned or not.  I tend to be more satisfied when I solve a problem with wit or creativity than with brawn or elbow grease.  I'm pretty much always having girl trouble.  I'm often a wise cracking big mouth who doesn't know when to shut up (is now a good time?), especially during times of stress.  I'm forever misunderstood with people assigning foul motives to the most innocently intended thoughts, words & deeds.

Who am I?

Monday, September 12, 2011

Unhappy Feet: Penguin Goes Poof

[Author's note:  Those that know me will immediately know and understand how difficult it was for me to write this blog.  For those that don't yet know me, I have had an affinity for penguins since before I could walk.  My first penguin was probably a floaty soap dish named "Perry the Penguin", I think it was also a squeak toy, (kitsch from the late 1960s) and they have populated my life ever since; from plush toys to key chains to shower curtains to swizzle sticks and all points between.  I guess the technical term is having a penguin fetish.]

Happy Feet, the wayward emperor penguin, has disappeared from satellite tracking.

Happy Feet was discovered June 21st on Peka Peka Beach in New Zealand.  It was only the second sighting of an emperor penguin in New Zealand, the last sighting having been in 1967, but not nearly as far north.  I've been monitoring his progress ever since.  It has been easy as the authorities in the area have kept the Internet informed.

At first he didn't seem to be in distress, but neither did he return to the sea to go home to Antarctica.  He began eating sand, which seems to have been displaced behaviour -- penguins eat snow in order to cool off.  Four days after he beached, this errant behaviour resulted in New Zealand zoo authorities taking the penguin into custody/care and ultimately to performing 3 surgeries to remove the glut of sand and stones from his digestive tract.  He pulled through this difficult time and began to thrive in captivity.

But captivity was never in the cards for Happy Feet.  The plan all along was to release him back into the wild so he could return to his natural habitat, Antarctica and the Southern Sea.  To that end, Happy Feet was fitted with a very small satellite transmitter.  It represented less than 1% of his body mass.  It was affixed with glue on feathers that would be shed in moulting in the summer (Northern Hemisphere's winter).  Further, it was attached in a fashion so as to minimize the impact on his swimming.

On September 4th, after 72 days in Kiwi care, Happy Feet was released into the sea about 80km north of Campbell Island, which is the southernmost New Zealand territory.  To get home in an ideal fashion, he would have to get around Campbell Island, preferably going around the western coast, and travel roughly SSW to Antarctica.

Things went wrong almost from the get go.  (You could say that things went wrong before the get go -- Happy Feet's launch was delayed two days due to inclement weather.)  Happy Feet seemed to be on a fairly consistent SE track.  If you factor in the effort fighting strong eastbound ocean currents, Happy Feet was trying to swim SSE.  So his sense of direction didn't seem to be as bad as it had been when he found himself at Peka Peka in the first place.  While he would still reach Antarctica this way -- you cannot have a southerly component to your travel and not eventually reach Antarctica -- but it would be on a coastline possibly as far as 180° removed from where he originated.  This isn't tragic.  As long as there are emperor penguin rookeries where he alights he'll be fine and while the trajectory was not the most direct, Happy Feet had plenty of time to get where he was going.

Four days after his return journey started Happy Feet disappeared from satellite imagery.  All this technically means is that the transmitter hasn't stayed above the ocean surface for at least 3 consecutive minutes during the 7-hour window that it is powered daily.  (Another very unlikely possibility is that the battery or transmitter itself was damaged and has ceased functioning.)  Emperor penguins are thought to dive for no more than 20 minutes before surfacing to breathe, so that can't explain the 7-hour absence.  It takes at least 4 'pings' to the satellite for the tracking software to acknowledge a location.  Is it possible that between hyperactive solar flares and equipment on the fritz that a 3-ping (or less) presence has been registered, but been discarded as unreliable noise?  Could the super-glue and cabling used to affix the transmitter to Happy Feet's back have failed and he is presently continuing his journey home free of prying eyes?  Does it have to be the most tragic of circumstances, namely that Happy Feet has been eaten or drowned due to injury?

We may never know.

