Today was the last day of the Major League Baseball regular season and boy was it eventful.
The St. Louis Cardinals shutout Houston while the Atlanta Braves lost in extra innings to Philadelphia giving St. Louis the come-from-behind capture of the National League Wildcard playoff berth. When Milwaukee surged past St. Louis in the standings two months ago it appeared as though the Cardinals season was over, but miracles happen. Atlanta really swooned in September to enable St. Louis' comeback. Surprisingly, this collapse paled in comparison to what occurred in the American League.
In the American League, the Boston Red Sox gave up a 9th inning lead against Baltimore, losing for the first time in 78 such situations. Meanwhile, the Tampa Bay (I still want to call them Devil) Rays knocked off the Yankees 8-7 in 12 innings after having trailed the Yankees 7-0. Boston's collapse was epic -- the worst in Major League Baseball history -- giving up a 9 1/2 game lead they held as late as September 2nd. Relatively, New York's collapse today was nothing!
But there's more to the story. The New York Yankees had clinched the American League East Division title earlier in the week, and had no motivation to beat the Rays. Their primary motivation was to rest their stars for the playoffs which is pretty much the opposite of wanting to win. So no one was surprised when the Yankees fielded a lineup featuring many prospects and back-up players.
But hold on...there's an unwritten rule in Baseball that when the game has playoff implications for the other team you don't mail it in. And that's exactly what New York did. In fact, the winning run in the Ray's clinching game was scored against a tired pitcher, some would even say spent pitcher, that wasn't even on the Yankees' playoff roster. Win or lose, his season was over.
Was this fair? Was this right? Who was hurt -- only the Boston Red Sox and their fans, who just happen to be the nemeses of the Yankees. I'm certain that the Yankees and their die-hard fans are taking particular delight in the fact that Boston was kept from the playoffs. The fact that this was in part orchestrated by the play of the Yankees made the outcome even sweeter.
In the previous series, the Yankees and Red Sox played each other with New York taking two of the three games. New York managed to field semi-competitive teams against Boston -- they played them tough...and then they went through the motions against Tamps Bay.
This was wrong. Plain and simple. The Yankees had a responsibility to make as honest an effort against Tampa as they had against Boston, and they chose to ignore this responsibility out of self-interest. The Yankees are Major League Baseball's juggernauts, nothing they do is really criticized because their success is good for Baseball as a whole, so don't expect to see many headlines or stories like this one. Maybe there won't be any others!
Was this outcome in the best interests of Baseball? Well, it depends who you ask. Boston is a close second to New York in popularity and in garnering high television ratings. Having them miss the playoffs will hurt the networks in that the audiences will be smaller than they could have been. On the other hand, having any team other than New York or Boston in the playoffs helps those that argue that the 'status quo' is good for Baseball; anyone can make the playoffs at any time, not just the big, BIG spenders. By 'status quo' I mean 1) having no salary cap, resulting in a $150,000,000 disparity between the highest and lowest payrolls; 2) having playoff spots determined mainly by divisions; 3) having unbalanced schedules; 4) having inter-league play which no one has ever tried to make balanced.
From where I'm standing, the first position is a matter of fact not opinion so pulling strings to keep Boston out of the playoffs is not in the best interests of Baseball. From where I'm standing, one more season where Boston misses the playoffs changes nothing and does not add weight to the argument in support off the status quo, so again, this was not in the best interests of Baseball. After all, the Yankees have made the playoffs 16 of the last 17 years (winning the World Series 5* times), and Boston has made the playoffs 9 of the last 17 years (winning the World Series 2 times). This data does not make for a significantly better argument than had it been 10 of the last 17 years for Boston.
So, now that we've exposed the wrong doing, what can we do about it. Nothing. Should we? In this case, probably not. The unwritten rules of baseball are never officially enforced -- if they were, they wouldn't be 'unwritten' rules. The closest we get to enforcement is how teams treat each other after a perceived violation. Things like pitchers throwing 98 mph fastballs at or behind your slugger's (or the offending player's) head/shoulder tend to happen in these situations. It really isn't news that the Yankees are a monolithic juggernaut that is completely out of control to the detriment of many cities and many fans -- they've only failed to buy their way into the playoffs once in 17 years! (Of course, they do still have to play their way in each year, but all-star teams are expected to beat normal/traditional teams.) And, while it is true that New York didn't lift a finger to meet their competitive responsibility you can't escape the fact that Boston's record in September was absolutely terrible! More than anything or anyone else, they have to own this failure. Even a sub-mediocre, possibly even bad, performance would have been enough to hold off the Rays and they just couldn't manage to adequately represent themselves. (I wouldn't be the least bit surprised if Boston had the worst September record of all 30 teams! That's just not how you shepherd a team into the playoffs, regardless of how big a lead you've amassed!) Further, if Boston had limped into the playoffs, there's no reason to believe that they would have been able to capitalize on the opportunity since so many players played so poorly, particularly the pitching staff. It was so bad that they really didn't have anyone to put on the mound tomorrow had there been a need for a one-game-playoff to decide the Wildcard.
If you're looking for justice, perhaps you can find it in this: the Yankees first playoff appointment is with the Detroit Tigers, the club with the guaranteed Cy Young Award, and possibly MVP Award winner, Justin Verlander. Oh, and if Verlander doesn't win the MVP, first baseman Miguel Cabrera will garner plenty of votes, too. (Yeah, New York's outfielder Curtis Granderson is probably the odds-on favorite for the MVP, but it's no slam dunk.)
So, enjoy the Red Sox-less playoffs, folks. It only happens about every other year.
* Only 16 of the 17 World Series have been decided, New York could conceivably make it 6 of 17.
Thursday, September 29, 2011
Wednesday, September 28, 2011
Monday, September 19, 2011
Handsome As Hudak
Apparently someone is running a 'beauty contest' for our Ontario politicians. Ontarians are asked to pick the more attractive candidates as they square off in pairs. When asked about what his chances of winning might be, Tim Hudak said [paraphrasing]... there aren't enough Michael Keaton fans left for me to win.
Interesting...Michael Keaton, eh? Tim Hudak looks like Michael Keaton?
I just don't see it. Well, maybe. But only Michael Keaton as Beetlejuice. And he’s just as scary.
What do you think?\
Interesting...Michael Keaton, eh? Tim Hudak looks like Michael Keaton?
I just don't see it. Well, maybe. But only Michael Keaton as Beetlejuice. And he’s just as scary.
What do you think?\
Sunday, September 18, 2011
Conflict in the Classroom: Two Hot Issues
There are two issues related to public education that are hot right now. One is about the appropriateness of allowing prayer in the school. The other is about just how gay-friendly Separate (Catholic) schools should be. I'd like to address these for a moment.
I understand that we live in a mainly secular society and should therefore strive for a secular public school system. My question is how much effort we should put in to discourage students from engaging in prayer. Is that unconstitutional? Let's face it. The reason this is a hot button topic is that it mainly concerns the right of Muslim students to pray in the school. Islam, as a local minority religion, has always been controversial but it is even more so post 9/11, whether that's justified or not. So, what to do?
The school system's mandate is to educate the students, to prepare them for life as productive and informed adult citizens. (Whether we are fully achieving this goal is irrelevant right now.) The school boards would additionally like to not offend anyone along the way. Let's examine the possible solutions.
1) Force non-Christians to become Christians and be part of the majority. If this is your goal, you officially qualify as a nut. Or at the very least a fervid Evangelical. This is never going to happen, so stop pushing for it -- don't even wait or hope for it.
2) Force non-Christians to choose secularism over piety. This is as unlikely to happen as option #1. I might point out that both are unconstitutional.
3) Force non-Christians into private, religion-based schools. This is at least feasible, but I don't think it is desirable. It's a workable solution. John Tory's Progressive Conservatives ran on a platform of funding for private schools which would be more egalitarian than the current model. (Yes, I just agreed with John Tory and the Progressive Conservatives. Mark it on your calendar, it's likely to be that rare.) Nominally, each cultural group will have their own self-regulated school boards funded by public money. They will have control over how much religious/cultural content will be compulsory and what will be ignored. They will have control over which days the schools are open and which days they are closed -- a scheme that will match their own holy days. Everyone should be happy, right? Cultural leaders almost certainly will be.
