It seems that London's has a new baseball team. The team's origin is a deal made on October 1st by some American owners with local council to use the local ballpark for Fronteir League play. They decided to take a name that would jump out and grab you (or in this case, stab you) something that couldn't be ignored. Marketing theory at its best.
Welcome to the London "Rippers"! Yes, they chose to have serial murderer Jack "The Ripper" as their central theme, though they claim they don't. Their logo has a stylized Jack "The Ripper" looking very menacing in Victorian garb. He wields a bat and dall, only the bat looks more like a billy club than a baseball bat. Their mascot is "Diamond Jack", which along with the "Rippers" nickname proves without any doubt that the serial murderer of women is, in fact, their inspiration. If it wasn't, why not choose "Diamond Jim" or "Diamond Fauntleroy" for that matter?
This may be the worst marketing decision ever made! Worse than New Coke!
To call this gambit insensitive is an exercise in understatement. This choice is intentionally disrespectful. It's disrespectful of every person who can trace their relationship to one of Jack's victims. It's disrespectful to anyone who has lost someone to a murderer. It is disrespectful of every woman that has been attacked in any fashion and every person that cares for these women. That should leave just about nobody to appreciate their marketing 'genius'. Sure, the owner has a corny, thin veil of an explanation that the similarity is 'coincidental'. If it is coincidental, why does even he consider the theme 'edgy'. Edgy doesn't begin to address how wrong this is.
The pathetically contrived 'back story' is that "Diamond Jack" is a"Phantom of the Opera" inspired character. A rogue that is not wanted anywhere because he always 'rips' the covers off of baseballs when he hits them. So, he creates his own team to have a place to hang out. GIVE ME A BREAK! Do they really think that anyone is going to swallow that tripe?
Part of the problem is that the owner came up with this plan on his own. At no point did he consult with city officials -- or the public for that matter. Ideas that get acted upon before they've been vetted almost always turn out badly and this is perhaps the perfect, classic example.
Already, within 48 hours of the 'brand's' unveiling the public has given its verdict: FAIL! Megan Walker, executive director of the London Abused Women’s Centre is on the case. She stresses what should have been obvious to even the most obtuse person, that this theme is disrespectful of women in general and even more disrespectful for people with specific experiences. She goes on to predict that the team will fail miserably, noting that the last local team, the London Werewolves -- an allusion to both a popular song by Warren Zevon in 1978 and a popular (fictional) 1981 horror movie -- also failed and that was with the approval of the community. Without it the team is doomed! The owner thinks the public has overreacted. Nonsense! This is EXACTLY the reaction he was looking for. There is no way that the team could have gotten even half as much attention with ANY other name. It was chosen entirely for shock value and shock it certainly has.
Politicians have picked up on the pulse of the city and have also expressed their concern. London has been very proactive about ending violence against women. Actually, they're pretty much leaders where this is concerned. David Martin, the obviously mentally or morally challenged owner, has said a great deal about the controversy. Here are some quotes...
His response to the political flak and fallout:
“The mayor was in attendance [at the unveiling of the team nickname, logo and mascot Tuesday night]. Everything was fine last night.”
“That’s probably the way a politician would answer [the controversy].”
His stance on why there's controversy:
[It's] “negative spin” [from a] “loud minority.”
On the idea itself:
“It’s a great logo. It’s a great look. We took a lot of time putting it together and thinking the storyline out.”
No doubt! I'm sure it took a lot of creativity to come up with a rationalization for getting away with a Jack "The Ripper" theme. Again, this was done to shock and outrage. It follows the woeful incorrect and mostly immoral or amoral philosophy that 'there is no such thing as bad publicity'.
So far, I've intentionally been leaving out one key detail. This isn't happening in London, England. It's happening in London, Ontario, Canada! If this had happened in England, someone who really wanted to make a case for the legitimacy of this 'brand' could say that Jack "The Ripper" is not just a 19th Century serial killer. He's a piece of London's history and culture. They effectively 'own' the legacy and phenomenon that is "Jack." London, Ontario has absolutely no connection to Jack "The Ripper" other than the fact that the cities share the same name. So, not only is Martin using a terribly insensitive and insulting 'brand' but he's using it without even a remote connection to the history, folklore or mystery that surrounds "Jack." He has absolutely no leg to stand on for justifying this pathetic 'brand'!
What is it about White, Christian (Western) society that makes them think that they can do whatever they want whenever they want and if it offends someone, that's their problem!? I've got news for those people that think the world has gone too far in political correctness and is oversensitive about everything. It isn't that they are oversensitive, it's that you are completely insensitive. Frankly, I think it borders on being sociopathic, being completely unable to place one's self in other people's shoes and see how things appear/feel for them.
"The Rippers" certainly aren't the first team nickname in ridiculously poor taste. There are tons of teams that have stolen Native American culture for their own fun and profit. Why this is considered acceptable but a hypothetical sports team from Mississippi that called itself the N-----s is considered obviously wrong! Here's the short list of nicknames that 'white man' has no business using to represent themselves, but does anyway:
Atlanta Braves
Chicago Black Hawks
Cleveland Indians
Edmonton Eskimos
Kansas City Chiefs
Washington Redskins
...and MANY more college/university/high-school nicknames
It wasn't enough that Europeans came to North America and leveraged the fact that they had more technology than the indigenous peoples to slaughter them and steal their land. By doing so, they showed that they were technologically 'superior' to the dozens of cultures and civilizations that they destroyed and inferior to them in EVERY other way!. Today, many wonder if worshiping rampant technology was somehow better than living in harmony with the land. The ongoing collapse of the environment says otherwise.
What gave them the right to kill indiscriminately? Does the Bible authorize it? Does it even condone it? Where does it say it's OK to kill and then steal so long as the 'enemy'/'others' have something you covet? To me, that's 3 out of Ten Commandments broken and all the while they felt they had the moral imperative to sin! To this day the vast majority of people think that the actions of this era were just and that modern society has no obligation to apologize or provide reparations. Now, centuries later, the descendants of those butchered, marginalized and criminalized peoples are all too often living on the fringes of society, frequently with the worst kind of poverty and addiction. If they're lucky, they have been 'granted' land by the government on which they can live as they please. Only they can't, because the quality and quantity of the land is pathetic and in some cases quite distant from their traditional territory. They are also forced from time to time to accept 'white man's law' which directly prevents them from living as they please. BTW, how do you 'grant' someone something that already belongs to them? No, it wasn't enough -- now, they misappropriate their cultural symbols as though these symbols have something to do with European heritage or history. It's a mockery. It's an insult. It's completely wrong.
But it won't change. We still live with that same sense of moral superiority and refuse to consider that our actions infringe on other's freedoms or identities. We still believe 'might makes right'. We live it every day, both politically and in terms of economics -- what are modern capitalism and class warfare if not 'might makes right'? Ultimately, sports are more important to the typical North American than the sum value of the lives of every single Native American that ever lived. They don't matter. "Didn't we beat them into submission enough? What the hell are they whining about? Maybe we should have gotten rid of all of them while we had the chance?" Disgusting!
The only possible exception to this rule is the Florida Seminoles. Florida State University had the surprising good sense to consider changing their nickname out of deference to and respect for the modern Seminole people. But the Seminole tribe spoke up and lobbied for the retention of their name. To them, it was a source of pride. In the end, they are the only people whose opinions matter! If they accept the nickname as a form of respect and acknowledgement then that's that. To the best of my knowledge no other tribe has EVER stepped up to support a team nickname that refers to Native peoples, so none of the other franchises get a pass. For teams to justify a 'brand' that refer generically to Native Americans they would have to get permission from ALL tribes.
Only slightly less offensive are the following:
Calgary Hitmen
Oakland Raiders
Minnesota Vikings
Pittsburgh Pirates
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
The Raiders, Buccaneers and Pirates all refer to the same thing, the same culture. When exactly was piracy an aspect of American culture? There were pirates and privateers from every seagoing culture in the world. If they are associated with any one location it's likely the islands of the Caribbean and those of the South Pacific. Besides, why is it OK to celebrate criminals? While we're doing that why not the Rapists, Embezzlers or Killers?
The Calgary Hitmen derive their name from one of the original owners, world famous and local ex-WWE wrestler Bret "The Hitman" Hart. Further, it is supposed to be an allusion to hockey's ubiquitous bodychecking, which is often called 'hitting'. Unfortunately, the logo features a 'player' that is reminiscent of "Jason", the goalie-mask-wearing serial killer from the "Friday the 13th" movie franchise. If he carried a goaltender's stick then he would just look like a goaltender, but he carries a normal stick and holds it in a fashion somehwere between the wielding of a long gun (e.g. Tommie gun) or an axe. Which forces one to think of the original meaning of "hitman", namely that of a murderer-for-hire generally employed by "the Mob." Actually, I don't think most people need a cartoon-like character on the logo to make that connection. Again, and maybe completely inadvertently, this is an example of glorifying criminals. Try to explain to your 4-year old son taking in his first hockey game what a "hitman" is.
The Minnesota Vikings are only marginally offensive. Actually, it's possible that they offend no one. In 2005 17% of the Minnesota population could trace their roots to Norway. Another 10% came from other Scandinavian countries. These numbers were likely much higher generations ago, but are now falling steadily as immigrants settle in Minnesota and the Hispanic population outstrips the growth of the other demographics. If this 25%-or-less-and-falling of the population wanted to lend their heritage and culture to their professional football team, then more power to them. As far as I know, the team was named to reflect Minnesota's traditionally strong Norwegian background. 2 of the 5 businessmen that founded the franchise in 1960 were of Norwegian descent. One of those owners went to a high school whose nickname was also the Vikings, but that was in Wisconsin where Norwegians make up less than 10% of the population. He also owned a professional football team prior to the Vikings and it was the Duluth Eskimos, so he already had a history of misappropriating the culture and heritage of others. Besides which, Duluth is 1000 miles removed from actual Eskimo (now considered a pejorative term, replaced by self-referential names including Inuit) habitat. I am not aware of the public having been consulted about their feelings regarding being represented by the team nickname "Vikings" This is perhaps most important because of the standard inclusion of a cartoonish, stereotypical reflection of the culture it adopts. At least here, there IS a cultural connection of the local people to that of the nickname, and if they chose it or openly accepted it, no harm, no foul.
"The Rippers" puts all of them to shame for sheer political incorrectness. Let's hope that Martin steps outside of himself for just a moment and allows the idiocy of his idea to penetrate to his consciousness. Unless the city boycotts the team I doubt he'll have any such revelation. Decisions like this have nothing to do with ethics or morals, they are entirely about money. So long as the money rolls in the name will remain the same. If tumbleweeds start to blow through the bleachers, the "Rippers" will have a new name in a heartbeat.
Thursday, November 17, 2011
Starts and Fits
Sports fans are funny. They can be totally bipolar and no one says a word. This year has provided great examples.
In the NFL, the Buffalo Bills and Detroit Lions got off to amazing starts of 4-1 and 5-0 respectively. Fans of those teams and sportscasters alike raved about how improved the teams were and were already talking playoffs and even championships. We're now into Week 11 of the NFL season and things look very different.
In the NHL, the most financially successful team has been the least successful team on the ice for over 40 years. That would be the Toronto Maple Leafs. Less than two weeks ago they stood atop the NHL standings for the first time in more than 17 full seasons. In this case it was almost exclusively the fans that went bonkers. By and large, broadcasters had been teased with temporary success and eventual failure for too long.
Skeptics and cynics laughed at the excited fans. They truly were fans -- that is fanatical. Logic is discarded. Calm is a foreign concept. People had jumped aboard the bandwagon, and drank deeply of the Kool-Aid. When you consider the fact that these fans have had virtually nothing to cheer for, nothing but grief for years and more, you can understand why people might be inclined to want to go off the deep end.
Here's a bold prediction! None of the three will make the playoffs! I'm not even sure any will make it a close call! The teams just aren't used to winning. As such, they lack a culture of winning. The Leafs may have the second most Stanley Cup championships (behind the Montreal Canadiens) but that is ancient history. The Bills lost umpteen games in overtime last year, extremely rare in the NFL, perhaps showing that they lacked the talent or guts to win. The Lions have been the NFL's losingest team for over a decade. That and injuries to key personnel will ultimately keep them all from success this season. Bills, Lions and Maple Leafs fans will have to deal with beleaguerment for at least another season.
Good starts do not make good seasons. They can be an important part of a good season, but can always just be statistical anomalies. All three teams have struggled of late, each for their own reasons. In some cases, injuries played a significant part. In others, it was just a matter of reality setting in. Buffalo has fallen to 5-4 and Detroit to 6-3. Detroit is still positioned to make the playoffs but Buffalo isn't. If you project their recent play for the rest of the season both will fall short. The Leafs are still tied in points for the lead in their division but have basically been in free-fall for two weeks. They are rated 2nd in their division behind the Buffalo Sabres since they have 1 fewer win (and 2 extra loses in extra time). They are only 3 points ahead of the miss-the-playoffs cutoff line. The Boston Bruins are only 4 points behind with 2 games in hand and are surging. Projecting their current record would still place them in the playoffs, but their most recent pace would guarantee them permission to play golf immediately after the regular season ends for the eighth straight year. With their starting goaltender out with "concussion-like symptoms", the local vernacular for a concussion, there is no telling when he will return. Without him, the team will surely fall. To make matters worse, of late they are only getting scoring from 1 of their 4 forward lines. Radically unbalanced scoring like that makes it easier for opponents to completely neutralize your offense.
Will all three teams missing the playoffs teach fans not to count their chicken before they've hatched? Not a chance! Where would the fun be in that? When you are used to your team being terrible you are even more desperate to celebrate every minor victory and even moral victories. It would be nice if rabid fans didn't get so drunk on the relative success of their teams that they become belligerent and hostile towards anyone that dares doubt, but don't hold your breath for that to happen any time soon. Reason and fanaticism just don't mix well, so it's understandable that manners and tolerance are in scarce supply.
Now, if we can only get the 7 billion people in the world to limit their fanaticism to ultimately inconsequential matters like sports, what a wonderful world it would be.
In the NFL, the Buffalo Bills and Detroit Lions got off to amazing starts of 4-1 and 5-0 respectively. Fans of those teams and sportscasters alike raved about how improved the teams were and were already talking playoffs and even championships. We're now into Week 11 of the NFL season and things look very different.