If this is a worst case scenario, it is one of those ironic, cartoon moments that flash through our heads from time to time.  Scenario 1:  A boy catches a fish and is lectured by his father about nature conservancy in sport fishing and is encouraged to unhook the fish and return it to the water.  He does so, feeling proud for having learned to respect God's creatures.  The 'camera' follows the arc of the fish as it returns to the water, and captures the image of a predator leaping from the water to gobble up the fish before it even hits the drink.  Scenario 2:  A fawn is collected after its mother was killed by a hunter.  It is sent to an animal rescue centre to be raised and prepared for a return to the wild.  Fast forward to 'graduation' day when the fawn, now a buck, is released into the wild...and, courtesy of a head-bobbing driver of an 18-wheeler, dies less than an hour later crossing a highway, possibly trying to make his way back to the animal rescue centre.  We can also try to help settle our nerves by cracking wise that this is what happens to 'pets' when you name them "Happy"-anything.  In any case, back to the real world...

Critics can point to the fact that Happy Feet was given a very long journey to complete on his own when he could have been given a shorter, more direct route home, for example, in deeper waters SW of Campbell Island.  I was certainly one of those that was alarmed when I heard where he was being released.  I wish my alarm had been misguided.  Still, no matter where he was released, Happy Feet would have had to deal with predators, elusive food supplies, strong ocean currents and his own wonky sense of direction.  There are no guarantees in life, but it is also natural to question "what if?", especially when things go awry.

At this point what we have left is mystery and hope.

It is remotely possible that rapid, staccato diving kept Happy Feet's transmitter from sending 4 consecutive signals to the satellite, and he is totally fine.

It is also possible that we may encounter Happy Feet again, if and only if he arrives at a monitored emperor penguin rookery.  You see, he had more than a transmitter on board.  He also had a sub-dermal microchip inserted in his thigh and will be recognized if encountered again.

Also, just because no one is there to tell of the happy ending doesn't mean there won't be one.  Happy Feet could return to the life he had before he washed up at Peka Peka, namely being just one of a quarter-million emperor penguins living in the wild.  He could end up at an unmonitored emperor penguin rookery and live a long life producing many offspring and we'll never know.

So, in the absence of further specific information, it comes down to a matter of choice.

You can despair and choose to believe that Happy Feet succumbed to Nature, and found his place in the Circle of Life (prey/food).  One might say it is the karmic end to a bird with such a poor sense of direction.

Or, you can hope and choose to have faith or believe that he is alive and well, living the life of an emperor penguin without the taint of human influence or observation, perhaps as God intended -- a true return to Nature.

What will your choice be?

I'm fairly certain that Happy Feet's story will be made into a children's book.  I hope I'm the one they tap on the shoulder for that task.

For additional information...

Colin Miskelly's blog

Satellite updates of Happy Feet (hopefully)

Wellington (NZ) Zoo (the people that took care of Happy Feet)

Sunday, September 11, 2011

Doug Ford's Secret Monorail Research Revealed


Maybe we can steal the ferris wheel from Chicago's Navy Pier.  That'll save money, for more monorail!

The Fords Are Picture Prefect

For the past year, the chief darlings and demons of Toronto politics have to be the Ford brothers, Rob and Doug.  The best part about them is that they seem to lampoon themselves.  The worst part about them is that they have been granted the authority of office.  How the heck did that happen?

Anyway, I expect I'll be talking about them a whole lot these next few years.  I foresee a problem with that.  "The Fords" and "The Ford brothers" are just too boring as far as appellations for colourful people go.  There has to be something more, interesting, more sardonic, funnier...  Well, I've got some suggestions.  I'm not sure how I feel about each of them, so I'm going to have to rely on you to tell which ones work and which ones don't.

  1. Bob and Doug, or Bob and Doug McKenzie.  There's nothing like invoking pop culture and classic Canadiana when being silly.  And judging from history they love to be silly.

  2. Blob and Slug Ford.  Come on!  Fat jokes are the last socially acceptable form of discrimination!  For a little while longer at least.  Then we'll remember that we are Canadian and above such baseness.

  3. Rube and Dung Ford.  Earthy names for salt of the earth personalities.

  4. Rob & Doug Fjord.  Given the recent focus on creating islands for football stadia and remaking the waterfront in their image, a waterway-related name could be appropriate.  (Of course, 'ford' is itself kind of a waterway term.)  Besides, with their fair complexion they could be mistaken for Norwegian/Nordic.

  5. The F5 Fords.  This one is a little more abstract.  If you asked them, they would probably say it referred to the 1940s - 1950s era model of flatbed truck.  The previously alluded to Ford Prefect was contemporaneous to the F5.  Is that it then?  Is that the joke?  Why would we want to compare them to an ancient motor vehicle?