However, some of the greatest sources of global concern are ignorance, intolerance and tribalism. If we force our children into environments where they never encounter anyone who is remotely different from them then we are promoting all three of those problems when we should be trying to eliminate them. Promoting these three root causes leads to burgeoning hate, something I believe we can all agree is to be avoided. So instead of helping society, we've hurt it. We need a better solution.
4) Let children leave the schools in order to pray during school hours. Unlike Christianity and Judaism, Islam's holy day falls during what we call the work week. That makes Islam stick out like a sore thumb and makes religious comparisons unfair if not impossible. So, everyday Muslim students leave the school in order to worship, but mostly on Fridays when the duration and importance of prayer is enhanced.
What does this really mean? It means that the Muslim students not only lose class time for the time the pray, but also for the time they travel to a house of worship. Depending on the school that can be a very significant amount of time, or even untenable. Are we serving the Muslim students by forcing them out of the classroom even more than they need to be? Are we serving the students that remain in class by maximizing the duration of their friends' absences? Further, in most cases, the students don't bother returning to school on Fridays after prayer. By the Ministry's own rules, this solution fails to serve Muslim students' right to an education as they miss too much time to technically and officially qualify for accreditation. Bureaucracy aside, what do they really learn!? Remember, school is about learning, not collecting marks or even credits. Those are merely our best tools for tracking and measuring learning.
5) What if we do it the other way. What if we allow the Muslim students to worship onsite? Travel time is nearly eliminated, reducing the disruption in their education. It sends a message to the Muslim community -- and for that matter all communities -- that they are valued and that their needs can be accommodated. I don't know how open the Muslim community is to this suggestion, but it wouldn't hurt for the other students to experience Muslim prayer once or twice in their lifetimes. (Gasp!) What better opportunity than when the prayer is happening in their own schools. Besides, who and how does it hurt to allow them to worship on site? Rationally, there is no harm whatsoever. The 'problem' is that it may currently be interpreted as being in violation of some board or Ministry policies. Why have a rule that causes more trouble than it solves? If there is in fact a conflict in rules, and I'm not sure there is, then change them!
Yes, I understand that people want to point to the segregation within the Muslim prayer community, namely separating the boys from the girls from the girls who happen to be menstruating, and call it discriminatory. Conservadox & Orthodox Jewish women worship separated from the men and that hasn't caused the ire of the general public. Why is that? Is it that the women are subdivided? The Bible itself calls women who are menstruating "unholy" -- it is questionable as to whether in ancient times they were permitted in temple at all. Is it the fact that the subdivisions are made from front to back instead of side-to-side? Are we really going to get up in arms over semantics? Seriously!
When people start trying to protect their ideals without really knowing why, you pretty much know they are in the wrong.
I was going to move on to topic two, but there were demonstrations on Saturday addressing this issue.
I'm fairly confident in saying that all in attendance did a good job of emulating nine-year-olds in trying to argue their positions. They were there for many reasons. Some were there due to very real and very current cultural and/or religious hatred. (The status of the Kashmir comes to mind.) Some were there due to fear, humanity's default reaction to things it doesn't understand. Some were there to complain that 'they' got a bigger scoop of ice cream than 'we' did. Some were there because they habitually have knee-jerk reactions that border on complete paranoia. I wonder, how many were there because they thought that children were being harmed in some way by the current policy? almost assuredly not that many since it really isn't happening. Why does the lunatic fringe get so much attention (i.e. press) and the wise and sensible that propose actual workable solutions get ignored and lost in history?
I particularly enjoyed one sign: "Today Muslims want prayer in our schools: what will they ask for tomorrow?" Good show! I like the choice of "our" to describe Ontario schools, like somehow they aren't "their" schools too. With an attitude like that you must really want 'them' ejected from 'your' country, isn't that right? There is nothing so rational as to punish people for what they haven't done, or in this case, deny people for what they might do at some point in the future. What might they ask for tomorrow? Peace? Harmony? A thriving multicultural community? How dare they!? Oh, I forgot. "Multicultural" is an increasingly dirty word as the world rebels against 'the Global Village'. There was a time when we looked to Europe and thought "how backwards, how intolerant", but now we want to emulate them and stir up a backlash against minorities. Is it the minorities that are 'ruining' Canada (or America) or is it established Canadians (Americans) that are inventing the problem? It's pretty clear to any objective viewer that it is the latter.
What did I mean by the 'ice cream' reference above? I mean that Jews and Christians are trying to make accommodating Muslim prayer on Friday somehow an issue of 'inequality'. Why can't our children pray in schools, too? Well, the last time there was prayer in schools it was in the classroom, and catered to Christendom only. That was an inequality issue. Fortunately, that's not what's happening now. Last time I checked, schools in Ontario were closed on Saturday and Sunday, the holy days of the Jewish and Christian weeks. Schools aren't accommodating these religions because there is no need for it! Jewish and Christian children are free to worship all day long without fear of missing any school.
Do we really want to make it an equality issue? Let's throw schools open seven days a week! Then everyone can be excused to pray to their definition of God on the day of their choosing, right there in the school auditoria. I'm sure that teachers will be only too willing to work seven days a week -- for no increase in pay, of course, since we simply have no money for that and can't increase taxes for fear of public lynching, completely forgetting that the Government is just doing what they demanded! Better yet, let's completely undermine the entire teaching profession! Make all teachers part time! Full-time jobs are disappearing everywhere, why not in education, too? Each teacher works 3.5 days a week and students will just have to learn from two people instead of one. Sure, communication between the two 'partners' will be difficult, particularly since they are never in the office at the same time, but they'll work it out and our kids won't suffer at all. For an added benefit, teachers will lose all their benefits, as is the norm for part-time workers. They won't receive a pay increase to offset the fact that they'll now be on their own covering those lost benefits so it's a net savings for the province (hey! they can reduce taxes!), and all it cost us was the integrity of the system and the quality of education for our kids!
Teachers aren't going to work continuously, nor part-time. Taxes aren't going to get raised, or lowered for that matter. Schools aren't going to be open on Saturday and Sunday, and Jews and Christians should stop whining and realize that there is no equality issue here. There's plenty of real inequality for them to concentrate on without inventing new problems.
What about tolerance of gay students? Students in the Separate School System want to be able to form clubs that are supportive and inclusive of gay people. This panics and angers far too many parents. The Bible says! The Bible says! We know what the Bible says, thank you very much. However, 2000 years have passed since these words of 'wisdom' were written. Attitudes have changed. Our understanding of the world around us has grown enormously. Tolerance of intolerance has greatly declined. More and more, people are being awarded full and equal rights regardless of any perceived differences they may have compared to the majority.
For those who believe that every word of the Bible, or the Qur'an, or any other holy texts for that matter, is/was the direct word of God, here's what I think. (I fully expect you to differ.) Language and culture was much, much more limited, primitive even, when the Word was received. God could only tell us what we could be made to understand. Then there is also the possibility that a prophet heard the Word of God and misinterpreted it with his fallible, less than godlike brain. But we take everything as gospel without considering any of these possibilities. Even if you dismiss the possibilities because you conclude that God wouldn't allow these things to happen, that conclusion came from you and your fallible human brain, and not from God -- your judgement is neither perfect nor above criticism. You could easily be wrong which brings us back to the possibility that God's Word did not come to us complete, intact and without error.
If God had dropped a bomb like "everyone, without exception, is equal" the limited, tribal, competitive, even vicious, human minds that received this Word would have rebelled, downright refusing the Word. They might have struck down the offensive prophet rather than accept his message. The prophets themselves might have even come to believe that it was not God that spoke to them, but some malign spirit, maybe even that one, you know his name. It is also possible that they may have henceforth doubted their own sanity. In any of these situations, God's intent is undermined -- the Word fails to be disseminated among the people which was the entire purpose of revealing it to a prophet in the first place.