In the NHL, the most financially successful team has been the least successful team on the ice for over 40 years. That would be the Toronto Maple Leafs. Less than two weeks ago they stood atop the NHL standings for the first time in more than 17 full seasons. In this case it was almost exclusively the fans that went bonkers. By and large, broadcasters had been teased with temporary success and eventual failure for too long.
Skeptics and cynics laughed at the excited fans. They truly were fans -- that is fanatical. Logic is discarded. Calm is a foreign concept. People had jumped aboard the bandwagon, and drank deeply of the Kool-Aid. When you consider the fact that these fans have had virtually nothing to cheer for, nothing but grief for years and more, you can understand why people might be inclined to want to go off the deep end.
Here's a bold prediction! None of the three will make the playoffs! I'm not even sure any will make it a close call! The teams just aren't used to winning. As such, they lack a culture of winning. The Leafs may have the second most Stanley Cup championships (behind the Montreal Canadiens) but that is ancient history. The Bills lost umpteen games in overtime last year, extremely rare in the NFL, perhaps showing that they lacked the talent or guts to win. The Lions have been the NFL's losingest team for over a decade. That and injuries to key personnel will ultimately keep them all from success this season. Bills, Lions and Maple Leafs fans will have to deal with beleaguerment for at least another season.
Good starts do not make good seasons. They can be an important part of a good season, but can always just be statistical anomalies. All three teams have struggled of late, each for their own reasons. In some cases, injuries played a significant part. In others, it was just a matter of reality setting in. Buffalo has fallen to 5-4 and Detroit to 6-3. Detroit is still positioned to make the playoffs but Buffalo isn't. If you project their recent play for the rest of the season both will fall short. The Leafs are still tied in points for the lead in their division but have basically been in free-fall for two weeks. They are rated 2nd in their division behind the Buffalo Sabres since they have 1 fewer win (and 2 extra loses in extra time). They are only 3 points ahead of the miss-the-playoffs cutoff line. The Boston Bruins are only 4 points behind with 2 games in hand and are surging. Projecting their current record would still place them in the playoffs, but their most recent pace would guarantee them permission to play golf immediately after the regular season ends for the eighth straight year. With their starting goaltender out with "concussion-like symptoms", the local vernacular for a concussion, there is no telling when he will return. Without him, the team will surely fall. To make matters worse, of late they are only getting scoring from 1 of their 4 forward lines. Radically unbalanced scoring like that makes it easier for opponents to completely neutralize your offense.
Will all three teams missing the playoffs teach fans not to count their chicken before they've hatched? Not a chance! Where would the fun be in that? When you are used to your team being terrible you are even more desperate to celebrate every minor victory and even moral victories. It would be nice if rabid fans didn't get so drunk on the relative success of their teams that they become belligerent and hostile towards anyone that dares doubt, but don't hold your breath for that to happen any time soon. Reason and fanaticism just don't mix well, so it's understandable that manners and tolerance are in scarce supply.
Now, if we can only get the 7 billion people in the world to limit their fanaticism to ultimately inconsequential matters like sports, what a wonderful world it would be.
Tuesday, November 15, 2011
Basketball Is In Trouble
Of all North American professional team sports, the indoor leagues are in more trouble than the outdoor sports. They are definitely at a disadvantage in terms of venue attendance as indoor arenas are almost universally smaller than outdoor stadiums. But today, the gate is not close to being the main source of revenue, so the blame lies elsewhere.
Interestingly, the indoor team sports (basketball and hockey) have smaller rosters than the outdoor sports (baseball, football and soccer), so the cost of athlete contracts are minimized and they are still in trouble.
The NBA might be on the brink of complete disaster. Or it might be on the brink of exploiting its players in a manner that hasn't been seen since the advent of free agency in the 1960s and 1970s. The players have been locked out for many months. There is no end in sight. The owners have decided that they aren't making enough money and have decided that they will boost their profit margin on the backs of the athletes. At the same time the owners have refused all requests to back up their claims with proof in the form of financial numbers. Outside observers note that revenues have climbed every year for decades and the industry pulls in multiple billions each year, yet somehow, the owners are not only not making enough, but actually losing money!
First of all, I believe that anyone who makes a claim and refuses to substantiate their claim is almost assuredly lying, or at the very least, stretching the truth to an absurd degree. No rational person would give their trust in such a situation, but that is exactly what NBA owners are telling the players to do -- "just trust us!" Second, most owners are multi-billionaires that have been incredibly successful in their other business pursuits. The notion that they can't find a way to make their multi-billion dollar industry profitable without forcing a 15-20% rollback in player salaries as well as dozens of other structural concessions in collective bargaining is absolutely ludicrous! If they were this inept at business they never would have become wealthy in the first place!
What appears to be happening is that the owners feel they aren't making enough money by being franchise owners and operators. In other words, their invested money would do better in other ventures, which implies that the opportunity cost of being an owner is very high. The logical thing to do in such situations is to reinvest your capital in more profitable ventures. That is what business is about! But owners are alpha males of the first order. By and large they made their obscene fortunes by being ruthless and cutthroat. Getting out of the sports franchise ownership business would feel like losing to them. These people never lose. They manipulate the rules until it is impossible for them to lose. Winning is the only option. Charlie Sheen to the nth degree. So, instead of recognizing that sports franchise ownership is not a high return industry and moving their money to better investments they have planted their feet into the ground and will move mountains to make it a more profitable industry and anyone in their way will suffer!
For what it's worth, most intelligent people recognize that sports franchise ownership is not a money maker. Few if any owners are making their fortune on sports entertainment. Pundits basically refer to franchises as "toys" for the ultra-wealthy. They are status symbols and allow former and wannabe athletes to live out their sports fantasies at the ownership and management level. Anyone who purchases a sports franchise in the 21st Century and expects it to be their bread and butter is delusional. The NFL makes money, well, except apparently the Detroit Lions who are managing to lose money. Given how Detroit has been hit as hard or harder by the economic downturns of the past decade than any other North American city perhaps this is not completely unexpected. A select few MLB franchises make real money and only a few more operate at a profit at all. The NHL has some franchises that make money but other than the Toronto Maple Leafs none of them make significant profits. Why the NBA owners think that they should universally be making money hand over fist must be a product of ego and hubris as it is certainly not based in realism.
And then there's the players. NBA players are not very sympathetic. They may represent 'labour' in this dispute but the typical fan cannot identify millionaires as 'labour'. It is only relative to the billionaire owners that they seem to be the disadvantaged 'poor'. In a battle between billionaires and millionaires no one gets the public's sympathy.
That does not mean that the public doesn't take sides. They definitely take sides. In almost all cases fans and the public both side with ownership. It's completely ironic but explainable too. In a society weaned on The American Dream the public is predisposed to look favorably on the wealthy. No one looks beneath the surface and asks questions like "how did they become wealthy?" Surely some billionaires became super-rich by pure entrepreneurship. They saw a market need that was not being addressed, formed a company to fill that need, did the job better than anybody else and became rich by making life better for their customers.
This is not the typical story. Most people come to extreme wealth in less than entirely wholesome manners. Taxes are avoided either illegally or by lobbying politicians to reduce their tax burden. The 'bribe' known as lobbying is cheaper in the long run than meeting their moral and legal tax obligations. Monopolies and oligopolies are formed and the public gets gouged. Monopolies are leveraged into other markets in grossly anti-competitive fashion. Companies with potentially threatening new innovations are purchased before they can come to market and affect the bottom line. The pending innovation is sometimes incorporated into the established company's products and is sometimes quashed -- which is never in the public interest. Stereotypically, the wealthy don't bother to watch on whose heads and hands they step on the way up as they have no intention to ever allow themselves the indignity of having to climb back down. In rare cases laws beyond the scope of Antitrust are broken in various cost-cutting measures meant to improve the profit margin. Likewise, ethics are often a casualty of big business. Manufacturing is shipped offshore to sweatshops employing children to reduce costs, regardless of the drastic negative effect the lost jobs have on the local economy and regardless of the human rights violations happening on foreign soil away from prying eyes. Polluting is rampant and either hidden or environmental agencies are paid to look the other way. Ultimately, few fortunes are built in a fashion that will get the profiteering decision makers into Heaven. But we are awed by their success, nonetheless, and put them on a pedestal as paragons of virtue, wishing we could be like them.
The players on the other hand are perceived as opportunists who have little to no value to the economy outside of their athletic ability. In other words, if they didn't have their sport in which to make a fortune they would be working class stiffs living paycheck to paycheck. As such, athletes should take whatever pittance the owners throw their way and be thankful for it. The fact that the athletes are often more highly educated than the owners actually works against them! The public is alienated by education and intelligence as they can't relate to either. "Dubya" managed to portray the educated as "the elite", people to be held in scorn and marginalized, while portraying the super wealthy as "the ordinary guy"...and America ate it up, hook, line and sinker! What is incredibly ironic is that the likelihood of a person escaping the ranks of the poor or middle class and becoming wealthy through sport are greater than their chances to become wealthy by other means. Sportsmen and athletes are the very embodiment of the American Dream and yet we look at them with disdain.
Here's some common sense that seems to be lost on the masses. On the whole, money is not made in sports on the acuity of owners or management. It is made on the skill and popularity of the athletes. How many NBA owners can you name? For most people the number is two, the most notorious two -- Mark Cuban and Michael Jordan -- or less! If the owners are mostly unknown, how can you attribute any portion of ticket sales or television revenue to the owners? The athletes are the only commodity of sports and have every right to demand as much money as the market is willing to bear. That is the nature of capitalist, free market economics. (Actually, I think the entire industry is broken and all parties should be making no more than 10% of their current earnings, with the other 90% either being 'returned' to the consumer in the form of lower ticket prices or being contributed to worthy charities.)
Another piece of common sense is that the contractual concessions and salary reductions the owners seek amount to a request for the players to protect the owners from themselves! When a player signs for $30 million dollars a year, or $1 million for that matter, no one is holding gun to the head of the owner forcing them to offer that contract! The owners would never make the kind of decisions they make in sports in their other businesses! So, because the less affluent billionaire owners suddenly can't seem to manage a budget they are going to take it out on the players. It all comes down to the egos of the owners. They cannot abide losing so spend money they don't have in a vain attempt to win. They all end up doing it, so overspending doesn't guarantee anything beyond blowing their budgets. (When only some of them do it, like in MLB and the English Premiership (soccer), money does buy success.)
Another deep dark secret of the NBA is something known as BRI -- Basketball Related Income. Ticket sales, direct television, Internet and radio contracts and sale of merchandise and memorabilia (replica uniforms, caps, etc.) count in BRI. ALL the NBA contract negotiations revolve around BRI. What the owners aren't telling you is that they are making a mint off of their franchises in areas that don't count as BRI. For example, a great many of the franchise owners also own various media. They use their franchises as cheap or free content for their media. All the money made by these media wings of the owner's conglomerate doesn't contribute a penny to BRI. Generally, these moneys are comparable to the BRI itself! So, while the team as an independent business unit may be losing money on paper the owners are making very tidy sums as a result of league operations. The NFL, for all its failings, doesn't make a distinction between profits made directly and indirectly from the operation of the league. Good for them for being so up front. The NBA, however, does make that distinction. It's like a huge tax shelter -- they make money but avoid paying taxes by an act of accounting. IMHO, this kind of obfuscation are merely lies of omission, and are thus still lies.
[Small tangent]
For what it's worth, creative accounting is being used everywhere by owners and management to exploit investors and employees alike. Tens of thousands of investors and stars of Hollywood motion pictures whose contracts call for a percentage of profits have never seen a red cent because, on paper, movies that grossed hundreds of millions of dollars seemingly lost money. If they lost money, how are the fat cats in control making money hand over fist? Lawsuits stagnate in court -- studio lawyers ensure that it costs these cheated investors more money in legal expenses to recoup their rightful earnings than the earnings are worth. This is done because human greed knows no bounds and because they know they can get away with it! Justice is indeed blind, but not in a good way.
[end of tangent]
Finally, like much of the financial world today, money isn't make on the operation of business. In terms of public holdings the proceeds from the operation of business are paid out as dividends. Dividends represent a very small portion of the growth of wealth. The value of the stocks themselves is what matters these days and often the value of stock has little to do with actual earnings or even earning potential. Speculation and psychology play a big part in stock valuation. Sports franchises are exactly the same. The owners don't make much money from the operation of these franchises. They make the real money by selling the franchise for twice what they paid for it. In general, franchise values, particularly for prestige franchises, only go up, so there isn't much in the way of risk involved in ownership, in spite of what the owners and their PR machines (including their League Commissioners) tell you.
Frankly, the athletes experience more risk than the owners! How many times have you heard someone tell a child that their chances of making the big leagues are somewhere between slim and none and they had better place a lot of attention and effort on a back-up plan just in case they fall short of their professional goals and their dreams of making it rich in sports. Perhaps you've done it yourself. Kids are highly resistant to listening to adults, especially parents. Somehow they always seem to think they know better than the people who have experienced everything they (the kids) have and much, much more and thus have earned the wisdom of age. A child's intuition, hope and tenuous grasp of logic generally wins the day. For what it's worth, the kids that don't invest any time in a backup plan and devote themselves exclusively to their dream are often the ones that make it. Of course, talent is required but hard work and unswerving dedication go a long way, too. In either case, the amount of time and money invested in the quest for a professional sports career is much riskier for a have-not kid than any risk the owners experience by operating a franchise! Yes, the owners put up more money, but their return on investment is astronomically higher than that of athletes. (Not many athletes complete college and those that do often have degrees that are little more than a piece of paper. The athlete that graduates with a (functional) degree in law, medicine, engineering, hard science or education (or other profession) are few and far between. Their degrees generally qualify them for virtually no form of gainful employment.)