    Nope, that's not it.  I'm referring to the Fujita scale of tornado intensity.  Tornadoes are very unpredictable storms.  F5's blow the hardest and are the most destructive, damaging even the sturdiest infrastructure, and are known for consuming nearly everything in their path.  Yeah, I like this one.  It's a literal and alliterative.

  6. Mayor McCheese and Hamburglar.  Is this too old school?  Too trademarked by McDonalds?

  7. Tweedledee & Tweedledum.  If Tweedledum wouldn't recognize Margaret Atwood should she walk by him on the street, neither of them should recognize Lewis Carroll no matter where they encounter him.  They might react, though. They might scream, "Zombie!" or, if they had just watched the right movie, "Hey look, it's Bernie!"  I wonder if they would recognize the Jabberwocky, Cheshire Cat, March Hare, Mad Hatter, etc., etc. Oh right!  It was a Disney film!  Of course they'll recognize the characters!  But who the hell is Lewis Carroll?  The director?  Cinematographer?  Lead animator?  Did he write the Narnia books?  Are you making fun of us? OFF WITH HIS HEAD!

  8. Thing 1 & Thing 2.  With apologies to the great Theodor S. Giesel, the incomparable Dr. Seuss!  Hopefully, he, his estate and its litany of lawyers won't mind if I both quote him and channel his voice for a moment.  (Saying what you want to say, while sticking to a mostly monosyllabic lexicon, and keeping to anapestic tetrameter is HARD!  No wonder it took Dr. Seuss 9 months to write The Cat In The Hat!  Sometimes, though, I wonder if this is the only way to reach the dull, the distant, the dreamy and the disinterested.)

    ("¬" denotes an unstressed/unused beat -- or pause -- in the meter.  Also, I've stressed the beats to make it easier to read in the sing-song meter.)

    "UNLESS someone like you cares a whole awful lot,
    ¬ nothing is going to get better. It’s not."
    (Dr. Seuss, from The Lorax)


    "If you lend us your ears, you will see we're not quacks,"
    "We know what we must do in pursuit of No-Tax."

    ¬ "What we know is business," said One to Thing Two
    "And you must run your city as business men do."

    ¬ "So what of the poor?" asked a Who from the back.
    "Well the poor just don't matter, we must stay on track."

    "We're concerned with the health of the economy."
    "And the poor only want what they can get for free."

    "We should only keep doing that which we do best."
    ¬ "We must be ef-fic-ient -- forget all the rest."

    "So we'll cut out on buses and library books."
    ¬ "Now why are you giving us those dirty looks?"

         { Time out.  I just answered the phone and it was an automated poll seeking opinions regarding the Mayor's general approval rating one year after the election... Rolling on the floor, pissing myself, laughing my a** off.  Delicious irony!  Life is too funny.  And now back to the Seussisms. }

    "And our lake shore is lacking, but don't think it through"
    ¬ "We'll fix it by building a big wheel or two."

    "Man-made islands are needed where we'll build a park."
    "And to get people to it we'll build a new ark."

    ""Stop right there", said a Who, "Is this some kind of stunt?"
    "Sit back down and be silent you miserable runt!"

    "You elected me mayor, with Thing Two, can't you see?"
    "We are try'n to establish our own legacy!"

    ¬ "Then why not commission a statue of you?"
    "Give the seagulls and pigeons a new place to poo."

    "You may laugh, you may joke, but we're the ones in charge."
    "So expect we'll embrace it and keep living large."

    "In this time of restraint I've one more thing to say,"
    "We will pay to kill bike lanes, make them go away."

    ¬ From reading this poem, you should take away,
    ¬ A moral that's simple, and as plain as day,
    ¬ Be careful to whom you give your right of voice,
    Lots of time and much thought should go into that choice.
    If it's done, and it's gone to a Dimwit or Sot,
    ¬ Well, don't be surprised when things all go to pot.

  9. Who knows, maybe I'll come up with more soon.  Maybe you'll suggest your own.  I'm sure the words and actions of the Fords will suggest -- nay, inspire -- more material in due time.

MLS Is Unwatchable

Date of composition: Saturday, September 10th, 2011

I've had enough.  I can't take any more -- not a match, not a half, not even a moment of extra time.  MSL soccer is absolutely unwatchable, or in my case, as a radio listener, unlistenable.  (Why isn't there a sound-based word analogous to the sight-based word 'unwatchable'?)