Don't buy that? What if God had provided specific medical detail regarding the technical and absolute point that life begins? He couldn't, all-powerful though he is, because man had no words for these concepts, nor the ability to measure or determine when this time might occur for any one life. What about the ethics of utilizing nuclear bombs, or nuclear power plants, or computers, or airplanes, or armoured tanks? Should we have ever begun burning coal and petroleum? Should we even be trying to explore space? That information would be extremely helpful to us today. We've had to guess because it was not included in the Word.
But that couldn't happen. We weren't ready. We weren't even remotely equipped. We didn't even know the world was round, let alone have knowledge of all seven continents. What's gravity? What's an atom? I know the periodic table! I know all FIVE elements! They are Fire, Air, Earth, Water and Quintessence. What does this mean? It means that we have to consider the fact the Word makes some approximations and compromises that we may finally be able to address after 1500-2000 (or more) years of linguistic and technological development. How? Through reinterpretation. (For some, this is surely blasphemy!) In this specific case, perhaps the complete disdain for homosexuality was an approximation which needs to be addressed today now that we are more enlightened. Here's a theory. In classical times it was common for important people to have protégés and it was also common for the two to engage in homosexual sex. Perhaps the ban on homosexual sex was primarily, maybe even exclusively, to prevent what amounted to same-sex statutory rape / pedophilia. Perhaps the crime being proscribed was child abuse rather than consensual sex between adults, regardless of gender. This is the kind of 'approximation' I'm talking about. Why didn't God say "no more statutory rape"? There was no such concept. Enforcement would be tricky in any case. When does one's childhood end? Most people at the time didn't track time so had only a rough idea of their age. Would it be based on puberty? How do you know when puberty starts or ends? Better to just ban homosexual sex and with a broad stroke end what was really bothersome. It's just a theory.
Or, we can look at it like this. For a people that is passionate about "Judge not lest ye be judged," we do an awful lot of judging and worse, condemning!
When God said "I will surely bless you and make your descendants as numerous as the stars in the sky and as the sand on the seashore," (Genesis 22:17) did he really mean that we should reproduce at the maximum biological rate until our burgeoning masses utterly crushed the biosphere? That's where we're headed with the world's major religions' positions on birth control. Might it be time to reinterpret that? Do we have to drive the train off the edge of the cliff just because that's where the tracks lead? Because of a steadfast refusal to think? Can't we reexamine, reinterpret, turn around or stop?
When we were few, and being eaten by lions and wolves was a constant threat -- not to mention the prevalence of disease, parasites, stillbirth and famine -- having as many children as possible made sense. What a great way to glorify God, by giving him more worshipers! Today, lion and wolf attacks are almost unheard of, medicine is winning the battle against disease and parasites, birth defects are no longer the death sentence they once were and, most people have enough to eat. We're seriously straining the planet's ability to feed and shelter us, but for now we have enough. Explosive population growth no longer glorifies God because it conflicts with man's stewardship of Earth in God's name. In fact, there are more starving people today than there were people then! But the world's religions unilaterally refuse to change their views on birth control. The only rational reason for this is that religious leaders are choosing to use population as the primary weapon in the next war, a war of religious ideology where every birth represents a new soldier, a war that will completely change the planet if not render it as sterile as the Moon. To some degree, it's already happening. Is this really where we want to go? Is it so important to cling to the perceived and accepted Word of God that we are willing to leave God with no worshipers whatsoever?
I doubt anyone that reads this will be swayed from their position in the slightest. Today, rational thought is considered fairly toxic. The five things (why five? for fingers of course) that man fights most viciously to protect are: family, property, country/tribe, ideals, and ignorance. True wisdom lies in knowing whether you are fighting for ideals or for ignorance. If any society has figured that out, and moved to cast off ignorance, I haven't seen it. But, we have the capacity to change, to better ourselves, to improve our lot in life without it being at the expense of the quality of life of others. I dream of such a time and place. That might be the closest I ever get to it. I hope not.
So, how does that relate to the school problem? People need to get over themselves. Let the kids choose tolerance over ignorance. You don't have to agree with something/someone in order to tolerate it/them. Homosexuality isn't an infectious disease; so your kids aren't going to 'turn gay' because they refused to discriminate against gays. In fact, their lives may be richer for their openness. Any time you can replace hate in your heart with acceptance, you have both improved yourself and the world you live in. If parents must impose their ignorance upon their children, then by all means, remove your children from school and start your own school. Ruin their lives or at the very least their life chances. Take a giant step backwards. Your kids will hate you, but that's your prerogative. Take care that you don't back yourselves off the aforementioned cliff, taking your children with you.
Tangent: I believe that when the next prophet comes (or the return of Jesus, whichever comes first) 'he' will arrive in the form of a physically handicapped or deformed, gay, black woman. God loves to do things like this, meaning to challenge our beliefs, to test our faith and judgement! It will be interesting to see whether she winds up in an institution, incarcerated, killed or merely relegated to obscurity by a disinterested and unbelieving media, or whether she is accepted for what she is. It will be interesting...
I understand that we live in a mainly secular society and should therefore strive for a secular public school system. My question is how much effort we should put in to discourage students from engaging in prayer. Is that unconstitutional? Let's face it. The reason this is a hot button topic is that it mainly concerns the right of Muslim students to pray in the school. Islam, as a local minority religion, has always been controversial but it is even more so post 9/11, whether that's justified or not. So, what to do?
The school system's mandate is to educate the students, to prepare them for life as productive and informed adult citizens. (Whether we are fully achieving this goal is irrelevant right now.) The school boards would additionally like to not offend anyone along the way. Let's examine the possible solutions.
1) Force non-Christians to become Christians and be part of the majority. If this is your goal, you officially qualify as a nut. Or at the very least a fervid Evangelical. This is never going to happen, so stop pushing for it -- don't even wait or hope for it.
2) Force non-Christians to choose secularism over piety. This is as unlikely to happen as option #1. I might point out that both are unconstitutional.
3) Force non-Christians into private, religion-based schools. This is at least feasible, but I don't think it is desirable. It's a workable solution. John Tory's Progressive Conservatives ran on a platform of funding for private schools which would be more egalitarian than the current model. (Yes, I just agreed with John Tory and the Progressive Conservatives. Mark it on your calendar, it's likely to be that rare.) Nominally, each cultural group will have their own self-regulated school boards funded by public money. They will have control over how much religious/cultural content will be compulsory and what will be ignored. They will have control over which days the schools are open and which days they are closed -- a scheme that will match their own holy days. Everyone should be happy, right? Cultural leaders almost certainly will be.
However, some of the greatest sources of global concern are ignorance, intolerance and tribalism. If we force our children into environments where they never encounter anyone who is remotely different from them then we are promoting all three of those problems when we should be trying to eliminate them. Promoting these three root causes leads to burgeoning hate, something I believe we can all agree is to be avoided. So instead of helping society, we've hurt it. We need a better solution.
4) Let children leave the schools in order to pray during school hours. Unlike Christianity and Judaism, Islam's holy day falls during what we call the work week. That makes Islam stick out like a sore thumb and makes religious comparisons unfair if not impossible. So, everyday Muslim students leave the school in order to worship, but mostly on Fridays when the duration and importance of prayer is enhanced.
What does this really mean? It means that the Muslim students not only lose class time for the time the pray, but also for the time they travel to a house of worship. Depending on the school that can be a very significant amount of time, or even untenable. Are we serving the Muslim students by forcing them out of the classroom even more than they need to be? Are we serving the students that remain in class by maximizing the duration of their friends' absences? Further, in most cases, the students don't bother returning to school on Fridays after prayer. By the Ministry's own rules, this solution fails to serve Muslim students' right to an education as they miss too much time to technically and officially qualify for accreditation. Bureaucracy aside, what do they really learn!? Remember, school is about learning, not collecting marks or even credits. Those are merely our best tools for tracking and measuring learning.