Based on news coverage, it is pretty clear that the owners had no intention of bargaining in good faith. They had a goal in mind and nothing short of achieving that goal today would suffice. (In other businesses, management might seek smaller concessions today and seek further concessions in the next Collective Bargaining Agreement, but the NBA wants it all now! They aren't willing to risk the possibility that the economic reality of the NBA might improve in the future, jeopardizing their ability to leverage further concessions from the Player's Union in subsequent CBAs.) The players have moved significantly from their starting position. They have accepted the fact that they are going to come out losers in these negotiations even though they don't accept the assertions by the NBA that they are leeching money. Ownership hasn't really moved. What little movement there was merely changed completely unrealistic and unfair positions to less unrealistic and unfair positions. This is standard practice -- the owners never expected to achieve the originally offered deal.. You always ask for more than for what you are willing to settle. In this case, the demands were so radical and drastic that the starting position was simultaneously comical and desperately sad. The owners weren't even hiding the fact that they were bargaining in bad faith. They issued ultimatums like "take this deal or the next offer will be much, much worse for you." (The point of bargaining is for two differing positions to move towards each other, not away from each other.)
Given that the owners had no intention of bargaining in good faith, the players were left with two choices. They could let the owners get away with highway robbery and take a bad deal. The other option was to reject the bad deal and walk away from the farcical negotiations, specifically pointing to the owners' bad faith, and dissolve the union. Unions are only worth something to its members if it can do a better job negotiating contracts and working conditions than the individuals could manage separately. There's no point in paying dues to an organization that can achieve nothing.
The absence of a union opens the door for an Antitrust lawsuit against the NBA. The only recourse for players is to appeal to the courts of law. All major team sports have been in violation of America's Antitrust legislation for a century. Baseball, America's National Pastime, received exemption from Congress from Antitrust laws. That having been said, if it could be demonstrated that this exemption was no longer in the best interest of the American People it would disappear in a heartbeat. None of the other sports leagues have similar exemption. The assertion of Antitrust violations have never really been tested in court. The NFL Player's Association made a weak attempt to challenge the NFL earlier this year. The initial results favored the players but ultimately a higher court overturned the ruling and sided with ownership.
If the players succeed in their court claims that the NBA is operating in violation of Antitrust laws it is unclear how this would affect future operations. There is no reason to believe that such a ruling would directly result in better contracts for players. In fact, there may be no change in internal economics at all. Worse, the owners may decide to be punitive on top of being greedy and offer even less "to make up for lost revenues resulting from the lockout." First of all, the owners are locking out the players, not the players striking against the owners. Games aren't being played because the owners refuse to stage them. Any "lost revenue" is a result of owner decisions, not player malpractice or malfeasance and the owenrs have no leg to stand on demanding recompense. Second of all, the NBA is claiming that owners are losing money by operating under the current CBA with current player contracts. If they would lose money by operating, then surely they are saving money by locking out the players! In that case, there isn't a single dollar that needs to be "made up"! The owners would simply be using this as an opportunity to further pull the wool over the public's eyes and gouge the players even deeper.
In the terrible eight years suffered under Dubya, the Supreme Court was stacked with very thinly veiled ideological conservatives. With Republicans having control of all three Houses (Representatives, Senate and White) there was nothing that could be done to prevent these politically incorrect, politically motivated and basically unethical appointments. The bottom line is that the players have no hope whatsoever of wining this matter in the courts. They may win in a local circuit court. They may win in the Court of Appeal. But they are guaranteed to lose when the matter reaches the Supreme Court which is completely in bed with Big Business and the super-wealthy.
But it doesn't really matter...it won't get that far. Obscenely paid lawyers representing the owners will use every trick in the book (and will probably invent a few new ones!) to delay the procession of this case through the courts, that is, if they can't derail it entirely! Only a couple of the owners make a substantial portion of their income, directly or indirectly, via the operation of the NBA. The rest will continue to have annual earnings on the order of $100 million upward to $2 billion! If the NBA never plays another game, they will simply write off the franchises as losses and gladly take the associated tax breaks.
All but a couple of the players make their money directly from their NBA contracts. The few that could live off of their significant endorsement deals will find those deals disappearing -- players that don't play make poor spokespersons for sponsoring companies. So, in effect, all the players make their living from the operation of the NBA. They can't afford to continue to forgo 'average' annual incomes of $4 million when the 'average' player has a career lasting only 4 years. (Significantly more than 50% play 4 years or less.) They are making a stand on moral grounds and they can't possibly win. Given that this contract dispute is part of a larger phenomenon of the rich getting richer faster and to greater extremes than ever before and the middle class (and relatively speaking the players are the middle class of that particular subsection of the economy) seeing their standard of living rapidly eroding the players are essentially taking one for the team, meaning us. The best they can really hope for is forcing the American media and American public to take a long, hard look at what is happening on their watch. It is unlikely that the media will be paying attention, and if they don't the public won't even be aware of the significance of what's happening.
My personal preference is that the owners be forced to sell their franchises -- at a major loss, the cost of their hubris -- to owners that recognize that sports ownership is a 'big toy for big boys' and a status symbol and have no expectation to make significant money. You may feel that this makes no sense. Neither does multi-billionaires extorting cities and states for hundreds of millions to billions of dollars to build brand-spanking new, state-of-the-art stadiums that they will completely own using only public money. The gravy train for the ultra-wealthy financed on the backs of athletes with the little guy's hard earned and scarce dollars needs to stop. (Don't even get me started on how the NCAA and its member schools exploit student athletes!) The new reality for the NBA will involve much lower levels of BRI due to lost goodwill / bad publicity and everyone will make less. This is reasonable when you consider the true value of their contributions to society relative to (relatively) poorly paid teachers, doctors, scientists and engineers. It is disgusting how entertainment is so enormously overvalued by modern society! Still, the split of revenue between the anonymous owners and star athletes will be more equitable and reasonable. Preferably this happens sooner rather than later.
Of course, this is not going to happen. The players will watch potential income evaporate every single day they are locked out. This is money they can never get back. In the end, they will come back to the table and take half of what the owners were offering before. Why? Because the system failed them, because the owners can get away with it and because the players have no other options.
There is a remote chance that the players will try to form their own league, owned by the players, and the NBA will become obsolete. NBA franchise values will become $0. I suspect that should this option be pursued by the players that the owners will sue on imaginary grounds and the courts will somehow agree with them, putting the kibosh on the players' attempts to be self-sufficient. Besides, the players would need somewhere to play these games and the owners they are being oppressed by are the very same owners of the athletic venues they would need to use. The owners could play it one of two ways. They could laugh at the players and their upstart league telling them to go to Hell. Or, they could charge 100 times the going rate for the rental of their facilities. Again, it all boils down to the fact that the players can't win. The deck is not only stacked in the owners favour, it is marked, too, and the owners know exactly what the next cards are going to be. Further, the dealer is an owner that can deal from the bottom of the deck without any chance of being detected. The owners cannot lose! The society that we've built and are so proud of has set things up so that the just cannot win. Power and money buy justice.
Even if/when the NBA once more puts the squeak of rubber soles back into the arenas they aren't out of the woods. Officiating in the NBA is an exercise in politics. The popular, big market teams get the calls. The superstars get the calls. The home team gets the calls. NBA officiating is terrible. In part this is human psychology. Officials cannot completely separate themselves from their own thinking or the human desire to please others. They please the audience by calling in favor of the home team. They please the most influential players, the superstars, by making calls in their favor. They please their bosses, the NBA itself, by ensuring that the most lucrative and popular teams make the playoffs and go farther in the playoffs by making calls for the big market "in" teams. All of these are subconscious processes and to some extent unavoidable. Regardless, officials should be aware of these inherent biases and be consciously avoiding them! They don't appear to be combating anything. The fans and pundits that are most steeped in testosterone and have been "drinking the Kool-Aid" for years will tell you that's just how it is. It is up to the journeyman, rookie and unheralded player, the visiting teams and the have-not franchises to suck it up and overcome the adversity. I'll never understand why inherent and obvious unfairness is explained away as a fundamental part of competition.
Also, it was revealed a number of years ago that at least one NBA referee (or exactly one, depending on who you believe) was corrupt and taking money on the side to call a game a certain way or ensure a certain outcomes for gamblers and gangsters, like "making a spread". He claims he wasn't alone and that he's been made a scapegoat so the league can say it dealt with the 'isolated' problem when in fact it continues unabated. He may be a bitter and miserable cheat that got caught and got punished (he was convicted and received prison time) and is trying to make himself look better by creating a conspiracy theory...or, he could be telling the truth. The public will never know, unless somehow another cheat is exposed. Given the prevalence of proven corruption of soccer officials, and the proliferation of legal and illegal gambling, corruption probably has a greater hold on all professional sports than anyone is willing to admit.
In the cases of both inherent bias and blatant corruption the league seems not to particularly care. They are making money and that is apparently all that matters. TV contracts are more lucrative when the most popular players and teams go the farthest in the playoffs, ultimately/hopefully winning championships. So long as this is happening, the league seems disinterested in exposing or changing anything. The NBA has the greatest disparity of any professional league and thus more dynasties than any other league. More than any other sport you can count on the same teams making the playoffs year after year and the same teams missing the playoffs year after year. The emergence of a team from the also-rans to the elite almost never happens. The self-centered and self-interested owners will tell you that this is because the 'good' teams universally have better management. Posh! NBA officiating paves the way for the maintenance of the status quo. Also, salary cap or no salary cap, the best players all end up playing for the 'good' or 'traditional' markets because everybody knows that's the only path to winning. If the owners' claims of poverty are even remotely true, is it any wonder that the have-nots aren't making (enough) money when they cannot succeed on the court? It isn't the players causing the problem, it is the league and the owners that are at the root of all the NBA's problems, but it will be up to the players to solve them, mainly in the form of financial givebacks -- money is the ultimate band-aid -- and the (relative) poor will support the wealthy-beyond-belief.
Basketball is in trouble.
Interestingly, the indoor team sports (basketball and hockey) have smaller rosters than the outdoor sports (baseball, football and soccer), so the cost of athlete contracts are minimized and they are still in trouble.
The NBA might be on the brink of complete disaster. Or it might be on the brink of exploiting its players in a manner that hasn't been seen since the advent of free agency in the 1960s and 1970s. The players have been locked out for many months. There is no end in sight. The owners have decided that they aren't making enough money and have decided that they will boost their profit margin on the backs of the athletes. At the same time the owners have refused all requests to back up their claims with proof in the form of financial numbers. Outside observers note that revenues have climbed every year for decades and the industry pulls in multiple billions each year, yet somehow, the owners are not only not making enough, but actually losing money!
First of all, I believe that anyone who makes a claim and refuses to substantiate their claim is almost assuredly lying, or at the very least, stretching the truth to an absurd degree. No rational person would give their trust in such a situation, but that is exactly what NBA owners are telling the players to do -- "just trust us!" Second, most owners are multi-billionaires that have been incredibly successful in their other business pursuits. The notion that they can't find a way to make their multi-billion dollar industry profitable without forcing a 15-20% rollback in player salaries as well as dozens of other structural concessions in collective bargaining is absolutely ludicrous! If they were this inept at business they never would have become wealthy in the first place!
What appears to be happening is that the owners feel they aren't making enough money by being franchise owners and operators. In other words, their invested money would do better in other ventures, which implies that the opportunity cost of being an owner is very high. The logical thing to do in such situations is to reinvest your capital in more profitable ventures. That is what business is about! But owners are alpha males of the first order. By and large they made their obscene fortunes by being ruthless and cutthroat. Getting out of the sports franchise ownership business would feel like losing to them. These people never lose. They manipulate the rules until it is impossible for them to lose. Winning is the only option. Charlie Sheen to the nth degree. So, instead of recognizing that sports franchise ownership is not a high return industry and moving their money to better investments they have planted their feet into the ground and will move mountains to make it a more profitable industry and anyone in their way will suffer!
For what it's worth, most intelligent people recognize that sports franchise ownership is not a money maker. Few if any owners are making their fortune on sports entertainment. Pundits basically refer to franchises as "toys" for the ultra-wealthy. They are status symbols and allow former and wannabe athletes to live out their sports fantasies at the ownership and management level. Anyone who purchases a sports franchise in the 21st Century and expects it to be their bread and butter is delusional. The NFL makes money, well, except apparently the Detroit Lions who are managing to lose money. Given how Detroit has been hit as hard or harder by the economic downturns of the past decade than any other North American city perhaps this is not completely unexpected. A select few MLB franchises make real money and only a few more operate at a profit at all. The NHL has some franchises that make money but other than the Toronto Maple Leafs none of them make significant profits. Why the NBA owners think that they should universally be making money hand over fist must be a product of ego and hubris as it is certainly not based in realism.
And then there's the players. NBA players are not very sympathetic. They may represent 'labour' in this dispute but the typical fan cannot identify millionaires as 'labour'. It is only relative to the billionaire owners that they seem to be the disadvantaged 'poor'. In a battle between billionaires and millionaires no one gets the public's sympathy.
That does not mean that the public doesn't take sides. They definitely take sides. In almost all cases fans and the public both side with ownership. It's completely ironic but explainable too. In a society weaned on The American Dream the public is predisposed to look favorably on the wealthy. No one looks beneath the surface and asks questions like "how did they become wealthy?" Surely some billionaires became super-rich by pure entrepreneurship. They saw a market need that was not being addressed, formed a company to fill that need, did the job better than anybody else and became rich by making life better for their customers.
This is not the typical story. Most people come to extreme wealth in less than entirely wholesome manners. Taxes are avoided either illegally or by lobbying politicians to reduce their tax burden. The 'bribe' known as lobbying is cheaper in the long run than meeting their moral and legal tax obligations. Monopolies and oligopolies are formed and the public gets gouged. Monopolies are leveraged into other markets in grossly anti-competitive fashion. Companies with potentially threatening new innovations are purchased before they can come to market and affect the bottom line. The pending innovation is sometimes incorporated into the established company's products and is sometimes quashed -- which is never in the public interest. Stereotypically, the wealthy don't bother to watch on whose heads and hands they step on the way up as they have no intention to ever allow themselves the indignity of having to climb back down. In rare cases laws beyond the scope of Antitrust are broken in various cost-cutting measures meant to improve the profit margin. Likewise, ethics are often a casualty of big business. Manufacturing is shipped offshore to sweatshops employing children to reduce costs, regardless of the drastic negative effect the lost jobs have on the local economy and regardless of the human rights violations happening on foreign soil away from prying eyes. Polluting is rampant and either hidden or environmental agencies are paid to look the other way. Ultimately, few fortunes are built in a fashion that will get the profiteering decision makers into Heaven. But we are awed by their success, nonetheless, and put them on a pedestal as paragons of virtue, wishing we could be like them.