The players are as much actors as athletes, flopping around like fish out of water, hoping to draw a Yellow, or better yet a Red, against the opponent.  I am philosophically opposed to the concept of 'gamesmanship'.  In my view, gamesmanship is the polar opposite of sportsmanship, which is a quality to which we all aspire and attempt to instill in our children.  Gamesmanship is bending the rules of conduct and play as far as they can be bent without breaking completely and being unilaterally labelled as cheating.  Even as it is, there are those that label gamesmanship as cheating, at least in spirit.

As bad as the gamesmanship is the quality of officiating.  Referees and linesmen routinely make calls that defy the rules, show obvious biases, make calls that can best be described as imaginary and ignore calls that are flagrant, obvious and right in front of their noses.  Are blindness and bias prerequisites for employment?  At this point I wouldn't be surprised if a player somehow produced a sword from his uniform, beheaded an opponent, fell down holding his own head as though it were about to explode and successfully induced the referee to give a red card to the completely innocent and now lifeless corpse while the equally lifeless head rolls slowly offside.  Whatever.  You're a man down in every sense of the word now.

The league nominally admits that there are deficiencies in officiating but doesn't seem especially motivated to do anything about it.  They are a relatively minor league regardless of the fact that the 'M' in MLS stands for "Major".  When they look to hire officials they have two constraints.  First, they can only hire whomever is left after the real major soccer -- I mean football -- leagues have hired their officials.  Second, they can only hire whomever they can afford, which seems to indicate scraping the bottom of the barrel.  Financially, they may not be in a position to address the issue at all.

Some would say that the problem is bigger than MLS, and they are probably right.  Officials in FIFA matches frequently manage to look remarkably amateurish and occasionally quite one-sided.  Bias is rampant in soccer/football and for lots of reasons.

  1. In some cases, the officials have an interest in who wins the game through their own national allegiances and who plays whom when to qualify for what.
  2. In others, it is in the best interests of the officials to rule in favor of the local team, some times for fear of personal safety from the hands of the fans.  (To a degree this seems to happen in New Yankee Stadium during baseball games, so the problem is not limited to European and Latin American football teams.)
  3. The third reason is the most controversial of all -- officials get bribed.  Some countries are worse than others but it has been proven to happen.  With the stink of corruption going all the way up to the highest positions in FIFA -- some would say that's where it starts -- it is not surprising that the allegations keep coming yet the problem is allowed to persist.

So, I'm out.  I never turn off my radio and seldom change the station, but I'll be doing so every single time they try to ram an MLS game down my throat.

While I'm here, I'll take a tangent and criticize the world, especially the United States, for what amounts to a dispute over terminology.

"Football A" is a game played with a round ball by two teams of eleven players a side.  The ball is advanced almost exclusively with the feet (hence the name football) with rare aerial contact permitted with the head and torso.  The point is to advance the ball into the opponents goal.  The sport has existed in some form for thousands of years but was only officially codified in 1863.  It is played by an estimated 250 million people in 200 countries making it the world's most popular sport.

"Football B" is a game played with an oblong ball by two teams of eleven players a side.  The ball is advanced by carrying it manually or throwing it to another player.  Again, the point is to advance the ball into the opponent's goal.  If progress is halted by the opposing defense the team on offense may kick the ball for points, or kick the ball for field position.  There is even a special version of kick that can result in maintaining possession of the ball.  Football B was first played in 1869 and is generally accepted to be derivative of football A (see above) and rugby.  The sport is played almost exclusively in the United States and (in slightly altered form) in Canada.

So, what do we have here?  Quite a predicament.  Two sports that want to be known by the same name, without qualifiers. How do we decide which one gets to determine its own name and which must choose another name?

Let us compare...

Played most widely: Football A.

Most players: Football A. There are probably more children playing Football A than people playing that other game.

Older: Football A.

Actually uses the foot as the primary instrument of play: Football A.

Okay, it seems quite clear: Football A gets to call itself "Football" and Football B has to choose something else. American Rules Football, American Rules Rugby and Gridiron seem like good choices.

Somebody please explain to me why the f**k it doesn't work this way!!!!!!