5) What if we do it the other way. What if we allow the Muslim students to worship onsite? Travel time is nearly eliminated, reducing the disruption in their education. It sends a message to the Muslim community -- and for that matter all communities -- that they are valued and that their needs can be accommodated. I don't know how open the Muslim community is to this suggestion, but it wouldn't hurt for the other students to experience Muslim prayer once or twice in their lifetimes. (Gasp!) What better opportunity than when the prayer is happening in their own schools. Besides, who and how does it hurt to allow them to worship on site? Rationally, there is no harm whatsoever. The 'problem' is that it may currently be interpreted as being in violation of some board or Ministry policies. Why have a rule that causes more trouble than it solves? If there is in fact a conflict in rules, and I'm not sure there is, then change them!
Yes, I understand that people want to point to the segregation within the Muslim prayer community, namely separating the boys from the girls from the girls who happen to be menstruating, and call it discriminatory. Conservadox & Orthodox Jewish women worship separated from the men and that hasn't caused the ire of the general public. Why is that? Is it that the women are subdivided? The Bible itself calls women who are menstruating "unholy" -- it is questionable as to whether in ancient times they were permitted in temple at all. Is it the fact that the subdivisions are made from front to back instead of side-to-side? Are we really going to get up in arms over semantics? Seriously!
When people start trying to protect their ideals without really knowing why, you pretty much know they are in the wrong.
I was going to move on to topic two, but there were demonstrations on Saturday addressing this issue.
I'm fairly confident in saying that all in attendance did a good job of emulating nine-year-olds in trying to argue their positions. They were there for many reasons. Some were there due to very real and very current cultural and/or religious hatred. (The status of the Kashmir comes to mind.) Some were there due to fear, humanity's default reaction to things it doesn't understand. Some were there to complain that 'they' got a bigger scoop of ice cream than 'we' did. Some were there because they habitually have knee-jerk reactions that border on complete paranoia. I wonder, how many were there because they thought that children were being harmed in some way by the current policy? almost assuredly not that many since it really isn't happening. Why does the lunatic fringe get so much attention (i.e. press) and the wise and sensible that propose actual workable solutions get ignored and lost in history?
I particularly enjoyed one sign: "Today Muslims want prayer in our schools: what will they ask for tomorrow?" Good show! I like the choice of "our" to describe Ontario schools, like somehow they aren't "their" schools too. With an attitude like that you must really want 'them' ejected from 'your' country, isn't that right? There is nothing so rational as to punish people for what they haven't done, or in this case, deny people for what they might do at some point in the future. What might they ask for tomorrow? Peace? Harmony? A thriving multicultural community? How dare they!? Oh, I forgot. "Multicultural" is an increasingly dirty word as the world rebels against 'the Global Village'. There was a time when we looked to Europe and thought "how backwards, how intolerant", but now we want to emulate them and stir up a backlash against minorities. Is it the minorities that are 'ruining' Canada (or America) or is it established Canadians (Americans) that are inventing the problem? It's pretty clear to any objective viewer that it is the latter.
What did I mean by the 'ice cream' reference above? I mean that Jews and Christians are trying to make accommodating Muslim prayer on Friday somehow an issue of 'inequality'. Why can't our children pray in schools, too? Well, the last time there was prayer in schools it was in the classroom, and catered to Christendom only. That was an inequality issue. Fortunately, that's not what's happening now. Last time I checked, schools in Ontario were closed on Saturday and Sunday, the holy days of the Jewish and Christian weeks. Schools aren't accommodating these religions because there is no need for it! Jewish and Christian children are free to worship all day long without fear of missing any school.
Do we really want to make it an equality issue? Let's throw schools open seven days a week! Then everyone can be excused to pray to their definition of God on the day of their choosing, right there in the school auditoria. I'm sure that teachers will be only too willing to work seven days a week -- for no increase in pay, of course, since we simply have no money for that and can't increase taxes for fear of public lynching, completely forgetting that the Government is just doing what they demanded! Better yet, let's completely undermine the entire teaching profession! Make all teachers part time! Full-time jobs are disappearing everywhere, why not in education, too? Each teacher works 3.5 days a week and students will just have to learn from two people instead of one. Sure, communication between the two 'partners' will be difficult, particularly since they are never in the office at the same time, but they'll work it out and our kids won't suffer at all. For an added benefit, teachers will lose all their benefits, as is the norm for part-time workers. They won't receive a pay increase to offset the fact that they'll now be on their own covering those lost benefits so it's a net savings for the province (hey! they can reduce taxes!), and all it cost us was the integrity of the system and the quality of education for our kids!
Teachers aren't going to work continuously, nor part-time. Taxes aren't going to get raised, or lowered for that matter. Schools aren't going to be open on Saturday and Sunday, and Jews and Christians should stop whining and realize that there is no equality issue here. There's plenty of real inequality for them to concentrate on without inventing new problems.
What about tolerance of gay students? Students in the Separate School System want to be able to form clubs that are supportive and inclusive of gay people. This panics and angers far too many parents. The Bible says! The Bible says! We know what the Bible says, thank you very much. However, 2000 years have passed since these words of 'wisdom' were written. Attitudes have changed. Our understanding of the world around us has grown enormously. Tolerance of intolerance has greatly declined. More and more, people are being awarded full and equal rights regardless of any perceived differences they may have compared to the majority.
For those who believe that every word of the Bible, or the Qur'an, or any other holy texts for that matter, is/was the direct word of God, here's what I think. (I fully expect you to differ.) Language and culture was much, much more limited, primitive even, when the Word was received. God could only tell us what we could be made to understand. Then there is also the possibility that a prophet heard the Word of God and misinterpreted it with his fallible, less than godlike brain. But we take everything as gospel without considering any of these possibilities. Even if you dismiss the possibilities because you conclude that God wouldn't allow these things to happen, that conclusion came from you and your fallible human brain, and not from God -- your judgement is neither perfect nor above criticism. You could easily be wrong which brings us back to the possibility that God's Word did not come to us complete, intact and without error.
If God had dropped a bomb like "everyone, without exception, is equal" the limited, tribal, competitive, even vicious, human minds that received this Word would have rebelled, downright refusing the Word. They might have struck down the offensive prophet rather than accept his message. The prophets themselves might have even come to believe that it was not God that spoke to them, but some malign spirit, maybe even that one, you know his name. It is also possible that they may have henceforth doubted their own sanity. In any of these situations, God's intent is undermined -- the Word fails to be disseminated among the people which was the entire purpose of revealing it to a prophet in the first place.
Don't buy that? What if God had provided specific medical detail regarding the technical and absolute point that life begins? He couldn't, all-powerful though he is, because man had no words for these concepts, nor the ability to measure or determine when this time might occur for any one life. What about the ethics of utilizing nuclear bombs, or nuclear power plants, or computers, or airplanes, or armoured tanks? Should we have ever begun burning coal and petroleum? Should we even be trying to explore space? That information would be extremely helpful to us today. We've had to guess because it was not included in the Word.
But that couldn't happen. We weren't ready. We weren't even remotely equipped. We didn't even know the world was round, let alone have knowledge of all seven continents. What's gravity? What's an atom? I know the periodic table! I know all FIVE elements! They are Fire, Air, Earth, Water and Quintessence. What does this mean? It means that we have to consider the fact the Word makes some approximations and compromises that we may finally be able to address after 1500-2000 (or more) years of linguistic and technological development. How? Through reinterpretation. (For some, this is surely blasphemy!) In this specific case, perhaps the complete disdain for homosexuality was an approximation which needs to be addressed today now that we are more enlightened. Here's a theory. In classical times it was common for important people to have protégés and it was also common for the two to engage in homosexual sex. Perhaps the ban on homosexual sex was primarily, maybe even exclusively, to prevent what amounted to same-sex statutory rape / pedophilia. Perhaps the crime being proscribed was child abuse rather than consensual sex between adults, regardless of gender. This is the kind of 'approximation' I'm talking about. Why didn't God say "no more statutory rape"? There was no such concept. Enforcement would be tricky in any case. When does one's childhood end? Most people at the time didn't track time so had only a rough idea of their age. Would it be based on puberty? How do you know when puberty starts or ends? Better to just ban homosexual sex and with a broad stroke end what was really bothersome. It's just a theory.