The players on the other hand are perceived as opportunists who have little to no value to the economy outside of their athletic ability. In other words, if they didn't have their sport in which to make a fortune they would be working class stiffs living paycheck to paycheck. As such, athletes should take whatever pittance the owners throw their way and be thankful for it. The fact that the athletes are often more highly educated than the owners actually works against them! The public is alienated by education and intelligence as they can't relate to either. "Dubya" managed to portray the educated as "the elite", people to be held in scorn and marginalized, while portraying the super wealthy as "the ordinary guy"...and America ate it up, hook, line and sinker! What is incredibly ironic is that the likelihood of a person escaping the ranks of the poor or middle class and becoming wealthy through sport are greater than their chances to become wealthy by other means. Sportsmen and athletes are the very embodiment of the American Dream and yet we look at them with disdain.
Here's some common sense that seems to be lost on the masses. On the whole, money is not made in sports on the acuity of owners or management. It is made on the skill and popularity of the athletes. How many NBA owners can you name? For most people the number is two, the most notorious two -- Mark Cuban and Michael Jordan -- or less! If the owners are mostly unknown, how can you attribute any portion of ticket sales or television revenue to the owners? The athletes are the only commodity of sports and have every right to demand as much money as the market is willing to bear. That is the nature of capitalist, free market economics. (Actually, I think the entire industry is broken and all parties should be making no more than 10% of their current earnings, with the other 90% either being 'returned' to the consumer in the form of lower ticket prices or being contributed to worthy charities.)
Another piece of common sense is that the contractual concessions and salary reductions the owners seek amount to a request for the players to protect the owners from themselves! When a player signs for $30 million dollars a year, or $1 million for that matter, no one is holding gun to the head of the owner forcing them to offer that contract! The owners would never make the kind of decisions they make in sports in their other businesses! So, because the less affluent billionaire owners suddenly can't seem to manage a budget they are going to take it out on the players. It all comes down to the egos of the owners. They cannot abide losing so spend money they don't have in a vain attempt to win. They all end up doing it, so overspending doesn't guarantee anything beyond blowing their budgets. (When only some of them do it, like in MLB and the English Premiership (soccer), money does buy success.)
Another deep dark secret of the NBA is something known as BRI -- Basketball Related Income. Ticket sales, direct television, Internet and radio contracts and sale of merchandise and memorabilia (replica uniforms, caps, etc.) count in BRI. ALL the NBA contract negotiations revolve around BRI. What the owners aren't telling you is that they are making a mint off of their franchises in areas that don't count as BRI. For example, a great many of the franchise owners also own various media. They use their franchises as cheap or free content for their media. All the money made by these media wings of the owner's conglomerate doesn't contribute a penny to BRI. Generally, these moneys are comparable to the BRI itself! So, while the team as an independent business unit may be losing money on paper the owners are making very tidy sums as a result of league operations. The NFL, for all its failings, doesn't make a distinction between profits made directly and indirectly from the operation of the league. Good for them for being so up front. The NBA, however, does make that distinction. It's like a huge tax shelter -- they make money but avoid paying taxes by an act of accounting. IMHO, this kind of obfuscation are merely lies of omission, and are thus still lies.
[Small tangent]
For what it's worth, creative accounting is being used everywhere by owners and management to exploit investors and employees alike. Tens of thousands of investors and stars of Hollywood motion pictures whose contracts call for a percentage of profits have never seen a red cent because, on paper, movies that grossed hundreds of millions of dollars seemingly lost money. If they lost money, how are the fat cats in control making money hand over fist? Lawsuits stagnate in court -- studio lawyers ensure that it costs these cheated investors more money in legal expenses to recoup their rightful earnings than the earnings are worth. This is done because human greed knows no bounds and because they know they can get away with it! Justice is indeed blind, but not in a good way.
[end of tangent]
Finally, like much of the financial world today, money isn't make on the operation of business. In terms of public holdings the proceeds from the operation of business are paid out as dividends. Dividends represent a very small portion of the growth of wealth. The value of the stocks themselves is what matters these days and often the value of stock has little to do with actual earnings or even earning potential. Speculation and psychology play a big part in stock valuation. Sports franchises are exactly the same. The owners don't make much money from the operation of these franchises. They make the real money by selling the franchise for twice what they paid for it. In general, franchise values, particularly for prestige franchises, only go up, so there isn't much in the way of risk involved in ownership, in spite of what the owners and their PR machines (including their League Commissioners) tell you.
Frankly, the athletes experience more risk than the owners! How many times have you heard someone tell a child that their chances of making the big leagues are somewhere between slim and none and they had better place a lot of attention and effort on a back-up plan just in case they fall short of their professional goals and their dreams of making it rich in sports. Perhaps you've done it yourself. Kids are highly resistant to listening to adults, especially parents. Somehow they always seem to think they know better than the people who have experienced everything they (the kids) have and much, much more and thus have earned the wisdom of age. A child's intuition, hope and tenuous grasp of logic generally wins the day. For what it's worth, the kids that don't invest any time in a backup plan and devote themselves exclusively to their dream are often the ones that make it. Of course, talent is required but hard work and unswerving dedication go a long way, too. In either case, the amount of time and money invested in the quest for a professional sports career is much riskier for a have-not kid than any risk the owners experience by operating a franchise! Yes, the owners put up more money, but their return on investment is astronomically higher than that of athletes. (Not many athletes complete college and those that do often have degrees that are little more than a piece of paper. The athlete that graduates with a (functional) degree in law, medicine, engineering, hard science or education (or other profession) are few and far between. Their degrees generally qualify them for virtually no form of gainful employment.)
Based on news coverage, it is pretty clear that the owners had no intention of bargaining in good faith. They had a goal in mind and nothing short of achieving that goal today would suffice. (In other businesses, management might seek smaller concessions today and seek further concessions in the next Collective Bargaining Agreement, but the NBA wants it all now! They aren't willing to risk the possibility that the economic reality of the NBA might improve in the future, jeopardizing their ability to leverage further concessions from the Player's Union in subsequent CBAs.) The players have moved significantly from their starting position. They have accepted the fact that they are going to come out losers in these negotiations even though they don't accept the assertions by the NBA that they are leeching money. Ownership hasn't really moved. What little movement there was merely changed completely unrealistic and unfair positions to less unrealistic and unfair positions. This is standard practice -- the owners never expected to achieve the originally offered deal.. You always ask for more than for what you are willing to settle. In this case, the demands were so radical and drastic that the starting position was simultaneously comical and desperately sad. The owners weren't even hiding the fact that they were bargaining in bad faith. They issued ultimatums like "take this deal or the next offer will be much, much worse for you." (The point of bargaining is for two differing positions to move towards each other, not away from each other.)
Given that the owners had no intention of bargaining in good faith, the players were left with two choices. They could let the owners get away with highway robbery and take a bad deal. The other option was to reject the bad deal and walk away from the farcical negotiations, specifically pointing to the owners' bad faith, and dissolve the union. Unions are only worth something to its members if it can do a better job negotiating contracts and working conditions than the individuals could manage separately. There's no point in paying dues to an organization that can achieve nothing.
The absence of a union opens the door for an Antitrust lawsuit against the NBA. The only recourse for players is to appeal to the courts of law. All major team sports have been in violation of America's Antitrust legislation for a century. Baseball, America's National Pastime, received exemption from Congress from Antitrust laws. That having been said, if it could be demonstrated that this exemption was no longer in the best interest of the American People it would disappear in a heartbeat. None of the other sports leagues have similar exemption. The assertion of Antitrust violations have never really been tested in court. The NFL Player's Association made a weak attempt to challenge the NFL earlier this year. The initial results favored the players but ultimately a higher court overturned the ruling and sided with ownership.
If the players succeed in their court claims that the NBA is operating in violation of Antitrust laws it is unclear how this would affect future operations. There is no reason to believe that such a ruling would directly result in better contracts for players. In fact, there may be no change in internal economics at all. Worse, the owners may decide to be punitive on top of being greedy and offer even less "to make up for lost revenues resulting from the lockout." First of all, the owners are locking out the players, not the players striking against the owners. Games aren't being played because the owners refuse to stage them. Any "lost revenue" is a result of owner decisions, not player malpractice or malfeasance and the owenrs have no leg to stand on demanding recompense. Second of all, the NBA is claiming that owners are losing money by operating under the current CBA with current player contracts. If they would lose money by operating, then surely they are saving money by locking out the players! In that case, there isn't a single dollar that needs to be "made up"! The owners would simply be using this as an opportunity to further pull the wool over the public's eyes and gouge the players even deeper.
In the terrible eight years suffered under Dubya, the Supreme Court was stacked with very thinly veiled ideological conservatives. With Republicans having control of all three Houses (Representatives, Senate and White) there was nothing that could be done to prevent these politically incorrect, politically motivated and basically unethical appointments. The bottom line is that the players have no hope whatsoever of wining this matter in the courts. They may win in a local circuit court. They may win in the Court of Appeal. But they are guaranteed to lose when the matter reaches the Supreme Court which is completely in bed with Big Business and the super-wealthy.
But it doesn't really matter...it won't get that far. Obscenely paid lawyers representing the owners will use every trick in the book (and will probably invent a few new ones!) to delay the procession of this case through the courts, that is, if they can't derail it entirely! Only a couple of the owners make a substantial portion of their income, directly or indirectly, via the operation of the NBA. The rest will continue to have annual earnings on the order of $100 million upward to $2 billion! If the NBA never plays another game, they will simply write off the franchises as losses and gladly take the associated tax breaks.
All but a couple of the players make their money directly from their NBA contracts. The few that could live off of their significant endorsement deals will find those deals disappearing -- players that don't play make poor spokespersons for sponsoring companies. So, in effect, all the players make their living from the operation of the NBA. They can't afford to continue to forgo 'average' annual incomes of $4 million when the 'average' player has a career lasting only 4 years. (Significantly more than 50% play 4 years or less.) They are making a stand on moral grounds and they can't possibly win. Given that this contract dispute is part of a larger phenomenon of the rich getting richer faster and to greater extremes than ever before and the middle class (and relatively speaking the players are the middle class of that particular subsection of the economy) seeing their standard of living rapidly eroding the players are essentially taking one for the team, meaning us. The best they can really hope for is forcing the American media and American public to take a long, hard look at what is happening on their watch. It is unlikely that the media will be paying attention, and if they don't the public won't even be aware of the significance of what's happening.
My personal preference is that the owners be forced to sell their franchises -- at a major loss, the cost of their hubris -- to owners that recognize that sports ownership is a 'big toy for big boys' and a status symbol and have no expectation to make significant money. You may feel that this makes no sense. Neither does multi-billionaires extorting cities and states for hundreds of millions to billions of dollars to build brand-spanking new, state-of-the-art stadiums that they will completely own using only public money. The gravy train for the ultra-wealthy financed on the backs of athletes with the little guy's hard earned and scarce dollars needs to stop. (Don't even get me started on how the NCAA and its member schools exploit student athletes!) The new reality for the NBA will involve much lower levels of BRI due to lost goodwill / bad publicity and everyone will make less. This is reasonable when you consider the true value of their contributions to society relative to (relatively) poorly paid teachers, doctors, scientists and engineers. It is disgusting how entertainment is so enormously overvalued by modern society! Still, the split of revenue between the anonymous owners and star athletes will be more equitable and reasonable. Preferably this happens sooner rather than later.
Of course, this is not going to happen. The players will watch potential income evaporate every single day they are locked out. This is money they can never get back. In the end, they will come back to the table and take half of what the owners were offering before. Why? Because the system failed them, because the owners can get away with it and because the players have no other options.
There is a remote chance that the players will try to form their own league, owned by the players, and the NBA will become obsolete. NBA franchise values will become $0. I suspect that should this option be pursued by the players that the owners will sue on imaginary grounds and the courts will somehow agree with them, putting the kibosh on the players' attempts to be self-sufficient. Besides, the players would need somewhere to play these games and the owners they are being oppressed by are the very same owners of the athletic venues they would need to use. The owners could play it one of two ways. They could laugh at the players and their upstart league telling them to go to Hell. Or, they could charge 100 times the going rate for the rental of their facilities. Again, it all boils down to the fact that the players can't win. The deck is not only stacked in the owners favour, it is marked, too, and the owners know exactly what the next cards are going to be. Further, the dealer is an owner that can deal from the bottom of the deck without any chance of being detected. The owners cannot lose! The society that we've built and are so proud of has set things up so that the just cannot win. Power and money buy justice.
Even if/when the NBA once more puts the squeak of rubber soles back into the arenas they aren't out of the woods. Officiating in the NBA is an exercise in politics. The popular, big market teams get the calls. The superstars get the calls. The home team gets the calls. NBA officiating is terrible. In part this is human psychology. Officials cannot completely separate themselves from their own thinking or the human desire to please others. They please the audience by calling in favor of the home team. They please the most influential players, the superstars, by making calls in their favor. They please their bosses, the NBA itself, by ensuring that the most lucrative and popular teams make the playoffs and go farther in the playoffs by making calls for the big market "in" teams. All of these are subconscious processes and to some extent unavoidable. Regardless, officials should be aware of these inherent biases and be consciously avoiding them! They don't appear to be combating anything. The fans and pundits that are most steeped in testosterone and have been "drinking the Kool-Aid" for years will tell you that's just how it is. It is up to the journeyman, rookie and unheralded player, the visiting teams and the have-not franchises to suck it up and overcome the adversity. I'll never understand why inherent and obvious unfairness is explained away as a fundamental part of competition.
Also, it was revealed a number of years ago that at least one NBA referee (or exactly one, depending on who you believe) was corrupt and taking money on the side to call a game a certain way or ensure a certain outcomes for gamblers and gangsters, like "making a spread". He claims he wasn't alone and that he's been made a scapegoat so the league can say it dealt with the 'isolated' problem when in fact it continues unabated. He may be a bitter and miserable cheat that got caught and got punished (he was convicted and received prison time) and is trying to make himself look better by creating a conspiracy theory...or, he could be telling the truth. The public will never know, unless somehow another cheat is exposed. Given the prevalence of proven corruption of soccer officials, and the proliferation of legal and illegal gambling, corruption probably has a greater hold on all professional sports than anyone is willing to admit.