Obviously, Football A has been relegated to being known as "soccer" (an 1880 Oxford-er abbreviation of "association", i.e."soc-er") in the one part of the world where Football B is played, and Football B is globally known as Football.  Well, it's "American Football" in some circles, but the international branding is simply as "Football".

Americans generally don't understand why their great country is maligned and poo-pooed by foreigners, even allies, in spite of its greatness.  Frankly, it's totally trivial s**t like this that prompts the 'outside' world to have a distasteful opinion of America.  Always 'having things their way' even when it isn't 'right'.  Feels like bullying, smells like bullying.  And everybody loves a bully.  The little things add up and matter.

Yaroslavl Lokomotiv Disaster & the KHL

Date of composition: Friday September 9th, 2011

A tragedy that some say was inevitable happened two days ago when a chartered Russian jet crashed shortly after take-off.  The plane was transporting the Lokomotiv Yaroslavl KHL hockey team to play the first game of the season.  All but 2 of the passengers and crew perished in the crash, 1 passenger and 1 crew member,  There is little to any chance that the athlete survivor will ever play competitive hockey again given third-degree burns over the majority of his body, including internal respiratory damage.

It is widely known that the jets chartered by the various KHL franchises are of insufficient quality to be permitted to fly European Union air space, so they can only be used for flights within Russia.  Current and former KHL players and coaches have spoken out about their concern for the safety of these vehicles. But one can only charter whatever planes are available, and the fleet available is lacking.  Hence the view that this was inevitable.  But it is what it is.  It will be interesting to see if authorities move to remedy the situation.  Finding newer, safer planes is not cheap nor is it easy, and most unfortunately is an awfully time-dependent process.

Lokomotiv Yaroslavl, for intents and purposes, lost their entire team.  The fans and citizens of Yaroslavl have lost their heroes and role models.

The president of the KHL announced that the remaining franchises will be encouraged to give two to three players to Lokomotiv in order for them to field a team.  This offer wasn't nearly good enough.  The proposed player exchange would likely have given Yaroslavl twelve 4th-line forwards, seven 3rd-pair defencemen and a couple of strictly back-up goalies.  (It is also possible that one or more of the franchises would offer more highly skilled but grossly overpaid players, which doesn't help a team in crisis either.)  There was no chance of them competing favorably, and the people of Yaroslavl don't need the burden of a loser for an entire season.  They've been through enough.  All this would really do is allow the KHL to maintain the integrity of its schedule and fulfill obligations to Russian television and radio networks.  In other words, it wasn't a charitable or generous offer, if was a act of self-interest.

I don't think anyone will be surprised when Yaroslavl turns down this 'generous' offer.  The fans would be getting sub-standard levels of play, played by athletes with whom they have no emotional or civic relationships.  The games wouldn't be celebrations of hockey and wouldn't provide any consolation to a grieving city.  Yaroslavl needs time to mourn, to accept and to move on and the only way they will achieve this is with a year off from competition.  After all, professional hockey is a form of entertainment, a distraction, and ultimately a game played by grownups.  It just does not compare in any way to the tragic loss of life that occurred nor could hockey ever compensate for the aftermath of the disaster.

Give them love, give them support, and give them understanding, but give them time to be alone in their grief and decide where and/or how they will proceed for next year.  It wouldn't hurt if the KHL made a better offer, either.

[Editors note, Sept. 10th, 2011: Yaroslavl did in fact reject the offer of replacement players and opted out of the 2011-2012 KHL season.]

[Editors note, Sept. 12th, 2011: The one player who survived the initial trauma of the plane crash, Alexander Galimov, succumbed to his injuries today in hospital.  Unfortunately, given the severity of his wounds this was the expected outcome.  Galimov was a Yaroslavl native son and his passing may hurt the troubled city more than that of any of the others.  Our continued sympathy to the families of the deceased, the people of Yaroslavl, and the Lokomotiv organization.]

[Editors note, Sept. 12th, 2011:  In my humble opinion another blow was struck today against the grieving people of Yaroslavl.  The president of the KHL today announced that Lokomotiv Yaroslavl will be relegated to a lower league to allow them to 'grow' from scratch.  There was no guarantee made that the team will be reinstated to the KHL by some future date.  In fact, there were no guarantees at all.  So, on top of all the trauma received by Yaroslavl they now have insult to add to the injury -- they will not have a major league franchise to look forward to...indefinitely.  Is this really the best that the KHL could do?  If it really is I believe there are only two possible conclusions to be made.  1. The owners of the other franchises are greedy, unsympathetic machines for rejecting or possibly never even suggesting a better solution.  2. The KHL is only a self-described major league; in other words, it is not a major league in any real sense of the word.  The word "bush" comes to mind.  Shame, shame.]