Or, we can look at it like this. For a people that is passionate about "Judge not lest ye be judged," we do an awful lot of judging and worse, condemning!
When God said "I will surely bless you and make your descendants as numerous as the stars in the sky and as the sand on the seashore," (Genesis 22:17) did he really mean that we should reproduce at the maximum biological rate until our burgeoning masses utterly crushed the biosphere? That's where we're headed with the world's major religions' positions on birth control. Might it be time to reinterpret that? Do we have to drive the train off the edge of the cliff just because that's where the tracks lead? Because of a steadfast refusal to think? Can't we reexamine, reinterpret, turn around or stop?
When we were few, and being eaten by lions and wolves was a constant threat -- not to mention the prevalence of disease, parasites, stillbirth and famine -- having as many children as possible made sense. What a great way to glorify God, by giving him more worshipers! Today, lion and wolf attacks are almost unheard of, medicine is winning the battle against disease and parasites, birth defects are no longer the death sentence they once were and, most people have enough to eat. We're seriously straining the planet's ability to feed and shelter us, but for now we have enough. Explosive population growth no longer glorifies God because it conflicts with man's stewardship of Earth in God's name. In fact, there are more starving people today than there were people then! But the world's religions unilaterally refuse to change their views on birth control. The only rational reason for this is that religious leaders are choosing to use population as the primary weapon in the next war, a war of religious ideology where every birth represents a new soldier, a war that will completely change the planet if not render it as sterile as the Moon. To some degree, it's already happening. Is this really where we want to go? Is it so important to cling to the perceived and accepted Word of God that we are willing to leave God with no worshipers whatsoever?
I doubt anyone that reads this will be swayed from their position in the slightest. Today, rational thought is considered fairly toxic. The five things (why five? for fingers of course) that man fights most viciously to protect are: family, property, country/tribe, ideals, and ignorance. True wisdom lies in knowing whether you are fighting for ideals or for ignorance. If any society has figured that out, and moved to cast off ignorance, I haven't seen it. But, we have the capacity to change, to better ourselves, to improve our lot in life without it being at the expense of the quality of life of others. I dream of such a time and place. That might be the closest I ever get to it. I hope not.
So, how does that relate to the school problem? People need to get over themselves. Let the kids choose tolerance over ignorance. You don't have to agree with something/someone in order to tolerate it/them. Homosexuality isn't an infectious disease; so your kids aren't going to 'turn gay' because they refused to discriminate against gays. In fact, their lives may be richer for their openness. Any time you can replace hate in your heart with acceptance, you have both improved yourself and the world you live in. If parents must impose their ignorance upon their children, then by all means, remove your children from school and start your own school. Ruin their lives or at the very least their life chances. Take a giant step backwards. Your kids will hate you, but that's your prerogative. Take care that you don't back yourselves off the aforementioned cliff, taking your children with you.
Tangent: I believe that when the next prophet comes (or the return of Jesus, whichever comes first) 'he' will arrive in the form of a physically handicapped or deformed, gay, black woman. God loves to do things like this, meaning to challenge our beliefs, to test our faith and judgement! It will be interesting to see whether she winds up in an institution, incarcerated, killed or merely relegated to obscurity by a disinterested and unbelieving media, or whether she is accepted for what she is. It will be interesting...
What a piece of work is a man, how noble in reason, how
infinite in faculties, in form and moving how express and
admirable, in action how like an angel, in apprehension how like
a god! the beauty of the world, the paragon of animals—and yet,
to me, what is this quintessence of dust? Man delights not me—
nor woman neither, though by your smiling you seem to say so.
infinite in faculties, in form and moving how express and
admirable, in action how like an angel, in apprehension how like
a god! the beauty of the world, the paragon of animals—and yet,
to me, what is this quintessence of dust? Man delights not me—
nor woman neither, though by your smiling you seem to say so.
William Shakespeare, Hamlet, Act 2, scene 2
Labels:
Catholic,
Coptic,
education,
gay,
homosexual,
intolerance,
Islam,
Ontario politics,
prayer,
private school,
public school,
reinterpretation,
separate school,
tolerance,
Toronto Politics
Toronto Triumph: Titillation, Truth or Tragedy? Trivial!
The Toronto Triumph are the most recent addition to Toronto's list of professional sports franchises. They are receiving a lot of attention but they are also receiving a lot of hate. Why?
Well, the Triumph are members of the Lingerie Football League, that's why. Guaranteed controversial, and for almost no reason.
First of all, the ladies of the LFL don't wear lingerie. Lingerie doesn't belong in the same sentence as football, does it? Their uniforms are skimpy to be sure but they're not lingerie. Is that still too scandalous? What are you afraid of? That someone might be exposed to a bare...abdomen? Is the midriff taboo now? Women have been extremely candid about their appreciation of professional (men's) football players' uniforms, specifically because they are stretchy and clingy and show the definition of the, well, not the abdomen and it rhymes with 'glasses'. Besides, lingerie has never been known to adequately cover football pads, and is too frilly and delicate to use in a game that involves tackling. (That's right, they tackle, just like the NFL & CFL.) Why? Frilly makes it too easy to get a hold of your opponent in order to tie them up and ultimately to tackle them. Delicate means that it would not remain clothing for very long. While this might meet with approval from the audience, it is inconsistent with the reputation the league is seeking, namely that of a legitimate sport and not orchestrated burlesque. Also, uniforms cost much less than lingerie, especially when you need multiple changes per game as you would with tearing, stretching and exploding lingerie.
Second, these ladies play football. Do you suggest that perhaps they are not worthy athletes? These women are packing more muscle than most men. They are certainly athletes. I daresay they are more athletic than some (perhaps many) Major League Baseball players. They play it hard and fast just like the men that play professional football. The men deal with the constant threat of breaks & bruises, strains & separations, detachments and dislocations, not to mention tears, twists and other trauma. All this without so much as a peep from the public. I suppose this argument can go both ways: either we should increase our concern for the men to match our concern for the women, or we should give the women the same break we give the men. However, either way should you agree that our concern should be equal for both sexes. The women have just as much right to a low-quality of life post-retirement as the men do.
I haven't even touched on the most severe type of injury that is common to football -- the brain injury. The men's pro leagues have been tweaking the rules regularly to help minimize the threat of brain injury, but it still happens. With the increasing frequency with which we receive data about retired players who suffered from dementia and depression (including suicides) as well as balance, coordination and memory issues perhaps we should get them all off the field until we can improve the safety of the game. Sounds good, but it's never going to happen, not even if there was a 100% likelihood of these symptoms occurring later in life. So I guess we'll have to console ourselves with the fact that these women will be tackled by 200 lbs of hurtling bone and pads instead of the 400 lbs with which the men have to cope.
Third, and perhaps most importantly, what difference does it make? If the purpose of the LFL is to titillate then that makes the players entertainers. If the LFL is a purely athletic endeavour that makes the players entertainers. Are we discriminating between forms of entertainment now? The closest thing we have to that is the rating systems used for television shows, movies and video games, and these are merely guidelines for parents to act upon as they see fit. Can you remember when there was this much hullabaloo about the existence of R-rated movies? How about X-rated movies? Video games marked 'M' for 'mature' end up in the hands of teens and preteens all the time. Where's the big stink for that?
The reasons that the LFL is getting more attention than the others are simple and quite poor in quality. 1. Sexism. We've discussed that already and exposed an unfair double-standard. It's time we gave women the same opportunities that we allow men. The real controversy here is how little the women will make when compared to the men playing the same game. 2. Puritanism. It's the 21st century but there are still plenty of people stuck somewhere between the 15th and the 19th centuries. Wake up and smell the coffee, people! The world isn't run by the Church nor by petty monarchs anymore; now democracy reigns and you are in the tiny but self-righteously loud minority. If you disagree with the ethics, values, morals and mores of the place where you live, you are free to move elsewhere. I hear Antarctica is uninhabited, so you would automatically become the majority. When you get there you can have all the witch hunts you want. The short, rude and violent native men in tuxedos (known as penguins to the sane) will just swim away and mock you from the water instead of drown. While you're at it, since you love history so much, go ahead and genocide the penguins for having the audacity of being there before you but possessing 'inferior' culture & technology. That's really what you're about isn't it? See it my way or be destroyed? (Alternately, 'or God will destroy you', which is really the same thing since the destruction will come at the hand of 'God's instrument', man.)