In the cases of both inherent bias and blatant corruption the league seems not to particularly care. They are making money and that is apparently all that matters. TV contracts are more lucrative when the most popular players and teams go the farthest in the playoffs, ultimately/hopefully winning championships. So long as this is happening, the league seems disinterested in exposing or changing anything. The NBA has the greatest disparity of any professional league and thus more dynasties than any other league. More than any other sport you can count on the same teams making the playoffs year after year and the same teams missing the playoffs year after year. The emergence of a team from the also-rans to the elite almost never happens. The self-centered and self-interested owners will tell you that this is because the 'good' teams universally have better management. Posh! NBA officiating paves the way for the maintenance of the status quo. Also, salary cap or no salary cap, the best players all end up playing for the 'good' or 'traditional' markets because everybody knows that's the only path to winning. If the owners' claims of poverty are even remotely true, is it any wonder that the have-nots aren't making (enough) money when they cannot succeed on the court? It isn't the players causing the problem, it is the league and the owners that are at the root of all the NBA's problems, but it will be up to the players to solve them, mainly in the form of financial givebacks -- money is the ultimate band-aid -- and the (relative) poor will support the wealthy-beyond-belief.
Basketball is in trouble.
Monday, November 14, 2011
Ladies Golf Is In Trouble
This will be a brief entry since it is a simple problem and was touched on briefly here: Men's Golf: PGA Tour.
The LPGA is in trouble.
The main problem that the LPGA is experiencing is the dominance of Asian, mostly Korean, golfers. There's nothing wrong with having Korean champions. However, it is unfortunately true that their success is bad news for the overall health of the LPGA.
Why? Americans are notoriously fickle about who they cheer for and who they label as their heroes. Foreigners have never been popular in American sports. The media does better portraying foreign athletes as villains for American athletes to overcome than it does embracing them. A good question rises from this: is the media demonizing foreigners making it difficult for Americans to embrace and cheer for them or do Americans naturally spurn foreigners and the media simply know which side their bread is buttered on?
Either way, foreign success generally means Americans tune out and find other things to do with their time. The LPGA already has to deal with the enormous gender bias present in American society. Men are almost completely disinterested in consuming any women's sports, amateur or professional. This is almost assuredly a symptom of discrimination. Men who desperately try to portray themselves as not being sexist pigs argue that the women just don't play the sports well enough to warrant watching them. That's total BS. If men loved the sport they would watch anybody play it, including totally inept children. Their insistence on watching men only has more to do with idol worship and vicarious dream fulfillment than any lack of skill, imagined or real, that female athletes may have. The rest is entirely sexism. As a result, tournament purses are tiny when compared to their male counterparts. Virtually all events on the Champions' Tour, formerly known as the Seniors' Tour, and even some 'minor league' men's golf tour events have larger purses than LPGA events! Advertisers and sponsors know that LPGA audiences are smaller and pay accordingly. The fact that many corporations seem to value male customers more than female customers and that LPGA audiences are predominantly female make matters worse. (BTW, I've never understood this -- is women's money less green than men's, or is this an institutional admission of significant gender inequality in earning, and thus spending, power?)
The only exceptions to this disinterest are the not-as-rare-as-one-would-think female athletes that become sex- or fashion symbols (past or present), like tennis' Anna Kournikova, Maria Sharapova, the Williams sisters, Gabby Sabatini, and Caroline Wozniacki; figure skating's Katarina Witt; downhill skier Lindsey Vonn; the endless WWE and UFC divas; volleyball's Gabrielle Reece and Misty May; cycling's Elizabeth Hatch; racing's Danica Patrick and Ashley Force; swimming's Amanda Beard; and golf's own Natalie Gulbis, Maria Verchenova and Jan Stevenson. They get men's attention, but not because of their athletic exploits. It is questionable as to whether these male viewers count as consumers where advertisers are concerned. Perhaps they are considered to not be in the right, ahem, frame of mind at that time to be influenced by advertising?
Of the three LPGA icons mentioned above one has long since retired (there is no equivalent of the Champions' Tour for women) and one hasn't yet made an impact on the golf course. Only Gulbis is relevant and popular with men. Michelle Wie could conceivably join that list. She has the looks for it and also has the game, but is perhaps too squeaky clean to do the kind of modeling that propels women to sex-symbol status.
While we're on the topic of Wie, she should be a reason for people, male or female, to tune in to the LPGA, sex-symbol or not! Unfortunately, she's spent a significant part of past decade (she started competing at 13 and she's 22 now) trying to make it among the men instead of learning to win against or dominate the field of women. She never did manage to make a cut on the men's tour events in which she received a sponsor's exemption and I think it has been much too much of a distraction for her. She hasn't yet won a major championship, although she has been runner-up and is still quite young. She has the talent to be #1 and the beauty and personality to be the iconic American LPGA champion but hasn't yet realized that potential. She also has major appeal in Asian markets for obvious reasons. At least she's stopped chasing the Woman Power dream of competing with the men. When Annika Sorenstam tried to achieve the same milestone she had already been at the very top of the LPGA leader board for years. She earned the right to eschew the LPGA in favor of making a breakthrough for women in the PGA. I blame Wie's father for this distraction at a point far too early in her career.
In any case, the foreign dominance has been exacerbated by the fact that many of the Asian champions haven't been able to communicate effectively with their American audiences. Instead of speaking in fluent or even marginal English, of which they were incapable or uncomfortable doing, they spoke in halting, broken English or through interpreters. It is difficult for a winsome personality to shine through under these circumstances. This has alienated an already unwelcoming American audience.
Recognizing this problem, the LPGA attempted to pass regulations requiring players to learn English. This didn't go over well. The foreign players (and their home nations) cried foul and amazingly so did the American public. Complaints cited the rule as being discriminatory and basically unenforceable. Does the fact that Americans largely rejected this attempt at making Asian players more US-friendly mean that they are ready to embrace non-English-speaking Asian champions? Of course not! It means that the American public is fickle and wants to be able to have things both ways. They want to have their cake and eat it too. In other words, Asian players shouldn't be forced to learn and communicate in English, the expectation is that they should do it of their own accord, presumably for love of the American paycheck if not the American public! If it hasn't already happened then it's probably not going to happen and the American public will forget that they shot themselves in the foot by complaining and will continue to be disinterested due to foreign player dominance.
I don't know what the solution is. Maybe the problem with their earlier attempt at regulating communication skills was that they did it openly? Maybe this is something that has to be done behind the scenes? How you would keep such an effort under wraps is beyond me but that might be the only 'easy' way out. Barring that, the LPGA has to hope that the trend changes and some American players begin to dominate. And, as sexist as it may be, it really wouldn't hurt if they also happen to be totally hot super cuties!
Ladies golf is in trouble.
The LPGA is in trouble.
The main problem that the LPGA is experiencing is the dominance of Asian, mostly Korean, golfers. There's nothing wrong with having Korean champions. However, it is unfortunately true that their success is bad news for the overall health of the LPGA.
Why? Americans are notoriously fickle about who they cheer for and who they label as their heroes. Foreigners have never been popular in American sports. The media does better portraying foreign athletes as villains for American athletes to overcome than it does embracing them. A good question rises from this: is the media demonizing foreigners making it difficult for Americans to embrace and cheer for them or do Americans naturally spurn foreigners and the media simply know which side their bread is buttered on?
Either way, foreign success generally means Americans tune out and find other things to do with their time. The LPGA already has to deal with the enormous gender bias present in American society. Men are almost completely disinterested in consuming any women's sports, amateur or professional. This is almost assuredly a symptom of discrimination. Men who desperately try to portray themselves as not being sexist pigs argue that the women just don't play the sports well enough to warrant watching them. That's total BS. If men loved the sport they would watch anybody play it, including totally inept children. Their insistence on watching men only has more to do with idol worship and vicarious dream fulfillment than any lack of skill, imagined or real, that female athletes may have. The rest is entirely sexism. As a result, tournament purses are tiny when compared to their male counterparts. Virtually all events on the Champions' Tour, formerly known as the Seniors' Tour, and even some 'minor league' men's golf tour events have larger purses than LPGA events! Advertisers and sponsors know that LPGA audiences are smaller and pay accordingly. The fact that many corporations seem to value male customers more than female customers and that LPGA audiences are predominantly female make matters worse. (BTW, I've never understood this -- is women's money less green than men's, or is this an institutional admission of significant gender inequality in earning, and thus spending, power?)
The only exceptions to this disinterest are the not-as-rare-as-one-would-think female athletes that become sex- or fashion symbols (past or present), like tennis' Anna Kournikova, Maria Sharapova, the Williams sisters, Gabby Sabatini, and Caroline Wozniacki; figure skating's Katarina Witt; downhill skier Lindsey Vonn; the endless WWE and UFC divas; volleyball's Gabrielle Reece and Misty May; cycling's Elizabeth Hatch; racing's Danica Patrick and Ashley Force; swimming's Amanda Beard; and golf's own Natalie Gulbis, Maria Verchenova and Jan Stevenson. They get men's attention, but not because of their athletic exploits. It is questionable as to whether these male viewers count as consumers where advertisers are concerned. Perhaps they are considered to not be in the right, ahem, frame of mind at that time to be influenced by advertising?
Of the three LPGA icons mentioned above one has long since retired (there is no equivalent of the Champions' Tour for women) and one hasn't yet made an impact on the golf course. Only Gulbis is relevant and popular with men. Michelle Wie could conceivably join that list. She has the looks for it and also has the game, but is perhaps too squeaky clean to do the kind of modeling that propels women to sex-symbol status.
While we're on the topic of Wie, she should be a reason for people, male or female, to tune in to the LPGA, sex-symbol or not! Unfortunately, she's spent a significant part of past decade (she started competing at 13 and she's 22 now) trying to make it among the men instead of learning to win against or dominate the field of women. She never did manage to make a cut on the men's tour events in which she received a sponsor's exemption and I think it has been much too much of a distraction for her. She hasn't yet won a major championship, although she has been runner-up and is still quite young. She has the talent to be #1 and the beauty and personality to be the iconic American LPGA champion but hasn't yet realized that potential. She also has major appeal in Asian markets for obvious reasons. At least she's stopped chasing the Woman Power dream of competing with the men. When Annika Sorenstam tried to achieve the same milestone she had already been at the very top of the LPGA leader board for years. She earned the right to eschew the LPGA in favor of making a breakthrough for women in the PGA. I blame Wie's father for this distraction at a point far too early in her career.
In any case, the foreign dominance has been exacerbated by the fact that many of the Asian champions haven't been able to communicate effectively with their American audiences. Instead of speaking in fluent or even marginal English, of which they were incapable or uncomfortable doing, they spoke in halting, broken English or through interpreters. It is difficult for a winsome personality to shine through under these circumstances. This has alienated an already unwelcoming American audience.
Recognizing this problem, the LPGA attempted to pass regulations requiring players to learn English. This didn't go over well. The foreign players (and their home nations) cried foul and amazingly so did the American public. Complaints cited the rule as being discriminatory and basically unenforceable. Does the fact that Americans largely rejected this attempt at making Asian players more US-friendly mean that they are ready to embrace non-English-speaking Asian champions? Of course not! It means that the American public is fickle and wants to be able to have things both ways. They want to have their cake and eat it too. In other words, Asian players shouldn't be forced to learn and communicate in English, the expectation is that they should do it of their own accord, presumably for love of the American paycheck if not the American public! If it hasn't already happened then it's probably not going to happen and the American public will forget that they shot themselves in the foot by complaining and will continue to be disinterested due to foreign player dominance.
I don't know what the solution is. Maybe the problem with their earlier attempt at regulating communication skills was that they did it openly? Maybe this is something that has to be done behind the scenes? How you would keep such an effort under wraps is beyond me but that might be the only 'easy' way out. Barring that, the LPGA has to hope that the trend changes and some American players begin to dominate. And, as sexist as it may be, it really wouldn't hurt if they also happen to be totally hot super cuties!
Ladies golf is in trouble.
Professional Sports Is In Trouble
Pretty much every (North American) professional team sport is in trouble and some solo sports are too. They are in danger of making themselves obsolete, and pricing themselves out of the reach of the common person. They have rules problems, money problems and even corruption problems. I'll touch on each sport here and then devote a separate blog to each.
(Links will be active as soon as I post the associated blog. If the link doesn't work, check back in a day or two and it will work.)
Men's Golf: PGA Tour
Without a competitive Tiger Woods, what is it?
Women's Golf: LPGA Tour
The predominance of Asian players is alienating the western fan, you know, the ones with money.
Basketball: NBA
With billionaires locking out millionaires everybody loses.
Baseball: MLB
It all start with Selig.
Hockey: NHL
Concussions, concussions, concussions. Oh, and fighting too.
Football: NFL, CFL
The NFL is perhaps the only league that isn't in trouble. Multi-billion dollar TV contracts will do that. Still, they only narrowly avoided serious trouble by ending the labour dispute (owner/league instituted lock out) in time to have a complete regular season this year. They did manage to lose some preseason games and while they are only exhibition games they do affect the bottom line.
The CFL is in trouble and has been for years. The bigger the market, the lower the interest in the CFL. Further, the NFL has changed the way they draft and employ quarterbacks which may prove to be the death knell for the CFL.
Soccer: MLS
MLS has the same problems that all of soccer/football has: poor officiating and potential corruption. Throw in middling talent and you don't have a recipe for success.
(Links will be active as soon as I post the associated blog. If the link doesn't work, check back in a day or two and it will work.)
Men's Golf: PGA Tour
Without a competitive Tiger Woods, what is it?
Women's Golf: LPGA Tour
The predominance of Asian players is alienating the western fan, you know, the ones with money.
Basketball: NBA
With billionaires locking out millionaires everybody loses.
Baseball: MLB
It all start with Selig.
Hockey: NHL
Concussions, concussions, concussions. Oh, and fighting too.
Football: NFL, CFL
The NFL is perhaps the only league that isn't in trouble. Multi-billion dollar TV contracts will do that. Still, they only narrowly avoided serious trouble by ending the labour dispute (owner/league instituted lock out) in time to have a complete regular season this year. They did manage to lose some preseason games and while they are only exhibition games they do affect the bottom line.
The CFL is in trouble and has been for years. The bigger the market, the lower the interest in the CFL. Further, the NFL has changed the way they draft and employ quarterbacks which may prove to be the death knell for the CFL.