9/11: Ten Years After

Wow.  What a conspicuous day to start submitting blogs.

I've made my decision.  I've decided I'm not going to opine at length or in detail on 9/11, its 10th anniversary.  or any of the events that resulted from, or are rooted in, the tragedy ten years ago.  (After reading this, you may ask yourself, "This is what he calls not opining at length?"  My response: yes, for a topic this enormous I've barely scratched the surface!)  I will ask questions; I think we should all be asking questions.

Why?  Good question!  We're off to a good start!  The 9/11 10th anniversary would seem to be exactly the kind of topic to be given serious and detailed attention in this forum.

But it isn't.  Not even close.

It's too big.  The forces behind it are perhaps still the greatest threats to our way of life.

It's too current, and it always will be.

It's too controversial -- on all sides.  Believe it or not, in some parts of the world the 19 men -- call them men, demons, devils, killers, murderers, deranged, deluded or misguided souls, hate mongers, war criminals, martyrs, zealots, soldiers, patriots, or whatever else you want to call them, and please do feel free to use profanity here -- who perpetrated the 9/11 attacks are heroes.  Thank God -- the very same God that some believe authorized and condoned these attacks -- that the majority of humanity deems the emergency responders -- those that survived and those that did not -- the citizens aboard American Airlines Flight 93 and all the other innocent victims of the attacks the true heroes.  It's worth noting here that to those most sympathetic to the terrorists' cause, we don't worship the same god.  In their view, 'they' worship God, 'we' (the Judeo-Christian West) worship Satan.  If there is anything more frightening and dangerous than a Fundamentalist religion, it's a revisionist-history religion -- once that line is crossed they can, and apparently will, justify anything!

It touches too many raw nerves -- nerves that may never heal.  There are widows, widowers, orphans, parents, siblings and friends that will never be the same.  There are zealots still that wish the worst forms of harm to come to all the infidel Westerners of the world, even if the cost is the destruction of the planet*; their cause is unfulfilled.  There are too many open, ongoing questions and, really, nothing has been resolved.

* This is in direct conflict with the tenets of Islam which is actually the most ecologically harmonious of Western religions.

Was the act reprehensible?  Absolutely!  It compares fiendishly with the genocide and "ethnic cleansing" of the past century, in Europe (including the systematic and cruel extermination of Jews, Roma and Catholics during WWII), Africa (disturbingly ongoing and uncurbed) and Armenia, and the deployment of nuclear weapons upon Hiroshima and Nagasaki.  (Yes, it can be argued that the bombing of Japan's cities ultimately saved lives by ending the the Pacific Theater of WWII sooner, but this kind of argument requires guesswork as to when the war would have ended without the atrocities.  The real truth here is that American (Allied) lives were saved, and that is all that a nation needs to know in order to act in its own best, self-interest.  Overall, we don't know that lives were saved, we just reassure ourselves that they were in order to sleep better at night in a very scary and complicated world.)  At times, thinking about any of these events brings me to tears, as well as to the brink of rage and breakdown.  How are we as a species capable of such evil, and how do people commit such acts so cavalierly, even righteously!?

Was the reaction to 9/11 any better than the action?  I'm not sure.  I daresay most who think about it rather than merely feel about it aren't sure.  Were there any other reasonable courses of action?  Maybe.  It might be more accurate to say "probably."  Would we be better off had we followed another path?  Maybe, but we'll never know.  We don't get to explore that branch of history or probability.

I'm fairly certain that at least one reader will take a dive off the deep end, and read between lines that simply aren't there and will take my words as a sign that I do not support our troops.  To them I say, "Poppycock!"  I support our troops.  They are people that put their lives on the line in hope of promoting and protecting their, and our, ideals!  I support the cause.  I even support the main intentions behind their deployment.  But ten years later it is clearer than ever that the issues were too complex, too multinational, too multicultural and too socio-economical to rationally think that a military solution existed.  To those that point at the state of the world today and say the troops failed, I say, "How?"  There was nothing for them to fail at!  They succeeded at doing all the things that soldiers are reasonably capable of doing and should never have been asked to do things that they weren't suited to do.  (If you force your gardener to remove your cancerous tumour and you die on the table it's not your gardener's fault!)  You say they failed, I say they tried to exceed themselves and in some small ways, did.