So, lets give an open arms welcome to Toronto's latest professional team, the Triumph! May they live long and prosper. God help us if they pattern themselves after the Maple Leafs, or for that matter any MLS&E franchise.
Well, the Triumph are members of the Lingerie Football League, that's why. Guaranteed controversial, and for almost no reason.
First of all, the ladies of the LFL don't wear lingerie. Lingerie doesn't belong in the same sentence as football, does it? Their uniforms are skimpy to be sure but they're not lingerie. Is that still too scandalous? What are you afraid of? That someone might be exposed to a bare...abdomen? Is the midriff taboo now? Women have been extremely candid about their appreciation of professional (men's) football players' uniforms, specifically because they are stretchy and clingy and show the definition of the, well, not the abdomen and it rhymes with 'glasses'. Besides, lingerie has never been known to adequately cover football pads, and is too frilly and delicate to use in a game that involves tackling. (That's right, they tackle, just like the NFL & CFL.) Why? Frilly makes it too easy to get a hold of your opponent in order to tie them up and ultimately to tackle them. Delicate means that it would not remain clothing for very long. While this might meet with approval from the audience, it is inconsistent with the reputation the league is seeking, namely that of a legitimate sport and not orchestrated burlesque. Also, uniforms cost much less than lingerie, especially when you need multiple changes per game as you would with tearing, stretching and exploding lingerie.
Second, these ladies play football. Do you suggest that perhaps they are not worthy athletes? These women are packing more muscle than most men. They are certainly athletes. I daresay they are more athletic than some (perhaps many) Major League Baseball players. They play it hard and fast just like the men that play professional football. The men deal with the constant threat of breaks & bruises, strains & separations, detachments and dislocations, not to mention tears, twists and other trauma. All this without so much as a peep from the public. I suppose this argument can go both ways: either we should increase our concern for the men to match our concern for the women, or we should give the women the same break we give the men. However, either way should you agree that our concern should be equal for both sexes. The women have just as much right to a low-quality of life post-retirement as the men do.
I haven't even touched on the most severe type of injury that is common to football -- the brain injury. The men's pro leagues have been tweaking the rules regularly to help minimize the threat of brain injury, but it still happens. With the increasing frequency with which we receive data about retired players who suffered from dementia and depression (including suicides) as well as balance, coordination and memory issues perhaps we should get them all off the field until we can improve the safety of the game. Sounds good, but it's never going to happen, not even if there was a 100% likelihood of these symptoms occurring later in life. So I guess we'll have to console ourselves with the fact that these women will be tackled by 200 lbs of hurtling bone and pads instead of the 400 lbs with which the men have to cope.
Third, and perhaps most importantly, what difference does it make? If the purpose of the LFL is to titillate then that makes the players entertainers. If the LFL is a purely athletic endeavour that makes the players entertainers. Are we discriminating between forms of entertainment now? The closest thing we have to that is the rating systems used for television shows, movies and video games, and these are merely guidelines for parents to act upon as they see fit. Can you remember when there was this much hullabaloo about the existence of R-rated movies? How about X-rated movies? Video games marked 'M' for 'mature' end up in the hands of teens and preteens all the time. Where's the big stink for that?
The reasons that the LFL is getting more attention than the others are simple and quite poor in quality. 1. Sexism. We've discussed that already and exposed an unfair double-standard. It's time we gave women the same opportunities that we allow men. The real controversy here is how little the women will make when compared to the men playing the same game. 2. Puritanism. It's the 21st century but there are still plenty of people stuck somewhere between the 15th and the 19th centuries. Wake up and smell the coffee, people! The world isn't run by the Church nor by petty monarchs anymore; now democracy reigns and you are in the tiny but self-righteously loud minority. If you disagree with the ethics, values, morals and mores of the place where you live, you are free to move elsewhere. I hear Antarctica is uninhabited, so you would automatically become the majority. When you get there you can have all the witch hunts you want. The short, rude and violent native men in tuxedos (known as penguins to the sane) will just swim away and mock you from the water instead of drown. While you're at it, since you love history so much, go ahead and genocide the penguins for having the audacity of being there before you but possessing 'inferior' culture & technology. That's really what you're about isn't it? See it my way or be destroyed? (Alternately, 'or God will destroy you', which is really the same thing since the destruction will come at the hand of 'God's instrument', man.)
So, lets give an open arms welcome to Toronto's latest professional team, the Triumph! May they live long and prosper. God help us if they pattern themselves after the Maple Leafs, or for that matter any MLS&E franchise.
Saturday, September 17, 2011
CRC Guaranteed To Pass: 2 Good 2 B True?
For years now, CRC has advertised their product Guaranteed To Pass.(G2P) as a method of passing 'pesky' (vehicular) emissions tests. They also go so as to say that G2P doesn't "cheat or fool" emissions tests. Well, if it isn't cheating or fooling the emissions test, what does it do?
Their words are that G2P will "superclean the entire fuel system." I'm not 100% certain, but I suspect that a better description would be that it coats and conditions your fuel system. By either description, it temporarily reduces your vehicle's emissions and they are confident enough to guarantee that this boost in performance will be enough to pass the test.
In the event that it doesn't work, and any Internet search will reveal enough anecdotes and self-reports to show that this happens, there are conditions to the guarantee. You need your G2P receipt. That's completely standard, so no problem here. You need documentation of "before and after" emissions tests. In other words, you can't use G2P in a preventive fashion and have any hope of receiving your money back. You must document that your vehicle failed the test and then failed the test again after using their product. Finally, you need to produce either a Provincial Waiver or a bill for repairs that did allow the vehicle to pass the emissions test. Whoops! That's a third emissions test required to get your money back. I'm not sure if this is just typical legal rigmarole or if this is the sign of a company that isn't all that confident in its product.
But that's not really the point.
So, back to the whole 'what does it do?' issue. I think the scenario is very much like the following example:
A teacher takes pity on one of his/her students and lets them retake a failed test, this time with complete access to their textbook and notes. The test wasn't designed for students to have access to these materials. And the student passes, but is that really a surprise? A short time after writing the test the student could be tested again, without aids, and is more likely to fail than pass. The test, which is supposed to measure what they have learned ended up testing something else, something less rigorous. When we look at the piece of paper that says the student passed the course, what does it really mean? Is it any indicator of future success?
How is this any different than G2P being used for emissions tests? Annual emissions tests are supposed to measure the likely amount of pollution your car will produce for the year (or more) until your next test. It is administered in order to assure that the vehicles on the road meet a minimum emission standard. Use of G2P makes the test become an estimate for the pollution emissions expected for the first 3,000 miles driven after the product is applied. If you use an additive that has a temporary effect, like G2P, what is it really testing? The G2P label and literature state that you should "use every 3,000 miles to improve fuel economy, acceleration and reduce emissions." This amounts to a legal disclaimer limiting the company's legal responsibility for people 'misuse' of their product. What kind of misuse? The kind that almost assuredly occurs in 95% (or more) of all usage -- using the product to pass the mandatory test and forgetting all about it until the next emissions test. So, in effect, the product as it is being used is cheating and fooling the test. What about the remaining 7,000, 22,000, or 72,000 miles that the vehicle travels before the next emissions test? The test has no idea what will happen then, but, if the vehicle failed the test before applying G2P it is almost certainly going to be falling short of these standards after it wears off.