Soccer: MLS
MLS has the same problems that all of soccer/football has: poor officiating and potential corruption. Throw in middling talent and you don't have a recipe for success.
Golf Is In Trouble
For the past 15 years (or so) the PGA has enjoyed unprecidented popularity and it can be explained in two words: Tiger Woods.
There was so much hype about this young amateur that he couldn't possibly live up to the expectations, yet he did! As his popularity and notoriety grew and he transitioned from amateur to professional the PGA and their TV partners began to design broadcasts around Tiger. Watching the PGA on television was a bit like being in the gallery and walking the course along with Tiger. Between his shots they aired highlights of the rest of the field and ran the all-important commercials.
This formula worked for more than a decade. Sponsors flocked to the PGA and committed record amounts in sponsorship money. Purses grew by leaps and bounds. Profits for the PGA and the networks that aired it grew as well. America and the world was fascinated by the enigmatic golfer and his quest for history. When he won it was good for golf. When he struggled it was good for golf, so long as they were short term struggles. He had an ungodly streak of leads held and a knack of reeling in the leaders in unlikely final-day comebacks. He was on pace to be the first athlete billionaire mainly because he had countless corporate sponsors.
The drama, or circus, that was Tiger peaked at the 2008 U.S. Open. He managed to win the tournament and immediately thereafter revealed that he had basically done so on one leg! Surgery soon followed and everyone was confident that he would rehab well and resume his assault of Jack Nicklaus' record 18 major "Grand Slam" Championships. The 2008 Open was Tiger's 14th major and he was only 32 at the time, giving him plenty of time to break the Nicklaus record. (Nicklaus was 46 when he won his final major, and Tiger is considered one of the fittest golfers on the tour so should be competitive for years to come.) The moment Tiger left the tour for his surgery and rehab television viewership dropped almost 50%!
2009 was an up and down year for Tiger. His play was inconsistent by his standards. He won 6 tournaments but none of them was a major. It was the first time in 5 years that he had failed to win a major and only the 4th time in his career that he had failed to win at least one in a season. Actually, he missed the cut at a major for only the second time in his professional career, the other time being immediately after the death of his father, Earl. For him, this is a disappointing year -- Tiger's focus on Nicklaus' record 18 majors is unrelenting. Still, he managed to win the FedEx Cup for the second time in its then 3-year history. His PGA 2009 season winnings of $10.5 million were the third highest of his career.
Then Armageddon struck Tiger's life. It was revealed that Tiger had had an extramarital relationship and it was later revealed that he'd done so with over a dozen women! When this became public his marriage melted down. He had a car accident in his own driveway and may or may not have been fleeing from his angry wife, Elin, who may or may not have brandished a golf club breaking the windshield of Tiger's Cadillac Escalade. The official story is that she 'liberated' him from the car when the door jammed as a result of the crash. The chaos in his personal life forced Woods to step away from golf indefinitely as he tried to repair his broken life.
That didn't really work out well. He finally spoke to the media about what happened in a very artificial, orchestrated press conference where only invited persons were admitted and he took no questions from the gathered press. So, really it was a public statement, not a press conference. Public reaction to this was not favourable for Tiger. Within the year his marriage ended in divorce and his idyllic life was permanently shattered. His quest to become the first athlete billionaire was for all intents and purposes over as the divorce settlement effectively halved his wealth. Further, he lost most of his endorsements and sponsorships drastically reducing his earning power as well. 2010 saw Tiger play very little professional golf and he was not as competitive as he had been in the past. He managed 2 Top-5 finishes in majors but the other 2 were only Top-30 finishes. He suffered from poor health and suffered even more from poor play. He didn't even qualify to compete for the FedEx Cup tour championship.
2011 was every bit as bad a year as 2010 and worse. He missed two majors and missed the cut in a third. He also ended a 12 year working relationship with caddie Steve Williams. Williams took the news incredibly badly and IMHO showed extreme poor taste and poor sportsmanship in his reaction. Williams' relationship with Woods had made him extremely wealthy and he showed no gratitude or appreciation for that instead choosing to portray the break as a betrayal. (It is estimated that Williams' share of Tiger's winnings was about $12 million!) The reasons Woods gave were actually in Williams' best interest, which proved to be true when Williams and new pro golf partner Adam Scott promptly won the 2011 World Golf Championships - Bridgestone Invitational. Williams chose to rub this in Woods' face and later in the year made an allegedly racist comment about Woods. Williams' defense was "I had a lot of anger in me about what happened (with Woods) and it all came out."
During this attempt at a comeback television ratings and tournament galleries have not been the same as when Tiger was in his prime. If Tiger doesn't recapture the golf game that made him so successful it is likely that these will both erode even further. Part of the problem is that for a dozen years the PGA and its television partners have focused so intently on Woods that the public doesn't really have any kind of relationship with most, possibly all, other golfers. When others succeed, few seem to get excited about it.
Making the problem worse is the overall play of American golfers. Of late, international players have been dominant and the American viewer has always been fickle when it comes to rooting for 'foreign' athletes. This dynamic is even more extreme for the LPGA where Asians have dominated for some years now. Too many of these champions speak little to no English and communicate with the media through interpreters. This makes it difficult for the American fan to embrace them. The PGA doesn't really suffer from this problem as their 'foreign' champions are largely European (and many of them from the English-speaking UK), Australian, English-speaking Africans, etc.
So, the PGA and golf-broadcasting TV networks are reaping what they have been sowing for more than a decade. Too many golf fans are actually Tiger Woods fan and have very little to cheer about right now. Too many skilled golfers are effectively anonymous to the American golf enthusiast. The fact that Tiger's squeaky clean image, albeit sterile and typically laced with profanity, has been badly tarnished making him seem as much a villain as a hero has driven others away from golf entirely. It may be too late to fix this and recover lost audiences or even retain those that remain, but even if it isn't, the PGA and TV don't seem particularly well equipped to make any kind of change. They seem adamant to sink or swim on the fortunes of Tiger Woods. If the Tiger of old never returns the PGA is going to fall on hard times. Audience and gallery sizes will continue to drop, sponsorships will become less lucrative or dry up entirely and events may even cease to exist.
Golf is in trouble...
There was so much hype about this young amateur that he couldn't possibly live up to the expectations, yet he did! As his popularity and notoriety grew and he transitioned from amateur to professional the PGA and their TV partners began to design broadcasts around Tiger. Watching the PGA on television was a bit like being in the gallery and walking the course along with Tiger. Between his shots they aired highlights of the rest of the field and ran the all-important commercials.
This formula worked for more than a decade. Sponsors flocked to the PGA and committed record amounts in sponsorship money. Purses grew by leaps and bounds. Profits for the PGA and the networks that aired it grew as well. America and the world was fascinated by the enigmatic golfer and his quest for history. When he won it was good for golf. When he struggled it was good for golf, so long as they were short term struggles. He had an ungodly streak of leads held and a knack of reeling in the leaders in unlikely final-day comebacks. He was on pace to be the first athlete billionaire mainly because he had countless corporate sponsors.
The drama, or circus, that was Tiger peaked at the 2008 U.S. Open. He managed to win the tournament and immediately thereafter revealed that he had basically done so on one leg! Surgery soon followed and everyone was confident that he would rehab well and resume his assault of Jack Nicklaus' record 18 major "Grand Slam" Championships. The 2008 Open was Tiger's 14th major and he was only 32 at the time, giving him plenty of time to break the Nicklaus record. (Nicklaus was 46 when he won his final major, and Tiger is considered one of the fittest golfers on the tour so should be competitive for years to come.) The moment Tiger left the tour for his surgery and rehab television viewership dropped almost 50%!
2009 was an up and down year for Tiger. His play was inconsistent by his standards. He won 6 tournaments but none of them was a major. It was the first time in 5 years that he had failed to win a major and only the 4th time in his career that he had failed to win at least one in a season. Actually, he missed the cut at a major for only the second time in his professional career, the other time being immediately after the death of his father, Earl. For him, this is a disappointing year -- Tiger's focus on Nicklaus' record 18 majors is unrelenting. Still, he managed to win the FedEx Cup for the second time in its then 3-year history. His PGA 2009 season winnings of $10.5 million were the third highest of his career.
Then Armageddon struck Tiger's life. It was revealed that Tiger had had an extramarital relationship and it was later revealed that he'd done so with over a dozen women! When this became public his marriage melted down. He had a car accident in his own driveway and may or may not have been fleeing from his angry wife, Elin, who may or may not have brandished a golf club breaking the windshield of Tiger's Cadillac Escalade. The official story is that she 'liberated' him from the car when the door jammed as a result of the crash. The chaos in his personal life forced Woods to step away from golf indefinitely as he tried to repair his broken life.
That didn't really work out well. He finally spoke to the media about what happened in a very artificial, orchestrated press conference where only invited persons were admitted and he took no questions from the gathered press. So, really it was a public statement, not a press conference. Public reaction to this was not favourable for Tiger. Within the year his marriage ended in divorce and his idyllic life was permanently shattered. His quest to become the first athlete billionaire was for all intents and purposes over as the divorce settlement effectively halved his wealth. Further, he lost most of his endorsements and sponsorships drastically reducing his earning power as well. 2010 saw Tiger play very little professional golf and he was not as competitive as he had been in the past. He managed 2 Top-5 finishes in majors but the other 2 were only Top-30 finishes. He suffered from poor health and suffered even more from poor play. He didn't even qualify to compete for the FedEx Cup tour championship.
2011 was every bit as bad a year as 2010 and worse. He missed two majors and missed the cut in a third. He also ended a 12 year working relationship with caddie Steve Williams. Williams took the news incredibly badly and IMHO showed extreme poor taste and poor sportsmanship in his reaction. Williams' relationship with Woods had made him extremely wealthy and he showed no gratitude or appreciation for that instead choosing to portray the break as a betrayal. (It is estimated that Williams' share of Tiger's winnings was about $12 million!) The reasons Woods gave were actually in Williams' best interest, which proved to be true when Williams and new pro golf partner Adam Scott promptly won the 2011 World Golf Championships - Bridgestone Invitational. Williams chose to rub this in Woods' face and later in the year made an allegedly racist comment about Woods. Williams' defense was "I had a lot of anger in me about what happened (with Woods) and it all came out."
During this attempt at a comeback television ratings and tournament galleries have not been the same as when Tiger was in his prime. If Tiger doesn't recapture the golf game that made him so successful it is likely that these will both erode even further. Part of the problem is that for a dozen years the PGA and its television partners have focused so intently on Woods that the public doesn't really have any kind of relationship with most, possibly all, other golfers. When others succeed, few seem to get excited about it.
Making the problem worse is the overall play of American golfers. Of late, international players have been dominant and the American viewer has always been fickle when it comes to rooting for 'foreign' athletes. This dynamic is even more extreme for the LPGA where Asians have dominated for some years now. Too many of these champions speak little to no English and communicate with the media through interpreters. This makes it difficult for the American fan to embrace them. The PGA doesn't really suffer from this problem as their 'foreign' champions are largely European (and many of them from the English-speaking UK), Australian, English-speaking Africans, etc.
So, the PGA and golf-broadcasting TV networks are reaping what they have been sowing for more than a decade. Too many golf fans are actually Tiger Woods fan and have very little to cheer about right now. Too many skilled golfers are effectively anonymous to the American golf enthusiast. The fact that Tiger's squeaky clean image, albeit sterile and typically laced with profanity, has been badly tarnished making him seem as much a villain as a hero has driven others away from golf entirely. It may be too late to fix this and recover lost audiences or even retain those that remain, but even if it isn't, the PGA and TV don't seem particularly well equipped to make any kind of change. They seem adamant to sink or swim on the fortunes of Tiger Woods. If the Tiger of old never returns the PGA is going to fall on hard times. Audience and gallery sizes will continue to drop, sponsorships will become less lucrative or dry up entirely and events may even cease to exist.
Golf is in trouble...
Thursday, November 10, 2011
Sexual Abuse of Children & Penn. State
After the events of the past week at Pennsylvania State University I really need to talk about sexual predation of children. It has been called the worst and largest epidemic on the planet and I believe that to be true. It is the only current pandemic.
Unless you are speaking to a pedophile, you are unlikely to find anyone sympathetic to those that use children to satisfy their perverse and unnatural urges. I will never call them 'needs', the term that pedophiles and sometimes medical practitioners use. Their lives would go on with equal quality without indulging in their habitual crime against humanity so it clearly isn't a need. In spite of the fact that these predators have no open allies, laws and courts fail to understand the seriousness of the crime and fail to impose penalties commensurate with the offenses.
This is even more true in Canada than in the United States. Recent high profile cases in Canada have resulted in pathetically weak sentences. Two years less a day. Five years, but out on parole long before then. When released, the offenders are free to move anywhere in the world to begin anew and little if anything is done to warn their newly adopted communities of the threat that has just descended upon them. So the cycle continues -- this is a virtual guarantee.
Unlike many other criminal behaviours pedophilia has proven almost completely resistant to therapy. The damage is too fundamental, affecting too many parts of the brain and too many aspects of the psyche to be repaired. In the absence of cure, I think the world would be satisfied by repression of the behaviour, but pedophilia will not be repressed. The irony is that some pedophiles are wracked with guilt because of their urges and actions and are still not able to stop. I guess this is why you almost never hear of one-time offenders. Pedophiles always seem to have a huge roster of victims by the time they are brought to temporary justice. Often allegations against them are made and they somehow wiggle free of any repercussions. It is only years and many victims later that they are finally made to pay for their deviance and predatory actions.
Some people think that pedophilia isn't a disease, at least not in the strictest sense. They paint it more as similar to a bad attitude or a simple lack of morals and ethics. Others say that it is the result of similar trauma experienced in their youth. This is garbage! It is not true that all pedophiles were abused themselves. Some do it spontaneously. Further, not every person who was victimized sexualizes children. I contend that these apologist theories are invented by pedophiles themselves. Also, if sexual abuse of children was simply a result of moral or ethical defect, why would so many pedophiles feel remorse? If they were truly morally bankrupt then they would see nothing wrong with their actions (see NAMBLA) and would instead claim to be the victims of persecution by a corrupt society. They would insist that children are supposed to be used in this fashion and those that don't do it are in fact the defective ones. Pedophiles with this view constitute a minority of the whole, not the majority, further proof that it is not merely the result of moral or ethical deficiencies.