Well, if not the troops, then who the heck else?  Another good question!

The decision to militarize the fight against terror was an executive decision of the US Government.  If it was made in concert with any other world powers, no record has been made public to show it.  Everyone recalls who the primary players were, so there's no need to rehash that here -- doing so just glorifies them by giving them a place in history.  Most of the world, including many Americans, believe that the US-Gov. manufactured evidence to give itself the 'moral imperative' to take the 'war on terror' on the road.  This in spite of the fact that it was done with plausible deniability in ind from the start.  Is there hard and fast proof that they did so?  Is a smoking gun proof?  (Actually no, it isn't, since, in and of itself, it doesn't indicate who fired it -- that takes fingerprints and/or gunpowder trace to establish  -- and a ballistics match is required to connect the firing of the gun to the victim.)  I think that since November 1963, it is naïve to think that a complex juggernaut like the US-Gov. could ever leave behind any evidence of wrongdoing unless it wanted that evidence to be found.

The most likely reasoning behind the military solution was twofold:

  1. It is more politically acceptable for American soldiers to die than American civilians. (If you want to make this sound altruistic you can say that the people (i.e. soldiers) that were entrusted (i.e. paid) to defend America (i.e. civilians) were given the reign to do so.)
  2. It is infinitely more politically acceptable for billions or even trillions of dollars worth of infrastructure damage to be inflicted on foreign soil than domestically -- foreigners don't vote in American elections or pay American taxes and foreign reconstruction is generally far cheaper than domestic construction mainly but not exclusively due to labour costs.
Somewhere after these two considerations was the intent to root out terrorists where they live.  It's a good thing that this wasn't really the goal because, by and large, they did a rotten job of it.  This could have been accomplished with covert operatives at a fraction of the cost and most likely with greater probability of success.  Perhaps, I'm wrong.  Maybe there was a third purpose behind the militarization of the hunt for Osama et al.

    3?  To appear to be doing something in order to placate a very agitated, afraid & angry American people?

If you want to, you can believe that the war on terror was a front for the acquisition of oil interests in the Middle East and the export of American-style democracy.  There is certainly enough (circumstantial) evidence to support that opinion.  If it is true, then the parallel with the actions of the terrorists (co-opting Islam to further a tribal agenda of rectifying economic inequality) is ironic.  My belief is that these were just convenient bonuses.

Are we better off now than we thought we were on September 10th, 2001?  How?  Are we better off now than on September 12, 2001?  Probably not.

There was a lot of death and there continues to be lots of death.  It was polarizing then and it continues to be polarizing now.  Are there more Muslim extremists/terrorists today than there were on September 11, 2001? Almost certainly, and their numbers likely swell daily.  (Please note that I'm intentionally using the word "swell" and not the word "grow."  Growth is a natural and healthy process integral to life itself.  Swelling is associated with anger and pain, and is a sign of disharmony, infection or trauma, processes that are inimical to life and congruent with corruption, morbidity and death.  It's pretty clear to me which word is the appropriate choice.)

The big questions that bother me most are these two doozies.

  1. Has anyone claimed responsibility for allowing such acts to occur?  This is not the same as 'has anyone claimed responsibility for committing said acts.'  Obviously, Al Qaeda has in claiming The Cowardly 19 as their own.  By "allowing", I mean having had the power to prevent from happening.  A couple (others certainly exist) of possible targets for blame, and in very different ways and degrees, are: the US Government, that had received credible intelligence indicating impending attack and even attack targets, and attack windows...but didn't respond; and the institution or community that is Islam, which seems unperturbed by the heinous acts of their fellows, except when these acts harm innocent Muslims in Muslim countries.  I don't think anyone should be surprised.  Humans are nothing if not self-interested.  Where do you think NIMBY comes from?
  2. Has anyone claimed responsibility for preventing this from happening again?  Certainly the Western world has ratcheted up security in virtually every way.  Is that a good solution?  Will it prevent additional tragedy or will it only forestall it?  What about Islam?  Have moderate Muslims taken it upon themselves to discourage and 'deromanticize' the extremist, terrorist culture?  Seemingly not.

Please, allow me to design a metaphor.