So, people use G2P to cheat the testing/monitoring system put in place by the government, whether or not it was designed for this purpose. Who cares? I do, and you should, too. Looking at things from one perspective, if you allow people to blatantly cheat the system and their sponsor to flaunt their cheating product by advertising on your open airwaves, why bother testing at all? Let's keep every junk-bucket on the road until it won't move anymore. Air quality is overrated and has very little to do with automobile emissions anyway, and automobile emissions have little if anything to do with respiratory health. Right?
If you believe this, then you are almost assuredly one of the following (pick one): idiot, jerk. Actually, describing what I think of you requires stronger language than I want to use in this blog. Suffice it to say that I think you place the value of your self, life, needs and convenience above those of the other 7 billion people on Earth combined. If God made the decision of whether a soul went to Heaven or Hell on the fly instead of at the natural end of life your fate would already be decided and you'd be taking an elevator ride down. There's a reason that the term 'shortcut' is often used with implicit negativity, i.e. there is cost built into shortcuts that makes us think twice before using them. I guess in your mind if the cost is paid by someone else then that makes it okay. I call that "the right to make it someone else's responsibility." That's a rough definition of (lesser) evil, hence the 'going down' prediction above.
If it is not okay for people to cheat the system by taking shortcuts at the expense of others then why don't governments take action? Shouldn't this product be outlawed? Why hasn't it been? I've felt this way for years and naïvely thought that the government would eventually get around to it. That clearly isn't happening. I guess the only answers come come from this list: too expensive, impractical and apathy. To these I reply:
And to the people at CRC, if you want to continue selling and marketing G2P and do so ethically and morally, either improve the product to last at least a full year or stop pretending you don't know how nearly all your customers use your product. You obviously know or you would have called the product something less leading like "CRC Emission Reducer", or "CRC Air B Clean", which implies a generic year-round usage as opposed to "G2P" which basically tells the customers to cheat, and how to cheat. A legal disclaimer is just that, it absolves the issuing entity of legal responsibility but does nothing about waiving moral or ethical responsibility. I like to call this "Avoid jail, enjoy Hell."
Enjoy Hell, cheaters. Hope the bucks were worth it.
Their words are that G2P will "superclean the entire fuel system." I'm not 100% certain, but I suspect that a better description would be that it coats and conditions your fuel system. By either description, it temporarily reduces your vehicle's emissions and they are confident enough to guarantee that this boost in performance will be enough to pass the test.
In the event that it doesn't work, and any Internet search will reveal enough anecdotes and self-reports to show that this happens, there are conditions to the guarantee. You need your G2P receipt. That's completely standard, so no problem here. You need documentation of "before and after" emissions tests. In other words, you can't use G2P in a preventive fashion and have any hope of receiving your money back. You must document that your vehicle failed the test and then failed the test again after using their product. Finally, you need to produce either a Provincial Waiver or a bill for repairs that did allow the vehicle to pass the emissions test. Whoops! That's a third emissions test required to get your money back. I'm not sure if this is just typical legal rigmarole or if this is the sign of a company that isn't all that confident in its product.
But that's not really the point.
So, back to the whole 'what does it do?' issue. I think the scenario is very much like the following example:
A teacher takes pity on one of his/her students and lets them retake a failed test, this time with complete access to their textbook and notes. The test wasn't designed for students to have access to these materials. And the student passes, but is that really a surprise? A short time after writing the test the student could be tested again, without aids, and is more likely to fail than pass. The test, which is supposed to measure what they have learned ended up testing something else, something less rigorous. When we look at the piece of paper that says the student passed the course, what does it really mean? Is it any indicator of future success?
How is this any different than G2P being used for emissions tests? Annual emissions tests are supposed to measure the likely amount of pollution your car will produce for the year (or more) until your next test. It is administered in order to assure that the vehicles on the road meet a minimum emission standard. Use of G2P makes the test become an estimate for the pollution emissions expected for the first 3,000 miles driven after the product is applied. If you use an additive that has a temporary effect, like G2P, what is it really testing? The G2P label and literature state that you should "use every 3,000 miles to improve fuel economy, acceleration and reduce emissions." This amounts to a legal disclaimer limiting the company's legal responsibility for people 'misuse' of their product. What kind of misuse? The kind that almost assuredly occurs in 95% (or more) of all usage -- using the product to pass the mandatory test and forgetting all about it until the next emissions test. So, in effect, the product as it is being used is cheating and fooling the test. What about the remaining 7,000, 22,000, or 72,000 miles that the vehicle travels before the next emissions test? The test has no idea what will happen then, but, if the vehicle failed the test before applying G2P it is almost certainly going to be falling short of these standards after it wears off.
So, people use G2P to cheat the testing/monitoring system put in place by the government, whether or not it was designed for this purpose. Who cares? I do, and you should, too. Looking at things from one perspective, if you allow people to blatantly cheat the system and their sponsor to flaunt their cheating product by advertising on your open airwaves, why bother testing at all? Let's keep every junk-bucket on the road until it won't move anymore. Air quality is overrated and has very little to do with automobile emissions anyway, and automobile emissions have little if anything to do with respiratory health. Right?
If you believe this, then you are almost assuredly one of the following (pick one): idiot, jerk. Actually, describing what I think of you requires stronger language than I want to use in this blog. Suffice it to say that I think you place the value of your self, life, needs and convenience above those of the other 7 billion people on Earth combined. If God made the decision of whether a soul went to Heaven or Hell on the fly instead of at the natural end of life your fate would already be decided and you'd be taking an elevator ride down. There's a reason that the term 'shortcut' is often used with implicit negativity, i.e. there is cost built into shortcuts that makes us think twice before using them. I guess in your mind if the cost is paid by someone else then that makes it okay. I call that "the right to make it someone else's responsibility." That's a rough definition of (lesser) evil, hence the 'going down' prediction above.
If it is not okay for people to cheat the system by taking shortcuts at the expense of others then why don't governments take action? Shouldn't this product be outlawed? Why hasn't it been? I've felt this way for years and naïvely thought that the government would eventually get around to it. That clearly isn't happening. I guess the only answers come come from this list: too expensive, impractical and apathy. To these I reply:
- How can it be too expensive to outlaw/enforce and yet not too expensive to maintain a now flawed testing system? (I guess they need the sales tax dollars?)
- If it is impractical to outlaw/enforce against the use of this product then why are coloured license plate covers illegal? You know, the ones that make it harder to impossible for cameras to read the license plates of red-light-runners and toll-road-abusers, not to mention difficult for citizens to be able to identify license plates of vehicles being used in the commission of a crime. They're against the law, though I see so many of them I wonder how much, or even if, the law is being enforced. Still, the law discourages at least some people from using them. The same should be true for G2P, banning it should make it hard enough for people to get it (because retailers are generally law abiding people, or at the very least, afraid of prosecution) that enforcement should be relatively trivial.
- If the government is apathetic toward situations like these, why did they run for office in the first place, and more importantly, why did we vote for them?
And to the people at CRC, if you want to continue selling and marketing G2P and do so ethically and morally, either improve the product to last at least a full year or stop pretending you don't know how nearly all your customers use your product. You obviously know or you would have called the product something less leading like "CRC Emission Reducer", or "CRC Air B Clean", which implies a generic year-round usage as opposed to "G2P" which basically tells the customers to cheat, and how to cheat. A legal disclaimer is just that, it absolves the issuing entity of legal responsibility but does nothing about waiving moral or ethical responsibility. I like to call this "Avoid jail, enjoy Hell."
Enjoy Hell, cheaters. Hope the bucks were worth it.
Thursday, September 15, 2011
Are You Serious? Bad Advertisement #1
One of the things I like to talk about is bad advertising. Not 'bad' as in failing to entertain or persuade, but bad as in misleading, ridiculous, offensive or worse.
Also, every election, attack ads get more and more outrageous, exploding past the limits of good taste and into the realms of fantasy and insanity. One of these ads is in rotation now and is from the CFO of the Ontario PC Party. Interestingly enough, the only spots I've heard/seen this election have been from the PCs. I assume that the other parties are in fact promoting themselves, but they aren't doing good enough a job to reach me. Is this coincidence (am I tuned in to the wrong broadcasters), an indication of injustice or an indication of the size of each party's war chest?