So, why are these cancers not treated sufficiently seriously? Why are they not excised from society the way tumors are from a diseased body? The answer is simple. Money.
Short-sighted politicians, lawyers and judges, our lawmakers, are obsessed with money. The entirety of society is obsessed with money so this is not really that surprising. Still, we expect that people in those positions of power would be more morally upstanding. Instead, they follow the money, and in their opinion, child predation doesn't hurt the economy so it isn't that important. They couldn't be more wrong on multiple fronts. By their view, taking 'productive' members of society, i.e. the pedophiles, and placing them in jail hurts the economy and costs the State further money to house, feed and care for them while incarcerated. In their world view, it is a no-brainer. Penalties should be token attempts to appease an angry public so that they result in as little financial impact on the government's tight budgets. Our quiet complaints for longer sentences, which given the incredibly high occurrence of re-offending are the only logical way to protect the public's interest and safety, are ignored for financial reasons. These same politicians have no compunctions about wasting trillions on pork barrel spending or tax cuts for multinational mega-corporations and the wealthiest citizens (or in some cases to line their own pockets) but a hundred thousand dollars a year (at most) to keep a dangerous predator off the streets is too high a price to pay. It's pathetic and our tolerance of it is even more pathetic.
What lawmakers fail to understand is that the victims of these crimes are given a life sentence. They carry the scars of abuse their entire lives and you better believe that it keeps them from realizing their full economic potential. Millions of hours of productivity are wasted due to sick days, sometimes called mental health days, caused by the stress that they cannot escape. The fact that society seems to care so little makes this stress much, much worse. Each time a pedophile is slapped on the wrist the victims and their families (if they even know about the abuse) receive blows to the gut. Each time a pedophile is released or is found to have re-offended the victims suffer more than the criminal. The cost to the health care system for the scars of abuse is incalculable. Also, victims are often left with such despair that they believe that their only remaining course of action is to kill themselves. Suicide also has a negative economic impact. So, lawmakers' apathy and failure to examine the issue in stark detail leads them to believe that they are taking the financially prudent course of action, i.e. minimal consequences for pedophiles. And in doing so, they are actually hurting the economy. Another job well done by our elected officials!
Another indictment against the government and courts is that children are not adequately protected. The punishment doled out for a man who rapes a woman is almost always greater than what is levied against those that commit the same crime against children. (The gender of the child is not relevant.) How is this logical? Are crimes against children more palatable, tolerable or more understandable? Few people, if any, would suggest that children aren't more helpless, powerless and vulnerable than women, yet our protection of them is weaker. We like to call children "our future" but by our lack of detemination seemingly have no compunctions against exposing "our future" to the worst forms of abuse.
The only reason I can come up with for this illogical policy is that children cannot vote. Children cannot make politicians pay for their inaction. Sure, they grow up and eventually have the right to vote. I wouldn't be in the least bit surprised if their tendency to waive that right was much higher than in other populations due to complete disillusionment with the system. And who could blame them? Whether they grow up to vote or not politicians are banking on two outcomes. First, politicians hope that by the time child victims are old enough to vote they will be caught up in political ideology and will vote and lobby for reasons other than their nightmare experiences. Second, politicians are gambling that they will have left politics by the time the children are granted an electoral voice so no political price can be paid. In other words, by and large, politicians, like most human beings these days, will do every single self-interested thing that they think they can get away with and on the other hand will do nothing more for others than they absolutely must for survival. Under this microscope, we don't seem to be a very moral or ethical society. We hardly seem like a society at all! Where have civility and civilization gone?
In Penn State, a member of the athletic department staff has been accused of sexually abusing many boys over the past 15 years. This is terrible but is hardly international news. What makes this situation news is the fact that rumour of this activity has been floating around for almost all of the years in question! Assistant coach Sandusky 'retired' in 1999 at the age of 55. This is incredibly young for a college coach to retire. Actually, it is the prime of life in terms of coach careers. The first rumours of his clandestine activities came up just prior to his 'retirement'. This begs many questions. Did he retire or was he forced to resign? If the univeristy knew of these activities and forced the resignation/retirement doesn't that mean that they knew of the allegations? Further, while Sandusky was no longer an assistant coach at Penn State he still had full access to the university's campus and athletic facilities. Why? Sandusky was the leader of the children's charity he founded in 1977, The Second Mile (which it seems may have served as the vehicle for him to access children to prey upon). Was this sufficient reason to continue to allow Sandusky access at all levels? Why did the charity need access to college facilities? Aren't allegations cause enough to force the university to disavow all connections to the man? Or was this just Old Boys' Club mentality at its worst?
I'm going to point out what I consider a formality. Everything that has emerged falls under the category of allegations. Officially, until a court of law has determined his guilt Sandusky has done nothing wrong. Had there been one allegation, I would concur. A couple of days ago the number of boys that have made claims of abuse was reported as eight. Since then the number has grown reportedly to about 20. In my mind, with this many grievances it becomes difficult to maintain sterile objectivity and continue to maintain the innocence-until-proven-guilty-they-are-only-allegations posture. Almost impossible, actually. To say things don't look good is a huge understatement.
The results of the 1998 investigation are surprising given the fact that seemingly nothing was done. Sandusky admitted to having showered with boys and even to have hugged a boy while in the shower. Presumably both were naked at the time. He admitted that this was wrong and said he would no longer shower with boys. While it is true that hugs are not inherently sexual doesn't taking showers with boys and naked hugging speak of colossally bad judgment? Isn't this type of decision making cause to force the termination of whatever relationships allowed Sandusky access to boys in the first place. In this case, the campus polive and child welfare agency didn't think so. The fact that this matter was investigated primarily by campus police is ludicrous. Didn't anyone suggest that any campus organization lacked sufficient separation from the matter to be completely objective? One of the boys was identified as "victim 6" in the police reports. That means that in 1998 there were already at least 6 boys that had made allegations against Sandusky. The system completely failed these boys and all the boys since.
It has been suggested that Penn State is far too politically powerful in State College, PA to be held accountable for anything. Over the years it seems that these is cause to believe this. With the mess hitting the fan this past week the university has shown itself unused to, if not unable to, act decisively and ethically regarding this scandal. Last night they took a huge step in addressing that criticism by relieving both the university president and head coach Joe Paterno of duties. All that remains is for them to cancel the upcoming game, the three remaining games on the season, suspend the football program indefinitely and perhaps cancel the playoff game that is scheduled to take place in State College and they will have addressed matters to everyone's satisfaction. It's called damage control and ensuring the safety of the players, coaches and fans.
Everyone's satisfaction except apparently the students of Penn State. They demonstrated last night against the firing of coach Paterno. Paterno was made aware of the crimes that were taking place in the showers in 2002 when a graduate assistant reported having witnessed a sexual act between Sandusky and a boy. Paterno took this information to university administration. The university seems mostly to have buried the information. They did bar Sandusky from holding youth sports camps on campus, but did nothing when he merely relocated his camps to the university's Behrend campus, just outside Erie, PA, which continued until 2008. Paterno also seems to have done nothing after handing off to the university administration. At no point did his moral compass or even his curiosity compel him to follow up on his report to see what was happening. He was apparently satisfied that the matter as closed since Sandusky continued to have access to the university's facilities. Yesterday, Paterno said "I wish I had done more", and that the entire situation was "one of the great sorrows of [his] life."
In spite of logic, morality and Paterno's contrition, Penn State students demonstrated in protest of Paterno's dismissal. My reaction to this is to suggest that their parents immediately demand a total refund for all tuition paid over the course of these students' academic careers are Penn State on the grounds that they haven't learned anything! They are completely clueless. They are placing the good of the football program and the legacy of coach Paterno above the health and safety of at least 8 boys over the course of at least 40 counts of sexual impropriety. They somehow think that Paterno's dereliction of duty and failure to meet his moral obligations are not grounds for dismissal presumably since he officially met his legal obligations. The law is a strange thing. It is a living thing. Its development often lags behind the needs and desires of the society it is meant to serve. To argue that Paterno's satisfaction of his legal obligation allows him to wash his hands of all guilt is both naïve and offensive.
Obviously, crimes of this nature happen becomes criminals feel the need to offend and victimize others. But looked at from another viewpoint, crimes of this nature occur because we let them. On the one hand we rail against the crime and cry out for justice and/or punishment. Less often, we call for protection of children and less often still we call for compassion and understanding for the victims. When presented with vague evidence or some other indication of potential wrongdoing we tend to be evenly split.
Some of us act immediately. Those that have experienced the terror of this crime personally or secondarily flock to this banner as do most people who generally advocate on the behalf of children. The rest of us do what is easiest for us, which is nothing. In other words, we act solely in self-interest and laziness. "Don't rock the boat." "It's not my problem." "Let someone else do it." "It's probably not true anyway." "If it is true, it will come out without my action/intervention/sticking my neck out." Other motivators include disbelief. It is uncomfortable for us to think that the people close to us are bad or are doing bad things. That would reflect poorly upon us. After all, we chose to associate with these people -- if they are bad, we too must be bad, and that can never be admitted however true it might ring. In short, we make excuses. We come up with excuses to ignore our responsibilities and we all suffer as a result.
Tangent:
The back-story or origin behind the popular comic book character Spider-Man provides an allegory for this dynamic. Peter Parker, the man who has become Spider-Man uses his miraculous abilities to seek fame and fortune. He is presented with an opportunity to stop a burglar from stealing the money made from ticket sales and gambling on the wrestling matches in which he just competed. He was there to get paid for his performance. Instead of stopping the burglar, something he could have done with minimal effort given his new abilities, he gets out of the way and allows him to escape. This burglar goes on to kill a man while trying to make his getaway. That man turns out to be Peter Parker's uncle Ben Parker. By his own inaction, Peter had enabled the murder of his uncle. This is exactly what happens when we take the easy path and look the other way when wrongs occur, thus ignoring our moral responsibilities to look out for one another.
End tangent.
The bottom line is that each of us is 100% responsible for everything we do, or don't do. Further, we are completely responsible for all the consequences of our actions and inaction. No one would suggest that you can assume that other drivers on the road will look out for your safety -- it is up to you to assume 100% of the responsibility for your safety since you can count on others (eventually) failing to live up to theirs (intentionally or otherwise), putting you in mortal peril. This concept applies universally. Even Smokey the Bear had it right -- "Only you can stop forest fires." Don't wait for someone else to do it. If you have no qualms about letting others handle it you can rest assured that others will do the same allowing heinous and horrible things to happen. It is in our power to stop it, but only if we stop passing the buck. Politicians need to be pushed to do what is right, because what is tends not to be politically easiest.. So, go push! Force the powers that be, representatives that we elect to wield our power, to do what is right. Increase the penalties for crimes that are being taken too lightly.
In passing, I say the following without endorsing it. It is my attempt at thinking outside of the box. If the only way to protect society is to incarcerate offenders indefinitely, and this is deemed a budgetary impossibility there is one other option. We can turn our back on the Ten Commandments and other moral/religious imperatives and utilize the death penalty. It's a double-whammy. We kill, violating Commandment #5, and we judge harshly violating Matthew 7:1-2 ("Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you.") Oh, right. Many of us already utilize the death penalty. Ironically and hypocritically, it is often the case that the more fervently religious the person, the more likely they seem to support the death penalty.
Currently, the death penalty is even more expensive a proposition than life terms without the possibility of parole. The cost for state-appointed (and funded) lawyers and court time for near endless appeals and requests for clemency often dwarf the cost of incarceration. If we are going to kill criminals/people (and I don't think we should) there is a way to make it cost-neutral or even a money maker.
Televise it.
The Romans had the gore and violence of the Coliseum as a fate of choice for criminals and enemies of the State. The modern day equivalent is television. Put it on Pay-Per-View and recover the costs of applying the law by letting the private citizen pay the burden of those costs. There is no question this would attract an audience. Primarily the viewers would be proponents of the death penalty. Who better than they to foot the costs of execution? Executions the world over are already public. Clearly we don't object to people seeing state-imposed / state-sanctioned killing. How is airing it any different than admitting a gallery?
We flock to watch boxing and mixed martial arts. Some people watch auto racing hoping for the spectacle of a lethal crash. Many people watch hockey simply in hope of watching a fight. Traffic jams abound when there is the slightest form of accident because other drivers can't help but rubberneck looking for carnage. We have a nearly insatiable appetite for violence. Some would relish such telecasts, a fact which scares me. Friends and families of victims will watch to witness 'justice'. Some will watch to witness what they consider a state-sanctioned crime of the worst order. Others will watch out of simple curiosity. It is a disgusting option for sure but is it really any more violent than the contents of popular movies? Is it more violent than the news? There have already been (inadvertent and live) depictions of execution by terrorists (including beheading) on television and society managed to move on. I imagine that we'd manage to get past this proposed practice as well.
I guess I'm saying to let everyone stand witness to the practice of killing criminals. Perhaps, we will become so outraged when confronted with the reality of execution that we will turn around and finally end the barbaric practice. What a moral victory that will be! I mean, isn't it high time we moved beyond the Hammurabic Code? Sadly, as far as public budgets go, we'll be back at square one. I think this would be a small price to pay for an end to moral relativism and/or situational ethics.
Unless you are speaking to a pedophile, you are unlikely to find anyone sympathetic to those that use children to satisfy their perverse and unnatural urges. I will never call them 'needs', the term that pedophiles and sometimes medical practitioners use. Their lives would go on with equal quality without indulging in their habitual crime against humanity so it clearly isn't a need. In spite of the fact that these predators have no open allies, laws and courts fail to understand the seriousness of the crime and fail to impose penalties commensurate with the offenses.
This is even more true in Canada than in the United States. Recent high profile cases in Canada have resulted in pathetically weak sentences. Two years less a day. Five years, but out on parole long before then. When released, the offenders are free to move anywhere in the world to begin anew and little if anything is done to warn their newly adopted communities of the threat that has just descended upon them. So the cycle continues -- this is a virtual guarantee.
Unlike many other criminal behaviours pedophilia has proven almost completely resistant to therapy. The damage is too fundamental, affecting too many parts of the brain and too many aspects of the psyche to be repaired. In the absence of cure, I think the world would be satisfied by repression of the behaviour, but pedophilia will not be repressed. The irony is that some pedophiles are wracked with guilt because of their urges and actions and are still not able to stop. I guess this is why you almost never hear of one-time offenders. Pedophiles always seem to have a huge roster of victims by the time they are brought to temporary justice. Often allegations against them are made and they somehow wiggle free of any repercussions. It is only years and many victims later that they are finally made to pay for their deviance and predatory actions.