  • Problem: It rains frequently in your area and you want to be able to play tennis even when the weather does not cooperate.
  • Solution A: You can design, manufacture and distribute special water-repellent balls, nets and racquets, and engineer a new playing surface that quickly absorbs and leeches away moisture...at a prohibitive cost (R&D is expensive).
  • Solution B: You can put a roof on the stadium/court.

In other words, you can scramble to fight the symptoms or you can prevent the problem at the root.  This is an example of "An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure."  Is Solution A worth doing?  I guess if Solution B was impossible, but then, Solution A doesn't even address hail, lightning or excessive cold & heat. In this case a better question might be, "How do you make Solution B possible?"

That is the question that keeps me awake at night.  How do you impress upon a community to police its own?  When that community has a religious/cultural belief that it is wrong to criticize let alone censure other members of the community is there any hope for improvement?  (This is actually an incorrect interpretation of Islam.  In Islam, it is only 'wrong' for non-Muslims (A.K.A. ignorant societies) to criticize Muslims.  Since they are ignorant, their motives can only be negative, thus Muslims should pay no attention to the non-Muslims' complaints -- they simply aren't looking out for Muslims' best interests.  On the other hand, Muslims are expected to criticize Muslims: since they are Muslims, it is assumed that their motivations are pure, specifically to help the criticized become closer to Allah.  Criticism is done in a respectful, giving and educational manner, never in anger or frustration.  In practice, however, this seldom occurs.  At best, it is seen as 'selling out.'  At worst, it can be considered tantamount to heresy.  So, Muslims are reluctant to criticize one another,  especially if the criticized is of higher station in the (religious) community.  Needless to say, Islam has no compunctions about criticizing the ignorant societies.  (I have issues with any society that can't seem to follow the Golden Rule or see 'what's good for the gander...'  In practice, given the choice of solidarity or choosing right from wrong, solidarity is almost always chosen.  Why rock the boat?  The youngest generations do seem willing to be more internally critical, so the future does bring hope for change...if humanity can last that long.)  If you aren't part of that community, what, if anything, can you do to help?  Clearly, according to popular/religious custom, we of the ignorant societies can do nothing.  Any efforts to help will be seen as meddling, or attempts to corrupt, and will have negative repercussions.  Oh, no one doubts that there are millions of -- maybe more than a billion -- Muslims that are pulling their hair out asking the same questions, but what are they doing?  Sadly, even if the entire 'lay' population of Islam were united in their desire to criticize, to end extremism, or at the very least, to end terrorism, they basically have no say in the matter.   The people in charge -- the Imams, the Mullahs, the Ayatollahs (etc.), the tribal chieftains, and many of the governments and wealthiest citizens -- are intent on promoting further terrorism, intent on spreading more hate, handing out more fatwas, (and seeking glory and profit opportunities) and not in quelling violence or seeking peaceful solutions to disputes.  Apparently, anything is permitted if it rights a perceived wrong committed by an infidel against a Muslim, or, even if it doesn't right the wrong, as long as it 'makes them pay.'  (For what it's worth, Islam does not have the same laity/clergy dynamic that is present in Judaism and Christianity.)

And in order to bring things full circle, who, in political power plays, put many if not most of those governments in power?  In that sense at least, it seems the chicken has come home to roost.  That having been said, given prevailing custom it is unlikely that any organically grown governments would be or would have been any more inclined to do anything, so the damage we've done is probably minimal.  However, this relative innocuousness in outcome does not absolve our responsibility to be regretful and/or ashamed for what the world's Superpowers did to manipulate local politics in the Muslim world.

In summary: 10 years later; no answers; lots of questions; 1 dead Osama; 1 dead Saddam; an Iraqi government just waiting to be crushed by an irate Iran the moment the last Allied soldier leaves; a fragile, ineffectual Afghani government (nominally controlled by both US interests AND Taliban interests) just waiting to be overwhelmed by the Taliban as soon as the last Allied soldier leaves; ephemeral changes; boosts in overall terrorist population; a perhaps-weakened, relocated Al Qaeda; an Al Qaeda with its hand in genocide in Africa...at least we have hope that some of the 'Arab Springs' will bring the world some democracy and humanitarianism if not peace and prosperity.

That's pretty much what it boils down to.  We have hope and good intentions -- one of the hopes is that the good intentions aren't paving the way to, well, you know...