Apparently, PC stands for Progressive Conservative but it just as easily could stand for Probably Confrontational, Parliamentary Contempt, Possibly Corrupt, Pro-Corporation, Pot & Cannabis, Potentially Clueless, Prevaricating Crook(s), Plotting Conspirators, Pathetic Clown(s), Polluting Carbon, Political Cheaters, Perverting Capitalism, Perpetrators Club, Peter Cottontails, Petulant Children, Pickled Cucumbers, Philistine Cads, Plodding Cavemen, Preserved Cadavers, Peppercorns, Peppermint Candy, Postal Couriers, Paternal Custody, Perplexed & Confused, Pet Cause, Public Crib, Psychoactive Chemicals, Punish Canadians, Prison Crew, Paper Cup or a virtually limitless number of other combinations. To be fair, most of these apply equally to politicians of all stripes.
I'll take you directly to the offensive language and let you decide. The PCs would like to paint the Liberal Party as epic tax-raisers and in their effort to do so present the following words to be admitted into evidence:
"...not to mention all his future taxes."
In other words, we, the voting public, should indite "him", meaning Dalton McGuinty and the Liberals, not only for their track record, which may or may not resemble the picture the PCs try to paint, and of which you may or may not approve, but for things that haven't happened yet. There are words for things that haven't happened yet. "Fiction" is one of them. I suppose we could technically justify this as a "Future forecast" if we check the Liberal election platform and find that they have announced tax raises slated for the immediate future. Sadly for this advertised argument, they haven't. So what gives?
Making (or trying to make) people responsible for things that they haven't done or things that haven't happened yet is patently ridiculous! It is the realm of dystopian science fiction. (That's never good.) Popular movie examples, which are probably more widely recognized than literary examples, include:
For more examples of dystopian fiction, see:
AccreditedOnlineColleges.com's 20 Greatest Works Of Dystopian Literature
Snarkerati's Top 50 Dystopian Movies Of All Time
Popcrunch.com's 15 Greatest Dystopian Films Of All Time
Listverse.com's Top 10 Dystopian Films You Haven't Seen
Wikipedia's (extensive) List Of Dystopian Films
(Will October 7th's newspapers be another indicator of a dystopian future?)
Disturbingly, this ad isn't being promoted as fiction. You're supposed to treat it as 'fact'. So, the Ontario PCs ask you to vote PC in the upcoming election in order to punish the Liberals for the crime of levying or increasing unspecified and uncertain taxes at some vague point in the future. In this case, they don't even provide any evidence (other than the weak suggestion of past tax increases) that this future 'fiscal crime' is going to happen; they simply ask you to trust them that they can predict the future -- without the benefit of psychics or mysterious inventions I may add -- from their oh, so unbiased position as a self-interested, opposing political party. Not much of an engaging plot really; I expect the movie to have a high splat/rotten factor over at Rotten Tomatoes. It might even win a Razzie! Not only is this the worst kind of dystopian science fiction, it is blatantly undemocratic.
So, what does this advertisement tell me? It tells me that there is an equation in Ontario politics, possibly with an even broader truth, namely "Conservatives = dystopia". Come October 6th, try to remember that before you cast your ballot -- the Thoughtpolice are monitoring you!
Also, every election, attack ads get more and more outrageous, exploding past the limits of good taste and into the realms of fantasy and insanity. One of these ads is in rotation now and is from the CFO of the Ontario PC Party. Interestingly enough, the only spots I've heard/seen this election have been from the PCs. I assume that the other parties are in fact promoting themselves, but they aren't doing good enough a job to reach me. Is this coincidence (am I tuned in to the wrong broadcasters), an indication of injustice or an indication of the size of each party's war chest?
Apparently, PC stands for Progressive Conservative but it just as easily could stand for Probably Confrontational, Parliamentary Contempt, Possibly Corrupt, Pro-Corporation, Pot & Cannabis, Potentially Clueless, Prevaricating Crook(s), Plotting Conspirators, Pathetic Clown(s), Polluting Carbon, Political Cheaters, Perverting Capitalism, Perpetrators Club, Peter Cottontails, Petulant Children, Pickled Cucumbers, Philistine Cads, Plodding Cavemen, Preserved Cadavers, Peppercorns, Peppermint Candy, Postal Couriers, Paternal Custody, Perplexed & Confused, Pet Cause, Public Crib, Psychoactive Chemicals, Punish Canadians, Prison Crew, Paper Cup or a virtually limitless number of other combinations. To be fair, most of these apply equally to politicians of all stripes.
I'll take you directly to the offensive language and let you decide. The PCs would like to paint the Liberal Party as epic tax-raisers and in their effort to do so present the following words to be admitted into evidence:
"...not to mention all his future taxes."
In other words, we, the voting public, should indite "him", meaning Dalton McGuinty and the Liberals, not only for their track record, which may or may not resemble the picture the PCs try to paint, and of which you may or may not approve, but for things that haven't happened yet. There are words for things that haven't happened yet. "Fiction" is one of them. I suppose we could technically justify this as a "Future forecast" if we check the Liberal election platform and find that they have announced tax raises slated for the immediate future. Sadly for this advertised argument, they haven't. So what gives?
Making (or trying to make) people responsible for things that they haven't done or things that haven't happened yet is patently ridiculous! It is the realm of dystopian science fiction. (That's never good.) Popular movie examples, which are probably more widely recognized than literary examples, include:
- Michael Radford's (adaptation of George Orwell's novel) - 1984 (released, not surprisingly, in 1984)
Sure, you haven't done anything offensive but your thinking has fallen out of step with the party line. Expect to feel the wrath of the Thoughtpolice!
- Steven Spielberg's (adaptation of the Philip K. Dick short story) (with Tom Cruise)- Minority Report (released in 2002)
Why wait for criminals to actually commit crimes when you can have (powerful?) psychics predict the crimes before they happen? After all, an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, isn't it? The 'victims' certainly seem happier this way. Do we question the validity of the psychics' predictions? Should we? I mean, this is all established science and "I saw it in my dreams" is all the hard evidence a jury needs to convict, right?
- J.J. Abrams' - Person of Interest (forthcoming TV series, scheduled to premiere this month)
A scientist invents a machine presumably capable of seeing into the future and asks an ex-CIA hit-man for help eliminating people that presumably will be responsible for great tragedies and crimes against humanity. Minor problem -- the machine isn't so good at differentiating between perpetrators and victims. All are just 'persons of interest'. So who do we kill? Maybe it's spree time?
For more examples of dystopian fiction, see:
AccreditedOnlineColleges.com's 20 Greatest Works Of Dystopian Literature
Snarkerati's Top 50 Dystopian Movies Of All Time
Popcrunch.com's 15 Greatest Dystopian Films Of All Time
Listverse.com's Top 10 Dystopian Films You Haven't Seen
Wikipedia's (extensive) List Of Dystopian Films
(Will October 7th's newspapers be another indicator of a dystopian future?)
Disturbingly, this ad isn't being promoted as fiction. You're supposed to treat it as 'fact'. So, the Ontario PCs ask you to vote PC in the upcoming election in order to punish the Liberals for the crime of levying or increasing unspecified and uncertain taxes at some vague point in the future. In this case, they don't even provide any evidence (other than the weak suggestion of past tax increases) that this future 'fiscal crime' is going to happen; they simply ask you to trust them that they can predict the future -- without the benefit of psychics or mysterious inventions I may add -- from their oh, so unbiased position as a self-interested, opposing political party. Not much of an engaging plot really; I expect the movie to have a high splat/rotten factor over at Rotten Tomatoes. It might even win a Razzie! Not only is this the worst kind of dystopian science fiction, it is blatantly undemocratic.
So, what does this advertisement tell me? It tells me that there is an equation in Ontario politics, possibly with an even broader truth, namely "Conservatives = dystopia". Come October 6th, try to remember that before you cast your ballot -- the Thoughtpolice are monitoring you!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)