Some people think that pedophilia isn't a disease, at least not in the strictest sense. They paint it more as similar to a bad attitude or a simple lack of morals and ethics. Others say that it is the result of similar trauma experienced in their youth. This is garbage! It is not true that all pedophiles were abused themselves. Some do it spontaneously. Further, not every person who was victimized sexualizes children. I contend that these apologist theories are invented by pedophiles themselves. Also, if sexual abuse of children was simply a result of moral or ethical defect, why would so many pedophiles feel remorse? If they were truly morally bankrupt then they would see nothing wrong with their actions (see NAMBLA) and would instead claim to be the victims of persecution by a corrupt society. They would insist that children are supposed to be used in this fashion and those that don't do it are in fact the defective ones. Pedophiles with this view constitute a minority of the whole, not the majority, further proof that it is not merely the result of moral or ethical deficiencies.
So, why are these cancers not treated sufficiently seriously? Why are they not excised from society the way tumors are from a diseased body? The answer is simple. Money.
Short-sighted politicians, lawyers and judges, our lawmakers, are obsessed with money. The entirety of society is obsessed with money so this is not really that surprising. Still, we expect that people in those positions of power would be more morally upstanding. Instead, they follow the money, and in their opinion, child predation doesn't hurt the economy so it isn't that important. They couldn't be more wrong on multiple fronts. By their view, taking 'productive' members of society, i.e. the pedophiles, and placing them in jail hurts the economy and costs the State further money to house, feed and care for them while incarcerated. In their world view, it is a no-brainer. Penalties should be token attempts to appease an angry public so that they result in as little financial impact on the government's tight budgets. Our quiet complaints for longer sentences, which given the incredibly high occurrence of re-offending are the only logical way to protect the public's interest and safety, are ignored for financial reasons. These same politicians have no compunctions about wasting trillions on pork barrel spending or tax cuts for multinational mega-corporations and the wealthiest citizens (or in some cases to line their own pockets) but a hundred thousand dollars a year (at most) to keep a dangerous predator off the streets is too high a price to pay. It's pathetic and our tolerance of it is even more pathetic.
What lawmakers fail to understand is that the victims of these crimes are given a life sentence. They carry the scars of abuse their entire lives and you better believe that it keeps them from realizing their full economic potential. Millions of hours of productivity are wasted due to sick days, sometimes called mental health days, caused by the stress that they cannot escape. The fact that society seems to care so little makes this stress much, much worse. Each time a pedophile is slapped on the wrist the victims and their families (if they even know about the abuse) receive blows to the gut. Each time a pedophile is released or is found to have re-offended the victims suffer more than the criminal. The cost to the health care system for the scars of abuse is incalculable. Also, victims are often left with such despair that they believe that their only remaining course of action is to kill themselves. Suicide also has a negative economic impact. So, lawmakers' apathy and failure to examine the issue in stark detail leads them to believe that they are taking the financially prudent course of action, i.e. minimal consequences for pedophiles. And in doing so, they are actually hurting the economy. Another job well done by our elected officials!
Another indictment against the government and courts is that children are not adequately protected. The punishment doled out for a man who rapes a woman is almost always greater than what is levied against those that commit the same crime against children. (The gender of the child is not relevant.) How is this logical? Are crimes against children more palatable, tolerable or more understandable? Few people, if any, would suggest that children aren't more helpless, powerless and vulnerable than women, yet our protection of them is weaker. We like to call children "our future" but by our lack of detemination seemingly have no compunctions against exposing "our future" to the worst forms of abuse.
The only reason I can come up with for this illogical policy is that children cannot vote. Children cannot make politicians pay for their inaction. Sure, they grow up and eventually have the right to vote. I wouldn't be in the least bit surprised if their tendency to waive that right was much higher than in other populations due to complete disillusionment with the system. And who could blame them? Whether they grow up to vote or not politicians are banking on two outcomes. First, politicians hope that by the time child victims are old enough to vote they will be caught up in political ideology and will vote and lobby for reasons other than their nightmare experiences. Second, politicians are gambling that they will have left politics by the time the children are granted an electoral voice so no political price can be paid. In other words, by and large, politicians, like most human beings these days, will do every single self-interested thing that they think they can get away with and on the other hand will do nothing more for others than they absolutely must for survival. Under this microscope, we don't seem to be a very moral or ethical society. We hardly seem like a society at all! Where have civility and civilization gone?
In Penn State, a member of the athletic department staff has been accused of sexually abusing many boys over the past 15 years. This is terrible but is hardly international news. What makes this situation news is the fact that rumour of this activity has been floating around for almost all of the years in question! Assistant coach Sandusky 'retired' in 1999 at the age of 55. This is incredibly young for a college coach to retire. Actually, it is the prime of life in terms of coach careers. The first rumours of his clandestine activities came up just prior to his 'retirement'. This begs many questions. Did he retire or was he forced to resign? If the univeristy knew of these activities and forced the resignation/retirement doesn't that mean that they knew of the allegations? Further, while Sandusky was no longer an assistant coach at Penn State he still had full access to the university's campus and athletic facilities. Why? Sandusky was the leader of the children's charity he founded in 1977, The Second Mile (which it seems may have served as the vehicle for him to access children to prey upon). Was this sufficient reason to continue to allow Sandusky access at all levels? Why did the charity need access to college facilities? Aren't allegations cause enough to force the university to disavow all connections to the man? Or was this just Old Boys' Club mentality at its worst?
I'm going to point out what I consider a formality. Everything that has emerged falls under the category of allegations. Officially, until a court of law has determined his guilt Sandusky has done nothing wrong. Had there been one allegation, I would concur. A couple of days ago the number of boys that have made claims of abuse was reported as eight. Since then the number has grown reportedly to about 20. In my mind, with this many grievances it becomes difficult to maintain sterile objectivity and continue to maintain the innocence-until-proven-guilty-they-are-only-allegations posture. Almost impossible, actually. To say things don't look good is a huge understatement.
The results of the 1998 investigation are surprising given the fact that seemingly nothing was done. Sandusky admitted to having showered with boys and even to have hugged a boy while in the shower. Presumably both were naked at the time. He admitted that this was wrong and said he would no longer shower with boys. While it is true that hugs are not inherently sexual doesn't taking showers with boys and naked hugging speak of colossally bad judgment? Isn't this type of decision making cause to force the termination of whatever relationships allowed Sandusky access to boys in the first place. In this case, the campus polive and child welfare agency didn't think so. The fact that this matter was investigated primarily by campus police is ludicrous. Didn't anyone suggest that any campus organization lacked sufficient separation from the matter to be completely objective? One of the boys was identified as "victim 6" in the police reports. That means that in 1998 there were already at least 6 boys that had made allegations against Sandusky. The system completely failed these boys and all the boys since.
It has been suggested that Penn State is far too politically powerful in State College, PA to be held accountable for anything. Over the years it seems that these is cause to believe this. With the mess hitting the fan this past week the university has shown itself unused to, if not unable to, act decisively and ethically regarding this scandal. Last night they took a huge step in addressing that criticism by relieving both the university president and head coach Joe Paterno of duties. All that remains is for them to cancel the upcoming game, the three remaining games on the season, suspend the football program indefinitely and perhaps cancel the playoff game that is scheduled to take place in State College and they will have addressed matters to everyone's satisfaction. It's called damage control and ensuring the safety of the players, coaches and fans.
Everyone's satisfaction except apparently the students of Penn State. They demonstrated last night against the firing of coach Paterno. Paterno was made aware of the crimes that were taking place in the showers in 2002 when a graduate assistant reported having witnessed a sexual act between Sandusky and a boy. Paterno took this information to university administration. The university seems mostly to have buried the information. They did bar Sandusky from holding youth sports camps on campus, but did nothing when he merely relocated his camps to the university's Behrend campus, just outside Erie, PA, which continued until 2008. Paterno also seems to have done nothing after handing off to the university administration. At no point did his moral compass or even his curiosity compel him to follow up on his report to see what was happening. He was apparently satisfied that the matter as closed since Sandusky continued to have access to the university's facilities. Yesterday, Paterno said "I wish I had done more", and that the entire situation was "one of the great sorrows of [his] life."
In spite of logic, morality and Paterno's contrition, Penn State students demonstrated in protest of Paterno's dismissal. My reaction to this is to suggest that their parents immediately demand a total refund for all tuition paid over the course of these students' academic careers are Penn State on the grounds that they haven't learned anything! They are completely clueless. They are placing the good of the football program and the legacy of coach Paterno above the health and safety of at least 8 boys over the course of at least 40 counts of sexual impropriety. They somehow think that Paterno's dereliction of duty and failure to meet his moral obligations are not grounds for dismissal presumably since he officially met his legal obligations. The law is a strange thing. It is a living thing. Its development often lags behind the needs and desires of the society it is meant to serve. To argue that Paterno's satisfaction of his legal obligation allows him to wash his hands of all guilt is both naïve and offensive.
Obviously, crimes of this nature happen becomes criminals feel the need to offend and victimize others. But looked at from another viewpoint, crimes of this nature occur because we let them. On the one hand we rail against the crime and cry out for justice and/or punishment. Less often, we call for protection of children and less often still we call for compassion and understanding for the victims. When presented with vague evidence or some other indication of potential wrongdoing we tend to be evenly split.
Some of us act immediately. Those that have experienced the terror of this crime personally or secondarily flock to this banner as do most people who generally advocate on the behalf of children. The rest of us do what is easiest for us, which is nothing. In other words, we act solely in self-interest and laziness. "Don't rock the boat." "It's not my problem." "Let someone else do it." "It's probably not true anyway." "If it is true, it will come out without my action/intervention/sticking my neck out." Other motivators include disbelief. It is uncomfortable for us to think that the people close to us are bad or are doing bad things. That would reflect poorly upon us. After all, we chose to associate with these people -- if they are bad, we too must be bad, and that can never be admitted however true it might ring. In short, we make excuses. We come up with excuses to ignore our responsibilities and we all suffer as a result.
Tangent:
The back-story or origin behind the popular comic book character Spider-Man provides an allegory for this dynamic. Peter Parker, the man who has become Spider-Man uses his miraculous abilities to seek fame and fortune. He is presented with an opportunity to stop a burglar from stealing the money made from ticket sales and gambling on the wrestling matches in which he just competed. He was there to get paid for his performance. Instead of stopping the burglar, something he could have done with minimal effort given his new abilities, he gets out of the way and allows him to escape. This burglar goes on to kill a man while trying to make his getaway. That man turns out to be Peter Parker's uncle Ben Parker. By his own inaction, Peter had enabled the murder of his uncle. This is exactly what happens when we take the easy path and look the other way when wrongs occur, thus ignoring our moral responsibilities to look out for one another.
End tangent.
The bottom line is that each of us is 100% responsible for everything we do, or don't do. Further, we are completely responsible for all the consequences of our actions and inaction. No one would suggest that you can assume that other drivers on the road will look out for your safety -- it is up to you to assume 100% of the responsibility for your safety since you can count on others (eventually) failing to live up to theirs (intentionally or otherwise), putting you in mortal peril. This concept applies universally. Even Smokey the Bear had it right -- "Only you can stop forest fires." Don't wait for someone else to do it. If you have no qualms about letting others handle it you can rest assured that others will do the same allowing heinous and horrible things to happen. It is in our power to stop it, but only if we stop passing the buck. Politicians need to be pushed to do what is right, because what is tends not to be politically easiest.. So, go push! Force the powers that be, representatives that we elect to wield our power, to do what is right. Increase the penalties for crimes that are being taken too lightly.
In passing, I say the following without endorsing it. It is my attempt at thinking outside of the box. If the only way to protect society is to incarcerate offenders indefinitely, and this is deemed a budgetary impossibility there is one other option. We can turn our back on the Ten Commandments and other moral/religious imperatives and utilize the death penalty. It's a double-whammy. We kill, violating Commandment #5, and we judge harshly violating Matthew 7:1-2 ("Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you.") Oh, right. Many of us already utilize the death penalty. Ironically and hypocritically, it is often the case that the more fervently religious the person, the more likely they seem to support the death penalty.
Currently, the death penalty is even more expensive a proposition than life terms without the possibility of parole. The cost for state-appointed (and funded) lawyers and court time for near endless appeals and requests for clemency often dwarf the cost of incarceration. If we are going to kill criminals/people (and I don't think we should) there is a way to make it cost-neutral or even a money maker.
Televise it.
The Romans had the gore and violence of the Coliseum as a fate of choice for criminals and enemies of the State. The modern day equivalent is television. Put it on Pay-Per-View and recover the costs of applying the law by letting the private citizen pay the burden of those costs. There is no question this would attract an audience. Primarily the viewers would be proponents of the death penalty. Who better than they to foot the costs of execution? Executions the world over are already public. Clearly we don't object to people seeing state-imposed / state-sanctioned killing. How is airing it any different than admitting a gallery?
We flock to watch boxing and mixed martial arts. Some people watch auto racing hoping for the spectacle of a lethal crash. Many people watch hockey simply in hope of watching a fight. Traffic jams abound when there is the slightest form of accident because other drivers can't help but rubberneck looking for carnage. We have a nearly insatiable appetite for violence. Some would relish such telecasts, a fact which scares me. Friends and families of victims will watch to witness 'justice'. Some will watch to witness what they consider a state-sanctioned crime of the worst order. Others will watch out of simple curiosity. It is a disgusting option for sure but is it really any more violent than the contents of popular movies? Is it more violent than the news? There have already been (inadvertent and live) depictions of execution by terrorists (including beheading) on television and society managed to move on. I imagine that we'd manage to get past this proposed practice as well.
I guess I'm saying to let everyone stand witness to the practice of killing criminals. Perhaps, we will become so outraged when confronted with the reality of execution that we will turn around and finally end the barbaric practice. What a moral victory that will be! I mean, isn't it high time we moved beyond the Hammurabic Code? Sadly, as far as public budgets go, we'll be back at square one. I think this would be a small price to pay for an end to moral relativism and/or situational ethics.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)